ferrari or mclaren

Author
Discussion

dbs2000

2,689 posts

192 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
cayman-black said:
Good job we all like different things then.
Agree, the 360 for me is the much better looking car.

12pack

1,545 posts

168 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
Having recently gone to a 650s spider I am biased and still a bit in the honeymoon phase.
My observations on the McL:
-Amazing performance - lots of controllable power oversteer - great steering feel and turn-in
-clever suspension increases range of usability on poor roads where the others feel twitchy and unwieldy
-excellent forward visibility again makes it far more usable on challenging roads
-lightweight carbon tub - Lotus-like agility
-may not yet have the Italian cachet but all those Youtube videos of Mclarens pulling away from the Italians seem to have caught on at least with the younger crowd. Certainly more of a driver's car than a poseur.
-c'mon it has an air-brake!

As with all such cars, make sure you include depreciation and maintenance in your thinking (Was pretty significant on my V12V to be honest). Sweet spot likely a 3 year old car (with any initial niggles resolved) with extended warranty/service deal. NE dealers seemed quite willing to work with you.

bordseye

Original Poster:

1,986 posts

192 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
got to agree with that last sentence and its the reason why mclaren is on my shortlist.

V8Andrew

387 posts

162 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
Depends on why you are buying. If you don’t care about depreciation then buy the car you like most.
If depreciation worries you buy a Ferrari not a McLaren, or better still some sort of GT3 911.
Everything already said about McLaren costs is true having researched recently myself.
Personally if you don’t care about costs too much I’d up the budget a smidge and get a 650s, or a bit further and get a 458. Both are excellent, very different from each other.

PantsFire

519 posts

80 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
I've driven a 650s and a 570s and as driving experiences McLarens are a great, but everyone I know or have spoken to who has owned one has a story about reliability and/or depreciation and it would put me off a purchase. Literally before clicking on my pistonheads bookmark I was watching this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fbXT7rrLU0o

Upperworks

1,242 posts

152 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
Not at all biased, but having just got this 355 with a large chunk of change from 100k, I thoroughly recommend!


PantsFire

519 posts

80 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
Upperworks said:
Not at all biased, but having just got this 355 with a large chunk of change from 100k, I thoroughly recommend!

I've been eyeing manual 355 GTS's, for the Targa roof, for a while now, but they'll probably appreciate out of my price range before I can get one frown

The Surveyor

7,576 posts

237 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
Upperworks said:
Not at all biased, but having just got this 355 with a large chunk of change from 100k, I thoroughly recommend!

Nice that, really nice and all the better for not being red IMHO.

Upperworks

1,242 posts

152 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
The Surveyor said:
Nice that, really nice and all the better for not being red IMHO.
thank you, my requirements were not red or yellow (I know it's the classic colours, just too bright for me), Berlinetta, manual, carbon seats and challenge grill. This one ticked the lot, so I was really pleased I was able to snap it up.

AMVSVNick

6,997 posts

162 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
Upperworks said:
thank you, my requirements were not red or yellow (I know it's the classic colours, just too bright for me), Berlinetta, manual, carbon seats and challenge grill. This one ticked the lot, so I was really pleased I was able to snap it up.
I miss my 355 sooooo much. Challenge Grill rare on a manual yes

12pack

1,545 posts

168 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
AMVSVNick said:
I miss my 355 sooooo much. Challenge Grill rare on a manual yes
OTOH don’t miss my 355 at all. Great to own as a classic, but I like driving and it didn’t.

12pack

1,545 posts

168 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
PantsFire said:
I've driven a 650s and a 570s and as driving experiences McLarens are a great, but everyone I know or have spoken to who has owned one has a story about reliability and/or depreciation and it would put me off a purchase. Literally before clicking on my pistonheads bookmark I was watching this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fbXT7rrLU0o
Very old news about the first “high” production model in a country that has been conditioned to expect British cars to be unreliable.

Just to give an example of how things have changed, regarding the battery, all the newer cars come with conditioners and a convenient boot plug location with clear instructions to plug in if not used for a while, as well as indication on the dash of how much battery is left. I use the car only in the weekends, and I haven’t seen it drop below 100% so I haven’t bothered to plug in.

And if I believe the sales numbers US sales are growing the strongest.

Edited by 12pack on Tuesday 22 January 16:30