£5k, short term investment?

£5k, short term investment?

Author
Discussion

TheAngryDog

Original Poster:

12,422 posts

211 months

Thursday 10th August 2017
quotequote all
I have £5k to invest for a period of 2 to 3 years depending on how other things go.

I currently have this in a savings account with nets me around 1% interest (more than my ISA).

I am sure that there is a better place for this, but not sure where that is. Any recommendations? Thanks.

GR_TVR

721 posts

86 months

Thursday 10th August 2017
quotequote all
Over that period look at banks offering the best interest rates.
For example, nationwide flex direct offers 5% on £2.5k for a year. You can then also use a linked saver at 5%, but you can only put in an amount per month, not in one go, so the headline interest rate isn't on the full amount.

Other banks do similar things so take a look, Tesco 3% on £3k for example.

You'll probably have to move things around each year as most rates are for 12 months only.

Viper

10,005 posts

275 months

Thursday 10th August 2017
quotequote all
stocks and shares ISA

GR_TVR

721 posts

86 months

Thursday 10th August 2017
quotequote all
Viper said:
stocks and shares ISA
I'd be looking at a minimum 5 year timeframe for this option.

Viper

10,005 posts

275 months

Thursday 10th August 2017
quotequote all
picking a few decent funds for ISA is the key, mine are currently 20% and 15% so far this year

Even a 3 year term, on a small investment has got to be worth a try with the lowly being rates offered elsewhere

Edited by Viper on Thursday 10th August 21:38

sidicks

25,218 posts

223 months

Thursday 10th August 2017
quotequote all
Viper said:
picking a few decent funds for ISA is the key, mine are currently 20% and 15% so far this year

Even a 3 year term, on a small investment has got to be worth a try with the lowly being rates offered elsewhere

Edited by Viper on Thursday 10th August 21:38
Only if you can afford to accept a 10-20% loss on your investment!

colin79666

1,853 posts

115 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
NS&I investment growth bond at 2.2% if you can leave it 3 years although it is taxable and only 3k max can go in.

As above stocks and shares is really a longer term bet. Over 3 years you could be lucky but equally you could lose a chunk.

tharriso

108 posts

127 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
Funding Circle

sidicks

25,218 posts

223 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
tharriso said:
Funding Circle
Only if they can afford the downside risk, for reasons mentioned above!

jzbc

4 posts

82 months

Saturday 12th August 2017
quotequote all
Why not hedge your bets and split your funds over multiple investments?

Funding Circle offer 50 quid cash back with an invitation and I agree that the 5% Nationwide deal is fantastic (I have it myself, but there's a caveat - you have to pay in 1k per month, although it's no problem to move it out again to another account after a few days!)

2.5K in each gives you a guaranteed return of 5% over a year on half your investment, an instant 2% return on the other (50 pound cashback for 2.5K investment) with a potential return of 10%. In my experience (only of a year) just a fraction of FC loans default, and I'm in profit so far at over 8% on 9K biggrin but maybe I'm just lucky! :/

The Funding Circle ISA (IFISA) will also be available soon, but not just yet. Not that 5K will attract tax, but if you get bitten by the p2p bug then it's worth knowing wink

Edited by jzbc on Saturday 12th August 09:41


Edited by jzbc on Sunday 13th August 11:51

FredClogs

14,041 posts

163 months

Saturday 12th August 2017
quotequote all
Over 3 full years you'll be very very unlikely to not beat inflation and savings rates in a conservatively managed global equity fund concentrating on high value companies, something like Fundsmith. Or a global tracker, just stay invested and don't lose your bottle if it takes a dip.


Jon39

12,952 posts

145 months

Saturday 12th August 2017
quotequote all

FredClogs said:
Over 3 full years you'll be very very unlikely to not beat inflation and savings rates in a conservatively managed global equity fund concentrating on high value companies, something like Fundsmith. Or a global tracker, just stay invested and don't lose your bottle if it takes a dip.

2017 is the 30th year of me being an equity enthusiast, however, I would not suggest equities to the OP.
OP states 'for a period of 2 to 3 years'.

It breaks one of the golden rules, to invest in equities with any intention of withdrawing funds after a specific short-term period.
If your withdrawal time coincides with a market fall and you have to sell at a loss, you will regret ever getting involved (as many novice investors discover unfortunately).






Edited by Jon39 on Saturday 12th August 19:04

jzbc

4 posts

82 months

Sunday 13th August 2017
quotequote all
jzbc said:
Why not hedge your bets and split your funds over multiple investments?

Funding Circle offer 50 quid cash back with an invitation and I agree that the 5% Nationwide deal is fantastic (I have it myself, but there's a caveat - you have to pay in 1k per month, although it's no problem to move it out again to another account after a few days!)

2.5K in each gives you a guaranteed return of 5% over a year on half your investment, an instant 2% return on the other (50 pound cashback for 2.5K investment) with a potential return of 10%. In my experience (only of a year) just a fraction of FC loans default, and I'm in profit so far at over 8% on 9K biggrin but maybe I'm just lucky! :/

The Funding Circle ISA (IFISA) will also be available soon, but not just yet. Not that 5K will attract tax, but if you get bitten by the p2p bug then it's worth knowing wink
I should note that p2p isn't as risky as it sounds smile according to FC:

Funding Circle said:
- Lend to 100+ businesses
- Lend no more than 1% of your total to each one
Every investor who has followed these two steps has earned a positive return. 92% have earned 5% or more. Correct as of 1st April 2017.
If default is a serious concern then an investor can always stick with A+ (safest) loans to lessen their exposure..

audidoody

8,597 posts

258 months

Tuesday 15th August 2017
quotequote all
tharriso said:
Funding Circle
I invested some proceeds of a house sale into P2P lending 18 months ago (FC, Zopa, lending works)/.

Funding Circle was BY FAR the worst. Put in £15,000. Most gains lost to BAD DEBT and fees. and these were A+ loans (see below).

Fortunately I got my capital out within a couple of days.

The best performer was Zopa. No bad debt. Minimal fees. And very easy to transfer in and out.



Edited by audidoody on Tuesday 15th August 11:28

sidicks

25,218 posts

223 months

Tuesday 15th August 2017
quotequote all
audidoody said:
I invested some proceeds of a house sale into P2P lending 18 months ago (FC, Zopa, lending works)/.

Funding Circle was BY FAR the worst. Put in £15,000. Most gains lost to BAD DEBT and fees. and these were A+ loans (see below).

Fortunately I got my capital out within a couple of days.

The best performer was Zopa. No bad debt. Minimal fees. And very easy to transfer in and out.

Edited by audidoody on Tuesday 15th August 11:28
I assume that Funding Circle have their own (internal) loan rating approach which is inconsistent with the official ECAI rating agencies, so that an A+ loan on Funding circle is in no way compatible with an A+ compote bond rated A+ by S&P?!

I imagine that this is done deliberately to confuse less informed investors?

edited to add this last comment certainly wasn't directed at you, audidoody!

Edited by sidicks on Tuesday 15th August 16:08