"Cheating DAYS"

Author
Discussion

Mr Trophy

Original Poster:

6,808 posts

204 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
Morning all,

As per above, do these work or not? Been strict over the last three weeks and had abit of a blow out day yesterday!

Was told that this is good because it kicks your body out of it's usual?

Cheers,

Hoofy

76,554 posts

283 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
Depends what you mean by "blow out". 20,000 calorie binge eat? Moderately over what your daily goal is?

The latter is supposedly to stop your metabolism slowing down; plus it's good for your motivation knowing you can eat the st you like if you fancy it. The toughest bit about full on diets is cutting out.

goldblum

10,272 posts

168 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
I had a vast curry last night,it was most excellent.All my body knows is that if I don't exercise it will store the extra kcals as fat. smile

Ordinary_Chap

7,520 posts

244 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
I do it every week, not because I need it but because I like doing it! If you do the right thing 85% plus of the time you should be fine unless your goal is less than 10% body fat.

Yesterday it was pizza and cider!

It will slow down weight loss and it isn't required but I don't mind slower results in return for more living!

BriC175

961 posts

181 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
Ordinary_Chap said:
I do it every week, not because I need it but because I like doing it! If you do the right thing 85% plus of the time you should be fine unless your goal is less than 10% body fat.

Yesterday it was pizza and cider!

It will slow down weight loss and it isn't required but I don't mind slower results in return for more living!
+1. I eat healthily in the week and don't drink alcohol, but come weekend, I eat and drink what I want. Combine that with exercise, and I'm where I want to be!

GBDG

896 posts

155 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
There's no hard and fast rule.

I tried having planned cheat days, but they were a disaster. I would binge like a mofo and eat way too much food.

So now I don't plan them, I just let loose a bit on social occasions. I've come to the conclusion that for me, home based cheat meals, where I buy bad food and basically binge, are a terrible idea.

I also think it's good to mix in a little bit of bad food into your daily diet. Say no more than 200 cals per day. But it teaches you to control your eating when you have a free choice.

Hoofy

76,554 posts

283 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
nuts

Cheat days doesn't mean do a crazy-arsed binge.

GBDG

896 posts

155 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
Cheat days doesn't mean do a crazy-arsed binge.
It's not supposed to, but when you follow a strict diet, your body goes into a "starvation" type psychological state. When you let that slip, you can adopt "hoarding" mental state, where you binge to store up on food for another anticipated "shortage".

Anyone who has the self control to have 1 day off a week and not go mental has my respect. But I've got enough personal experience, and spoken to enough people about it to know that going mental on cheat days is really common. I think most people will mess it up at first - it doesn't really matter. You just find what works for you in the end. smile

amare32

2,417 posts

224 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
Cheat days is essential as a means of reward for eating clean. I've gone from 15% bodyfat to 6% since Aug '11 and I eat very clean everyday but be a bit more relaxed eating some of the things I want at the weekend. It keeps you from going crazy being 100% strict with your eating regime plus you've got to live a little.

Obviously not to go and stuff 2 pizzas and eat a curry + 6 nan breads followed by 8 beers as a reward.

Hoofy

76,554 posts

283 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
GBDG said:
It's not supposed to, but when you follow a strict diet, your body goes into a "starvation" type psychological state. When you let that slip, you can adopt "hoarding" mental state, where you binge to store up on food for another anticipated "shortage".

Anyone who has the self control to have 1 day off a week and not go mental has my respect. But I've got enough personal experience, and spoken to enough people about it to know that going mental on cheat days is really common. I think most people will mess it up at first - it doesn't really matter. You just find what works for you in the end. smile
I know what is going on. You still need to not binge. It's not difficult.

Edit: if you do find it difficult, then you need to dig deeper and work out why. I have cheat days when I visit my family or go out with friends. I'm still trying to maintain a calorie deficit overall, though.

Edit 2: I mean, if I can go from 10 packets of crisps a day to 1 a fortnight...

Edited by Hoofy on Monday 21st May 09:25