RE: New 911

Author
Discussion

shoestring7

6,138 posts

247 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
No no no. REAL Porsches were made in a woodshed in Austria by men with hammers. Then the company sold out to commercialism and everything made since THEN has been mass produced...

SS7

>> Edited by shoestring7 on Tuesday 11th May 14:58

rico

7,916 posts

256 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
996 + bodykit + Cayenne interior + Pricerise = 997

GregE240

10,857 posts

268 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
rico said:
996 + bodykit + Cayenne interior + Pricerise = 997


No.

996 + active suspension + engine revisions + new gearbox + Cayenne interior + pricerise

Didn't you read the article?

rico

7,916 posts

256 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
Greg,

i did read the article. I just don't know why Porsche didn't just call this the 996 facelift... well i guess thats all it is.

I just wouldn't fancy buying a car that was going to be replaced by the 998 in about two years...

Witchfinder

6,250 posts

253 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
I like the front aspect, it is a return to the 993 look which I like. The interior looks OK, although will probably be better in black. IMHO, Porsche have never done truly brilliant interiors.

The rear end looks less appealing though! It hints of the Chrysler Crossfire (another car I don't like the rear end of!). Perhaps it'll look better with a GT3-style bodykit.

rico said:
I just don't know why Porsche didn't just call this the 996 facelift... well i guess thats all it is.
Marketing. "New model" sounds far more appealing than "facelift"

>> Edited by Witchfinder on Tuesday 11th May 15:16

rubystone

11,254 posts

260 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
John - it looks nothing like a Beatle, but a lot like a Beetle - take a look again.

The bonnet looks 356-esque but is clearly influenced by the GT and makes the PU look like an extra chin. The interior is just plain ugly as sin. Didn't I see a similar interior in Snoop's Huggymobile in Starsky & Hutch recently?

Shoestring - great comment

rich1231

17,331 posts

261 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
The article says 80%new, that is not a facelift!
Its a 911 for gawds sake, did you want it to look like one or a robin reliant?

domster

8,431 posts

271 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
The interior is sh1te. What's with the clock in the middle of the dash where your road angel/origin is meant to go? Is that where the compass was on the Cayenne???

Jeez. It's a great interior for a truck, and I'm sure it is a league ahead of Tommy Telford's iron bridge for build quality, but even so... in a 911? It makes me want to rush out and buy a 996 before they stop making them.

Exterior looks better tho'. Shame they didn't go for a rear reflector strip like the C4S, as that is what got me onto Porsches aged 11 years (911 turbo with P-O-R-S-C-H-E script... yum yum!).



>> Edited by domster on Tuesday 11th May 16:13

dds1

1,407 posts

259 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
the clock is actually a chronograph / stopwatch

domster

8,431 posts

271 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
Hmmmm.

It still looks incongruous stuck there, and with trackday timing being as it is, will probably be eff all use.

Muncher

12,219 posts

250 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
It might be better to drive, but they've taken a BIG step backwards appaerance wise. The 996 looks vastly better.

dds1

1,407 posts

259 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
I don't disagree at all Dom, can just imagine the 1st time someone crashes one while the stopwatch is running - the press will have a field day....(added to the fact that it looks crap too)

robbo64

299 posts

244 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
What about other models? Hopefully we will see more powerful, more heavy-spoilered variants of this new design(Turbo, GT2 & GT3 for example), because these extra additions might just hide some of the bodywork flaws. YES there are flaws. It looks(minus the Beetle lights) just like the old one. If you showed me a picture of this from behind I would think it was the outgoing model- there is a tiny difference.

Is everyone not getting a bit sick of this evoloution over revoloution thing?same old Porsche look(although it has sold well for umpteen years) is maybe looking a bit tired now. I put this down mainly to unimaginative designers and mass-produced Vectra-style demand for it. The reason the 911 is still popular is because it has had little competition and if it did come up against new rivals, with a smart, different look with performance to match, I think it would probably be shaking in it's 1970's boots.

Surely the 911 can be changed to look different(still Porsche)but sporty and just as good as it used to be. I say used to because it is just the same now as it was ten years ago(sorry, looks and interior taken into account, worse)

I really would have loved to have read this article to have found how the "new" Porsche was going to excite us and make us want one again.

Not to say that this won't sell-It's a 911, but if it had really tough opposition, I think that it would struggle. It's a shame that the MG SV hasn't took off to fight the 911(good comment before about the amv8).

Revoloution welcome in my opinion. Evoloution hasn't exactly been the best way forward for the new Golf has it? Maybe Porsche should learn from it's German counterpart...

granville

18,764 posts

262 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
A little bit like The Bionic Man (the character, not standard of acting, allow me to stress), the 911 simply gets more and more accomplished.

The most profitable car company in the world is still set up to produce fundamentally supreme super cars and one suffers self-denial to espouse otherwise.

That their repertoire has expanded is a corporate inevitability but should not lessen the sensation that is their general design savvy.

I love my anachronistic beetle and it has a certain place in the scheme of my fevered concept of the world's automotive terrain but a GT2 with a very bad attitude would undoubtedly be 'better' by several conceivable notions of the term.

Then again, the subjective elements of the decision making process are multifarious and it's all relative at the end of the day.

Must say, I've not really noticed this kind of heavy 'luddite effect' within the Ferrari ranks - would a 308 driver ever think to challenge the veracity of a 355 or 360's right to contemporary supremacy in the mid-mounted V8 stakes?

Von Reigelschlaus.







shoestring7

6,138 posts

247 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
Interesting point about evolution, but its clearly the Porsche way of doing things. I've been working though Karl Ludvigson's 3 volume 'Excellence was Expected' and this is a constant theme. Sometimes its a strength, sometimes not.

Think about it, in over 50 years of existence Porsche has only ever marketed one 'clean sheet of paper' design; the 928.

SS7

rubystone

11,254 posts

260 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
SS7 what about the 914 and the 924? Granted they started out as collaborations but neither was based on an existing floorpan.

captain honesty

152 posts

243 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
IMHO the only time a 911 looks half decent is with side skirts/front splitter and a huge fin on the back.
the basic shape is about as flowing as michelle mcmassive after a pie eating contest!
the interior is,well to put it fairly mildly....z...zz.....sorry just fell asleep there for some reason!
porsche can make attractive cars(carrera gt)but i guess unless you start over with a brand new design,you'll always be polishing a turd with the 911!

bob944

163 posts

244 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
Why won't Porsche admit when somethings dead. They tried to get rid of the bad idea of a rear engined car in the 80's but have continued to flog a dead horse since then. The original concept was rubbish and would have died then if it had not been in such a beautiful looking piece of machinery. All latest 911's handle and look like crap!

Ps central clock is the same as in my Ford ka! What style!

>> Edited by bob944 on Tuesday 11th May 20:52

JamieBeeston

9,294 posts

266 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
I must admit, I am glad they arent doing a GT3 in 997 guise, I will be rolling my order onto the 998, in an effort to get one of the very first off the line.

I would like to see some more Aerokitted Versions..




I want to see more like that.!


www.997tt.com/997/

for more Pix.

clubsport

7,260 posts

259 months

Tuesday 11th May 2004
quotequote all
Jamie the GT3 register guys seem to think there will be a 997 version of the GT3.