Mods - question regarding rules and valuations
Mods - question regarding rules and valuations
Author
Discussion

FoxdieUK

Original Poster:

441 posts

171 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Hi mods,

Using http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/rules.htm as a reference, it states we agree not to;

6. Post links for the purposes of advertising or personal gain (including cars for sale) or cross-post across multiple forums. If you wish to advertise please use the classifieds or contact us directly. Please note that we do not allow members to advertise their own car, nor do we allow members to post asking for valuations on their current car (please use the classifieds as a guide).

I understand and respect those rules regarding the advertisement of vehicles, but it doesn't cover car parts nor accessories.

I'd like to get an appraisal on a set of alloy wheels, using the above rules this is how I interpret the wording;
  • I mustn't post a link in my post (as it may result in personal gain, although this too is questionable as I'm only asking for an appraisal?)
  • I don't wish to advertise them for sale, just seek appraisal, so I don't need to use the classified (which are for sales)
  • I am not advertising my car for sale, nor am I asking for a valuation of my car
It's a grey area as the rules are geared more towards vehicle sales rather than accessories / parts.

Additionally, they suggest using the classifieds as a guide, alloys for VXR8s are difficult to find as they're not a common fitment nor offset, that plus the fact there are many different brands of alloys, accurate appraisal using the classifieds as a guide is futile.

May be worth passing this back up the chain for them to clarify their position on parts / accessories too in the rules.

Thanks in advance smile

richie slow

7,570 posts

195 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
All valid points but to prevent arguments PH have a blanket ban on valuations

Edited by richie slow on Tuesday 4th March 14:11

H5V VE

615 posts

234 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Fair enough on valuations

But, what happens if you have broken one half of something that comes in pairs and is no longer available. Is it ok to post so see if anyone has then matching right hand side half of that item?

For example :-)

crisisjez

9,209 posts

236 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Rather than start a thread perhaps this would have been better addressed in the suggestions thread.
In a nutshell Richie is right.
However feedback is important to progress change so this s certainly an area for discussion at the meeting.

slippery

14,093 posts

270 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
This section of PH is moderated far more strongly than a number of the others now. There are pretty blatant wanted ads all over the TVR section for example, plus numerous trades people such as detailers and re-mappers self promoting in other sections. I'm certainly not saying that Richie and Jez are over zealous, it's more of an observation regarding the lack of following the rules elsewhere.

crisisjez

9,209 posts

236 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
slippery said:
This section of PH is moderated far more strongly than a number of the others now. There are pretty blatant wanted ads all over the TVR section for example, plus numerous trades people such as detailers and re-mappers self promoting in other sections. I'm certainly not saying that Richie and Jez are over zealous, it's more of an observation regarding the lack of following the rules elsewhere.
Another good point that should have been made in the suggestions thread. I think things are going to change within the PH forums.

mikeyb1987

2,358 posts

185 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
slippery said:
This section of PH is moderated far more strongly than a number of the others now. There are pretty blatant wanted ads all over the TVR section for example, plus numerous trades people such as detailers and re-mappers self promoting in other sections. I'm certainly not saying that Richie and Jez are over zealous, it's more of an observation regarding the lack of following the rules elsewhere.
Eg: wanted thread on the Merc forum:
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=...

richie slow

7,570 posts

195 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
I agree with all of the above. If we are to be seen as fair we need some guidance and latitude for discretion.

Apologies to the OP for my blunt reply earlier, time was limited at that moment. wink

PH have never entertained questioning of the rules. I'd like to see that change too.

slippery

14,093 posts

270 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
crisisjez said:
slippery said:
This section of PH is moderated far more strongly than a number of the others now. There are pretty blatant wanted ads all over the TVR section for example, plus numerous trades people such as detailers and re-mappers self promoting in other sections. I'm certainly not saying that Richie and Jez are over zealous, it's more of an observation regarding the lack of following the rules elsewhere.
Another good point that should have been made in the suggestions thread. I think things are going to change within the PH forums.
FWIW I actually wouldn't object to a more liberal approach. When a long standing PHer wants to buy or sell a car, I think it would be good if they were able to speak a bit more freely about it, as it would make PH a more interesting place. Instead, all that happens is members PM other members asking them to post links to their ads in the relevant threads, to avoid breaking the rules. All a bit contrived really. It's just frustrating for the people that stick to the rules, out of respect for a forum they enjoy using, when others don't. Especially when most of us law abiding citizens have been around for quite some time! I joined backed in the days of hsv.org.uk. A level playing field would be good, but moderating a forum as busy as this one is like trying to catch clouds! smile

TimDaciaBumdart

22,454 posts

241 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
How long is my piece of string?

S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
TimDaciaBumdart said:
How long is my piece of string?
I think your on a dot not a piece of string so not measureable. wink

Tattooboy

7,946 posts

209 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
TimDaciaBumdart said:
How long is my piece of string?
Check your tampon wink

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Tattooboy said:
TimDaciaBumdart said:
How long is my piece of string?
Check your tampon wink
rofl

Wyld Stallyn

2,056 posts

159 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
TimDaciaBumdart said:
How long is my piece of string?
Twice Half it's length biggrin

richie slow

7,570 posts

195 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
slippery said:
This section of PH is moderated far more strongly than a number of the others now. There are pretty blatant wanted ads all over the TVR section for example, plus numerous trades people such as detailers and re-mappers self promoting in other sections. I'm certainly not saying that Richie and Jez are over zealous, it's more of an observation regarding the lack of following the rules elsewhere.
I've just had a look at some of the other marques forums, they are littered with valuation , wanted and even for sale threads. It's seems that we are the only ones following the rules.

Edited by richie slow on Wednesday 5th March 10:38


Edited by richie slow on Wednesday 5th March 12:33

slippery

14,093 posts

270 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
richie slow said:
slippery said:
This section of PH is moderated far more strongly than a number of the others now. There are pretty blatant wanted ads all over the TVR section for example, plus numerous trades people such as detailers and re-mappers self promoting in other sections. I'm certainly not saying that Richie and Jez are over zealous, it's more of an observation regarding the lack of following the rules elsewhere.
I've just had a look at some of the other marques forums, they are littered with valuation and wanted threads. It's seems that we are the only ones following the rules. banghead
Absolutely. Quite ironic when you consider the moderating history of this little corner of PH! Even naming and shaming doesn't appear to be a problem elsewhere, even when the thread title should give a pretty strong clue that it's likely to happen. http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

slippery

14,093 posts

270 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
I don't think you are Richie. You've accepted a position that involves upholding the rules, whether you agree with them or not. To me, it just looks like PH need to either relax the rules, or increase the number of moderators. Perhaps they could take a fresh look at some of the current moderators and see if they are still as active as they should be?

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
richie slow said:
There's even loads of blatant advertising too!!

So, the question is..... are they being muppets or are we?
I don't think that's so important. Moreso is the fact that Raving was banned for so long, for a contravention that seems rife.

Still, if there's no favouritism in this area, then there's no advantage for anyone.

crisisjez

9,209 posts

236 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Trust me when I say I am aware of all this and am attempting a fix.
Sometimes, as with Raving, it takes time but pease bear with me. When I have news I shall share it with you all.

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
crisisjez said:
Trust me when I say I am aware of all this and am attempting a fix.
Sometimes, as with Raving, it takes time but pease bear with me. When I have news I shall share it with you all.
I don't envy you your task. If you point out other areas where the rules are lax, then there's a chance that you'll alienate the moderators of those areas from your/our cause.