Is a McLaren 570s A Supercar?

Is a McLaren 570s A Supercar?

Author
Discussion

selym

9,544 posts

171 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2019
quotequote all
With all the talk of cars being supercars or not, if you are disappointed when no-one thinks your car is a supercar then you've bought it for entirely the wrong reasons.

jakesmith

9,461 posts

171 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2019
quotequote all
selym said:
With all the talk of cars being supercars or not, if you are disappointed when no-one thinks your car is a supercar then you've bought it for entirely the wrong reasons.
A lot of presumption in that statement. Arguing a point doesn’t mean that was the reason played any part in a decision that was made

selym

9,544 posts

171 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2019
quotequote all
jakesmith said:
selym said:
With all the talk of cars being supercars or not, if you are disappointed when no-one thinks your car is a supercar then you've bought it for entirely the wrong reasons.
A lot of presumption in that statement. Arguing a point doesn’t mean that was the reason played any part in a decision that was made
No presumption at all; does it matter to you, me or av185 what other people think of our cars? The term supercar neither enriches or takes away from the experience of owning it.
The fact that a lot of participants and defenders of certain models have that model in their 'my garage' is telling. It's not as though a car being called 'not a supercar' means it is automatically st does it?

jakesmith

9,461 posts

171 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2019
quotequote all
selym said:
No presumption at all; does it matter to you, me or av185 what other people think of our cars? The term supercar neither enriches or takes away from the experience of owning it.
The fact that a lot of participants and defenders of certain models have that model in their 'my garage' is telling. It's not as though a car being called 'not a supercar' means it is automatically st does it?
I can discuss something without being disappointed if the consensus doesn’t validate my choice as I didn’t make my choice on that basis. I can’t speak for others but imagine similar

Can you back up your ‘a lot of participants’ bit. Apart from myself and the perennially cheerful Mr AV does anyone else even have a dog in the fight? It’s a discussion forum isn’t it.

ETA Unless you’re referring to the person who went to look at one but didn’t buy it as the Audi salesperson told them it wasn’t a supercar. What a master of sales he was. Coming to The Apprentice soon.


Edited by jakesmith on Tuesday 3rd September 17:05

ghost83

5,478 posts

190 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2019
quotequote all

Pioneer

1,309 posts

131 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2019
quotequote all
jakesmith said:
ETA Unless you’re referring to the person who went to look at one but didn’t buy it as the Audi salesperson told them it wasn’t a supercar. What a master of sales he was. Coming to The Apprentice soon.
Actually it was my wife who was looking at buying one, not me. And she only asked the R8 specialist (who is also a sales guy) whether it was a supercar as I'd been chatting about it on the way up. She didn't actually give a damm what the answer was, she just wanted a nice car that was quick and looked good.

We get you bought an old R8 on a shoestring, privately to save a few extra £. And maintain it yourself. Excellent, this is great, true sign of a PH. Great bang-for-buck, great car. But this is really getting boring now ......................... how about just drive and enjoy

Pioneer

1,309 posts

131 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2019
quotequote all
Just read that back, quite a rude/blunt post for me. I'm slowly morphing into RL

selym

9,544 posts

171 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2019
quotequote all
Pioneer said:
Just read that back, quite a rude/blunt post for me. I'm slowly morphing into RL
I think 'drive and enjoy' was absolutely spot on. For what it's worth, I like 911s but an R8 (especially 1st version) really catches my eye.

jakesmith

9,461 posts

171 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2019
quotequote all
Pioneer said:
Just read that back, quite a rude/blunt post for me. I'm slowly morphing into RL
Maybe get your wife to give you a nice relaxing massage and calm down a bit Mr Angry Wasp. She should be compliant as you bought her a lovely sports car

Btw not sure where you get that I work on my car myself, that’s a fantasy, maybe like the 2 men at Hull Audi who subtly smiled at you? Sounds a bit ‘are you being served’ to me. Do you dress exuberantly perchance?

jakesmith

9,461 posts

171 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2019
quotequote all
Pioneer said:
From here smile Actually found some of your fault-finding and stereo mod threads quite interesting.
Well thanks very much
Enjoy your Lambo smile

AC123

1,116 posts

154 months

Wednesday 4th September 2019
quotequote all
Imagine being cross because your Audi TT is a sports car and not a supercar

selym

9,544 posts

171 months

Wednesday 4th September 2019
quotequote all
AC123 said:
Imagine being cross because your Audi TT is a sports car and not a supercar
Thread revival attempt - poor.

Superleg48

1,524 posts

133 months

Thursday 5th September 2019
quotequote all
r o n n i e said:
The GT1 was developed as a race car. Porsche made 20 road versions (each of which are pretty bespoke) to meet homogenisation racing rules.
Is that before or after the Pasteurisation rules are applied? Homologation is the word you are looking for. wink

selym

9,544 posts

171 months

Friday 6th September 2019
quotequote all
Superleg48 said:
r o n n i e said:
The GT1 was developed as a race car. Porsche made 20 road versions (each of which are pretty bespoke) to meet homogenisation racing rules.
Is that before or after the Pasteurisation rules are applied? Homologation is the word you are looking for. wink
It is the cream.

GT4RS

4,428 posts

197 months

Sunday 8th September 2019
quotequote all
jakesmith said:
Here's the 'non' supercar in question BTW. Its design and performance and pedigree are the embodiment of what the word 'supercar' means to 99.999999999% of the global population, the exception being 2-3 people on this forum






Looks like a super car to me!

Matty3

1,178 posts

84 months

Sunday 8th September 2019
quotequote all
av185 said:
jakesmith said:
The R8 is on a shared platform with a Lamborghini it’s far more special IMO. Park the 2 next to each other and do a straw poll of random passers by on which one is the supercar I bet you the R8 wins by some margin
Given that my lowly 991.2 GT3 (white, winged clubsport)) receives more attention than my 458 Italia (Grigio Titanium) it seems fairly clear that a GT2 RS would receive waay more attention than an R8.

Not that attention is a good thing, as we all know.
Just for my clarification av185 do you actually own a 570s ? - wink - I am sure I have a saved post that states you do?

av185

18,514 posts

127 months

Sunday 8th September 2019
quotequote all
Matty3 said:
av185 said:
jakesmith said:
The R8 is on a shared platform with a Lamborghini it’s far more special IMO. Park the 2 next to each other and do a straw poll of random passers by on which one is the supercar I bet you the R8 wins by some margin
Given that my lowly 991.2 GT3 (white, winged clubsport)) receives more attention than my 458 Italia (Grigio Titanium) it seems fairly clear that a GT2 RS would receive waay more attention than an R8.

Not that attention is a good thing, as we all know.
Just for my clarification av185 do you actually own a 570s ? - wink - I am sure I have a saved post that states you do?
I do it's the blue one I posted a pic of with my white GT3 some time back.

Don't actually rate the car so it is for sale although have someone on for it atm.

jakesmith

9,461 posts

171 months

Sunday 8th September 2019
quotequote all
av185 said:
I do it's the blue one I posted a pic of with my white GT3 some time back.

Don't actually rate the car so it is for sale although have someone on for it atm.
So it might not even be a super car by the sounds of things!

av185

18,514 posts

127 months

Monday 9th September 2019
quotequote all
jakesmith said:
av185 said:
I do it's the blue one I posted a pic of with my white GT3 some time back.

Don't actually rate the car so it is for sale although have someone on for it atm.
So it might not even be a super car by the sounds of things!
I agree.

And of course, neither is the R8:


Chris355

795 posts

196 months

Monday 9th September 2019
quotequote all
Just my opinion...

La Ferrari, P1, Porsche 918, Bugatti Veyron, etc ... Hypercars

Maclarens, Ferrari and Lambo (non limited/special editions) ... all supercars.

R8, Aston, Porsche, Maserati are sports cars (with a few exceptions eg Porsche 918).