What3Words

Author
Discussion

HorneyMX5

Original Poster:

5,309 posts

151 months

Monday 22nd February 2016
quotequote all
I couldn't find a head on this but this seems like a genuine game changer for addressing service and sat nav accuracy.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3458234/Th...

https://map.what3words.com

GreigM

6,728 posts

250 months

Monday 22nd February 2016
quotequote all
HorneyMX5 said:
I couldn't find a head on this but this seems like a genuine game changer for addressing service and sat nav accuracy.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3458234/Th...

https://map.what3words.com
Can't really see this being adopted by anyone - ever.

It does nothing for accuracy (by definition), its inefficient to store and you need to know the 3 completely random words for the place you want to go - and in most cases to find the 3 words you'll have to have a GPS located device in your hand to retrieve the 3 words....when you already have the GPS device in your hand which gives you more accurate coordinates.

The only genuine use case is when a drunk stumbles into a cab and shouts "sucks.hairy.balls" repeatedly at the driver, instead of just giving their address.

What a waste of VC funding.

HorneyMX5

Original Poster:

5,309 posts

151 months

Monday 22nd February 2016
quotequote all
GreigM said:
HorneyMX5 said:
I couldn't find a head on this but this seems like a genuine game changer for addressing service and sat nav accuracy.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3458234/Th...

https://map.what3words.com
Can't really see this being adopted by anyone - ever.

It does nothing for accuracy (by definition), its inefficient to store and you need to know the 3 completely random words for the place you want to go - and in most cases to find the 3 words you'll have to have a GPS located device in your hand to retrieve the 3 words....when you already have the GPS device in your hand which gives you more accurate coordinates.

The only genuine use case is when a drunk stumbles into a cab and shouts "sucks.hairy.balls" repeatedly at the driver, instead of just giving their address.

What a waste of VC funding.
I think you missed the point. It's to work with GPS and to replace or work along side address data. We have postcodes in this country which are pretty good for accuracy down to a part of a street. This allows accuracy to within a 3m square. Now apply that to places like Eire where they have no postcodes and suddenly you have a very accurate addressing system your GPS device can you to navigate you to.

I work in an industry where accurate location data is paramount to creating efficiencies in the operation. Using this kind of accuracy teamed with good Nav software could save £1000s if not 10,000s a year to some business.

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

199 months

Tuesday 23rd February 2016
quotequote all
saw it when it first launched, had a token of interest for a while, but then meh.
may be useful if im travelling around the world in convoy and want to arrange meet up points but cant be bothered to name a place or the lat and long, or just bloody email a google maps pin


useful here where not a single property has an address or even a street name



also here



and here

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3171114/Am...

they've got a whole generation of junk-mail to catch up on... welcome to the world!


no so much use here in the uk with addresses and internet and all.



Crush

15,077 posts

170 months

Tuesday 23rd February 2016
quotequote all
Could be fantastic for couriers.

Places like Hereford have a lot of rural properties with no road names. They were a nightmare to try and find (especially when the owners couldn't be arsed to advertise the name of their home irked )

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

199 months

Tuesday 23rd February 2016
quotequote all
they also cant be arsed to use w3w.

doesn't really work if only one person uses it


would be more use addressing the rest of the solar system, get established there before its actually useful

Dave.

7,380 posts

254 months

Tuesday 2nd April 2019
quotequote all
Only just clocked on to this (yes I know) due to a story in the local rag.

So yeah, great for alerting the emergency services to your location if you don't know where you are.

Would be handy for couriers as previously mentioned, but has it been picked up my them?

Thinking of sticking our w3w in the instructions bit for deliveries, as our house is named and on a 4mile long road.

Dave.

7,380 posts

254 months

Tuesday 2nd April 2019
quotequote all
52GR+2V

Doesn't quite roll off the tongue does it?

Compared to "smooth.tracks.trains" (yes I know), especially when in a panic or at the side of a windy motorway, etc.

ReallyReallyGood

1,622 posts

131 months

Tuesday 2nd April 2019
quotequote all
The problem with it is it's yet another proprietary technology that no-one other than themselves knows how it works and requires royalties to use at scale. No thanks!

karma mechanic

730 posts

123 months

Tuesday 2nd April 2019
quotequote all
Dave. said:
52GR+2V

Doesn't quite roll off the tongue does it?

Compared to "smooth.tracks.trains" (yes I know), especially when in a panic or at the side of a windy motorway, etc.
Reciting 52GR+2V over a phone to someone has a number of possible transcription errors, especially with noise as above. The w3w phrases are deliberately arranged so that any error is obvious, such as pointing to Uzbekistan instead of the M25. Having said that it does seem like it is dead in the water.

Russ35

2,492 posts

240 months

Tuesday 2nd April 2019
quotequote all
It is slowly being taken up, Merc have it in their cars, Ford and Range Rover are supposed to be signed up. Tom Tom announced last year that it would be added to their sat navs (no sign of it yet).. Navmii have it in thier sat nav software.

I suppose the problem is that most of the developed countries have pretty good addressing and very few people need accuracy to 3m unless like mentioned above you live out in the sticks where postcodes cover a long road/area and nothing is numbered. And I suppose in the less developed countries how many of the general population have the technology to make use of w3w.








Stan the Bat

8,935 posts

213 months

Tuesday 2nd April 2019
quotequote all
Was mentioned on BBC last week where someone used it to notify police of something out in the wilds of Somerset.

Snubs

1,177 posts

140 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2019
quotequote all
It seems to me a good idea in principle. I was trying to find an office in Birmingham yesterday and had the full address, post code and the name of the company in the office. Could i find it? Could i ***k. The postcode covers at least 20 street numbers, only a couple of the buildings themselves were numbered as they were predominantly shop frontages and it just so happened that the office i was looking for was on the corner, so whilst the address was '4 Hills Road' or something like that, the building just said 'Hills Court' on the outside. Then the business name wasn't on the list of businesses behind reception on the inside......

The point being, w3w would have given a much less ambiguous description of the location and i wouldn't have spent yesterday morning wandering up and down a street in the rain!

Dave.

7,380 posts

254 months

Thursday 4th April 2019
quotequote all
I reckon if Apple/Google bought into this (or developed their own similar thing) people would lap it up.


Fetchez la vache

5,574 posts

215 months

Thursday 4th April 2019
quotequote all
Dave. said:
I reckon if Apple/Google bought into this (or developed their own similar thing) people would lap it up.
Absolutely.

GPS states my postcode is over half a mile away. We haven't got a road name, and the house name isn't on the road either - and I don't particularly want it.

Couriers love us biggrin. On the plus side we now tend to know all the couriers by name and we never have any trick or treaters, or jehova witnesses...

I can definitely see the benefit of w3w.

robbieduncan

1,981 posts

237 months

Thursday 4th April 2019
quotequote all
How are the words chosen? Can you complain if you get three you don’t like? I’d not want “chav scum here” for example!

Dave.

7,380 posts

254 months

Thursday 4th April 2019
quotequote all
Seemingly random, from "the dictionary" with offensive and ambiguous words removed. Like there and their, etc.

Quite interesting once you read into it a bit deeper.

Words cannot be changed as it's "offline" so you can't be changing things otherwise it won't be as accurate til everyone is updated to the latest.

robbieduncan

1,981 posts

237 months

Thursday 4th April 2019
quotequote all
Dave. said:
Seemingly random, from "the dictionary" with offensive and ambiguous words removed. Like there and their, etc.

Quite interesting once you read into it a bit deeper.

Words cannot be changed as it's "offline" so you can't be changing things otherwise it won't be as accurate til everyone is updated to the latest.
I hope they look at the initialisation too. I’d not want CUM or ASS as examples of the possible initialisations from 3 words

Edit: instead of asking silly questions I went and played with the map (https://map.what3words.com/) myself to see how it worked. My house (not exceptionally large) has enough frontage to the street to let me choose from at least 20 squares (probably more to the middle of the street). Help by our road being diagonal on the map. So even if one was something I didn’t like I could choose another. Unless you live in a 3m square you should have some choice!

Edited by robbieduncan on Thursday 4th April 08:54

Dave.

7,380 posts

254 months

Thursday 4th April 2019
quotequote all
Yup, pretty much...

One of the comment on the Play Store, he wanted each 3x3 square divvying up into smaller squares cos his fence ran through the middle of the squares and thinks the emergency services won't be able to find him.... hehe

Glasgowrob

3,246 posts

122 months

Thursday 4th April 2019
quotequote all
our taxi dispatch software supports it,

of the hundred of bookings every week no customer ever has used what 3 words to book their cab.


really needs someone like google and apple o integrate it into their maps before the public will show any interest