Kindle or Tablet or Notebook?

Author
Discussion

rene7

Original Poster:

535 posts

83 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
The Wife does a lot of reading - her birthdays coming up and I ws thinking of buying her a Kindle or maybe a 8 or 10" tablet or even a small notebook, so she'd be able to take several 'Books' with her when we're away from home.
Which is the best cheapest simplest option - I know nothing about E books, are most novels available easily for thhese devices?
Of course a Tablet or notebook have the advantage of net access which would be a Plussmile
TA

LordGrover

33,543 posts

212 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
If it's purely for reading, Kindle is peerless.

langtounlad

781 posts

171 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
Two Kindles in our family (one each) as well as a tablet.
Never read on the tablet, always the Kindle.
Far superior reading experience.

rene7

Original Poster:

535 posts

83 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
Sorry for this obvious Q - but how is the Kindle better than a tablet?

davek_964

8,818 posts

175 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
The advantage of being able to do other things on a tablet is nice, but the far far far greater battery life of the Kindle wipes that out.

If she reads a lot, get her the Kindle.

If you have prime, you can also 'borrow' one book a month for free (selected books but a pretty big range) and you can only read those on the Kindle, not a tablet.

ETA : to answer your question, the screen on the Kindle is better for reading. Much more like looking at paper than a glowing screen. Plus the battery life I mentioned.

FunkyNige

8,883 posts

275 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
rene7 said:
The Wife does a lot of reading - her birthdays coming up and I ws thinking of buying her a Kindle or maybe a 8 or 10" tablet or even a small notebook, so she'd be able to take several 'Books' with her when we're away from home.
Which is the best cheapest simplest option - I know nothing about E books, are most novels available easily for thhese devices?
Of course a Tablet or notebook have the advantage of net access which would be a Plussmile
TA
As has been said, if it's just for reading then then Kindle is the one to go for - the screen isn't pushing light towards you so there's no strain after reading at night.
Most (if not all) recent novels are available, if you take a look at the Kindle ebooks section on Amazon ( link) you can see how many are available and the cost (normally about the same as a paperback, sometimes a little more as you have to pay VAT).
The downside is that you're chained to Amazon and can only read books bought from there. Some of the other eReaders allow you to borrow books from local libraries.

I think the pressing question is - if your wife likes reading so much, why hasn't she got one already?

Hoofy

76,358 posts

282 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
Defo get the Kindle as per above - battery life, better reading ability.

However, I use my phone... to read books to me while I'm doing something else. I don't think a Kindle can do that.

sgrimshaw

7,323 posts

250 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
FunkyNige said:
The downside is that you're chained to Amazon and can only read books bought from there.
Not true.

You can load books / pdfs etc onto a Kindle obtained from elsewhere as long as the book is in a format supported by the Kindle, simplest way is to connect the Kindle to a PC, then simply drag and drop from PC to Kindle.

Another options is to use a piece of software called "Calibre". That makes it really easy and will convert e-books between formats if you need it to.

You can also email books and pdfs directly to the kindle.



tankplanker

2,479 posts

279 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
Defo get the Kindle as per above - battery life, better reading ability.

However, I use my phone... to read books to me while I'm doing something else. I don't think a Kindle can do that.
I think the older ones used to? But only the Oasis seem to now, but then you have to buy the audio book on audible first, which seems really cheeky to charge you twice.

If you use the Kindle app on your phone and sign with your amazon account any of the Kindles will sync your progress to your phone and vice versa. I've used that a few times when I want to carry on reading a book but forgot my Kindle for some reason.

sgrimshaw

7,323 posts

250 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
davek_964 said:
If you have prime, you can also 'borrow' one book a month for free (selected books but a pretty big range) and you can only read those on the Kindle, not a tablet.
If you have Prime, then Prime Reading allows you to read an unlimited amount from the Prime Library (which is a selection of around 1000 books/magazines).

You can read these on a tablet with the Kindle App.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/kindle-dbs/fd/prime-pr/re...

From memory, you can only have 10 titles "checked out" at a time.





davek_964

8,818 posts

175 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
sgrimshaw said:
davek_964 said:
If you have prime, you can also 'borrow' one book a month for free (selected books but a pretty big range) and you can only read those on the Kindle, not a tablet.
If you have Prime, then Prime Reading allows you to read an unlimited amount from the Prime Library (which is a selection of around 1000 books/magazines).

You can read these on a tablet with the Kindle App.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/kindle-dbs/fd/prime-pr/re...

From memory, you can only have 10 titles "checked out" at a time.
I think we're talking about different things?

I have Amazon Prime - which means I can use the Lending Library. I can "borrow" one book a month, and it must be read on an Amazon device (Kindle or Fire Tablet).
Prime Reading is a different thing, and I think you have to pay for that membership separately from the normal Amazon Prime membership? Much like Amazon Music - as an Amazon Prime member, you can listen to a limited music library for free - or (like me) you can pay another £80 and have access to a vast music library.

FunkyNige

8,883 posts

275 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
Prime Reading, you get this with normal Amazon Prime
Free with prime
Borrow 10 books at a time from a choice of 1000

Kindle Unlimited, you have to pay £7.99 a month
Unlimited borrowing of books
Unlimited audiobooks with Audible

There's also Kindle First where Prime members get a book free a month (from a choice of 6).

davek_964

8,818 posts

175 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
FunkyNige said:
Prime Reading, you get this with normal Amazon Prime
Free with prime
Borrow 10 books at a time from a choice of 1000

Kindle Unlimited, you have to pay £7.99 a month
Unlimited borrowing of books
Unlimited audiobooks with Audible

There's also Kindle First where Prime members get a book free a month (from a choice of 6).
OK, thanks. So Lending Library has a bigger pool of books, but more restrictions and is also free with Prime. Didn't know about Prime Reading - will take a look (although if there are only 1000 books I suspect I won't want 10 of them!).

WolfieBot

2,111 posts

187 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
Depends how she will use it.

Kindle if it's just reading, if for general day to day use a tablet is far more flexible.

I've just got a Kindle fire tablet for Xmas which is excellent for the price.

Though I also have a Kindle which I will continue to use at home as it has a superb battery, but the tablet will save taking 2 devices away.

V8mate

45,899 posts

189 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
My wife had an original Kindle. I got her a Fire HD 8 for her birthday just before Christmas and she is over the moon with it.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B01J94T0XU/

She says that reading experience is far improved on this device, and she loves that she can also do her FB and Twitter stuff on a screen that is much more accessible than her phone, but without the clumsiness of a larger tablet or laptop.

I got it for £50 rather than £80 during the Black Friday sales, but considering I paid £300 for my dad's 10" Galaxy tablet, I reckon this is still a bargain.

karona

1,918 posts

186 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
Reading on a tablet is uncomfortable anywhere except a shaded room, reflections and glare will very quickly make you wish you'd bought a Kindle.

ZesPak

24,429 posts

196 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
We have e-readers, tablets, smartphones,...
For reading, the e-readers are just great. We have a kindle, sister has a Kobo which is also very good imho (they also have a larger one if you're interested).
The screen is more like paper, so if you've got light, it doesn't need to light up to work. Battery life is measured in weeks instead of hours which is great if you're travelling through areas with no grid power.
Another point is, in the summer, outside, it reads just like a page. While a smartphone can get nearly unreadable in direct sunlight.
I think a decent one will be about 100 quid, also a lot less dear than a decent tablet when stolen/lost/damaged. Because of their plastic build they are also light and can stand drops and the like very very well.

Edited by ZesPak on Friday 19th January 14:14

sgrimshaw

7,323 posts

250 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
davek_964 said:
OK, thanks. So Lending Library has a bigger pool of books, but more restrictions and is also free with Prime. Didn't know about Prime Reading - will take a look (although if there are only 1000 books I suspect I won't want 10 of them!).
The 1000 changes ... and I think you might be surprised wink

ETA - There's some magazines as well.

Hoofy

76,358 posts

282 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
tankplanker said:
Hoofy said:
Defo get the Kindle as per above - battery life, better reading ability.

However, I use my phone... to read books to me while I'm doing something else. I don't think a Kindle can do that.
I think the older ones used to? But only the Oasis seem to now, but then you have to buy the audio book on audible first, which seems really cheeky to charge you twice.

If you use the Kindle app on your phone and sign with your amazon account any of the Kindles will sync your progress to your phone and vice versa. I've used that a few times when I want to carry on reading a book but forgot my Kindle for some reason.
Oh right. The Kindle app started crashing a year or so ago so I ended up using Google Play Books and buying books to read on there. Most books can be read out loud by the reader without needing to buy the Audible version.

JimbobVFR

2,682 posts

144 months

Friday 19th January 2018
quotequote all
rene7 said:
Sorry for this obvious Q - but how is the Kindle better than a tablet?
A proper kindle is a completely different screen technology to any tablet or phone. They call it e-ink and images will stay on screen without power.

Essentially it's much more eye friendly and more like reading a proper book instead of staring at a screen.

The Kindle name is also used for Amazon tablets, hence the distinction of a proper Kindle above.