Estate or hatch

Author
Discussion

macp

Original Poster:

4,060 posts

184 months

Saturday 11th June 2011
quotequote all
Just interested what others have done to resolve a similar issue I have now.We enjoy family holidays in and around the uk and now have two small dogs.There are three of us in the family so plus the dogs we are going to need some space.I would rather avoid an estate and 2-3k will not buy me anything particularly interesing anyway but would a large hatch with perhaps a roofbox suit ?

What do you people do ?

simoid

19,772 posts

159 months

Saturday 11th June 2011
quotequote all
I'd try it and see.

Don't put the dogs in the roofbox though!

HiAsAKite

2,358 posts

248 months

Saturday 11th June 2011
quotequote all
Similar problem, but one large dog, bought an audi a6 (c5) avant v6 biturbo for 3.5k, bags of room, very comfortable, 4WD and quick enough as a day to day car.. only downside is mpg, but can live with that for the other benefits..

Smaller engine petrol can be had cheaper, likewise non-hot Volvo.v70's

macp

Original Poster:

4,060 posts

184 months

Saturday 11th June 2011
quotequote all
So remember dont put dogs in roofbox, dont put dogs in roofbox biggrin

Yes petrol costs are also a kicker.

Because I also need a car for the shortish (8ml) commute to work I have also been considering a snotter and maybe a 3rd car for the family.Thats the problem I need one car to do everything but putting it all in perspective we go on holiday only twice maybe three times per year.

MC Bodge

21,725 posts

176 months

Saturday 11th June 2011
quotequote all
An estate car is useful for me on many occasions and there are no downsides compared with a hatchback.

edit: Other than the scarcity of used ones now that bl**dy MPVs are all the rage.


Edited by MC Bodge on Saturday 11th June 16:23

GEP

459 posts

217 months

Saturday 11th June 2011
quotequote all
Can't really fault my MK1 Focus estate as a daily hack.


dave_s13

13,815 posts

270 months

Saturday 11th June 2011
quotequote all
My 52 plate Volvo V70 D5 is for sale if your interested. A bit more than 3.5k though.

The ad is in the classifieds somewhere (ignore the price it's a tad optimistic). It's a blue 52 plate auto.

PM me if interested and I'll send you info.

Oh and we have a dog and a young un, loads of room in the Volvo. You can even get a longitudinal load divider so hounds can go in one half and luggage in t'other. One of them and a roofbox and you'll have loads of room.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

191 months

Saturday 11th June 2011
quotequote all
macp said:
Just interested what others have done to resolve a similar issue I have now.We enjoy family holidays in and around the uk and now have two small dogs.There are three of us in the family so plus the dogs we are going to need some space.I would rather avoid an estate and 2-3k will not buy me anything particularly interesing anyway but would a large hatch with perhaps a roofbox suit ?

What do you people do ?
This worked for me, plenty of room:



But equally I quite like things like the Subaru Impreza Wagon or Forrester or even an e30/e36 estate.

macp

Original Poster:

4,060 posts

184 months

Saturday 11th June 2011
quotequote all
Awesome love it biggrin

Seems as if your partner does to.

I have been trying to suggest to swmbo that what we need is one of these which to be fair she likes but is not sexed up about the price.


macp

Original Poster:

4,060 posts

184 months

Saturday 11th June 2011
quotequote all
Was just looking at the 2003 on shape vectra SRi which seem to have a mahoosive boot.Ive driven the 1.8 which I thought was quite nice but needed more grunt and would then be much nicer.The question is should one touch one with a bargepole?

Alternatively there are the offerings from Ford in the shape of the mondeo or Mazda 6 both of which also seem to be well endowed in the boot dept.

Edited by macp on Saturday 11th June 17:46