Weed Killer?

Author
Discussion

f13ldy

Original Poster:

1,432 posts

202 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
Before I stick a membrane down, what is the strongest off the shelf weedkiller I can purchase?

Astacus

3,392 posts

235 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all


In general the best all round garden weedkiller is Glyphosate. It will kill pretty much every thing and will biodegrade on contact with soil. This means anything else you plant won't get killed off. Also it gets translocated to the roots and kills them too so the plant doesn't come back again two weeks later.smash

f13ldy

Original Poster:

1,432 posts

202 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
Astacus said:
In general the best all round garden weedkiller is Glyphosate. It will kill pretty much every thing and will biodegrade on contact with soil. This means anything else you plant won't get killed off. Also it gets translocated to the roots and kills them too so the plant doesn't come back again two weeks later.smash
Is it available from all good stores?

Astacus

3,392 posts

235 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
f13ldy said:
Astacus said:
In general the best all round garden weedkiller is Glyphosate. It will kill pretty much every thing and will biodegrade on contact with soil. This means anything else you plant won't get killed off. Also it gets translocated to the roots and kills them too so the plant doesn't come back again two weeks later.smash
Is it available from all good stores?
YUP any garden center...homebase etc

Lots of different trade names, check th edetails on the pack, they have to say what the active ingrefient is

Simpo Two

85,735 posts

266 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
Glyphosate is a total non-residual weedkiller. In short, it kills everything but as stated does not stay to deal with any successive growth.

If you want something to stay active in the soil and bump off new seedlings as well, look for a total residual product - often called 'Path and Drive' or 'Hard Surface' weedkillers.

The Student

17,306 posts

172 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
Glysophate will be your best bet. Tradenames; Roundup and Gallup are generally preferred.

http://www.progreen.co.uk/index.php?c=55

If you have any good sized weeds best to run a grass cutter over them and wait for new shoots to start growing, then knock it all down with roundup. Big weeds can take a bit to die. Dont do it before it rains, takes about 3 to 4 hours to absorb properly, and watch any drift. Mrs Muggins' prize geraniums will be just as affected as the weeds you want to kill! Oh, and mix up a good strong dilution!

AndyAudi

3,058 posts

223 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
I'm trying to remember the name of the stuff, it's something like "tric" (not sure if is banned now) but put some of it down and nothing will grow there for a years. If you can't find that you can get some granualar stuff to put down, path clear type stuff.

Glyposate previously mentioned will only kill stuff that is already growing (ie not the seeds that are yet to sprout), although it will go down to the roots unlike some weedkillers which just kill the bits they touch.

Agricultural stores are the place to get stuff like this

Simpo Two

85,735 posts

266 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
AndyAudi said:
Agricultural stores are the place to get stuff like this
Technically no, unless you have the appropriate qualifications. If you're Joe Punter, you're supposed to go to a garden centre. Pesticides for agrochemical use are much more concentrated and can be much more toxic (different active ingredients) - ie not idiot-proof!

eldar

21,867 posts

197 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
AndyAudi said:
Agricultural stores are the place to get stuff like this
Technically no, unless you have the appropriate qualifications. If you're Joe Punter, you're supposed to go to a garden centre. Pesticides for agrochemical use are much more concentrated and can be much more toxic (different active ingredients) - ie not idiot-proof!
True, but the agricultural stuff is about 20% of the shed prices, and can be mixed a little stronger (I mean a little, 10%) and works far better. You do need to be cautions and sensible.

racing green

537 posts

174 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
I think what Simpo means is that if you buy Roundup from a trade supplier it will be for professional use and be much stronger- hence requiring certificates (spray license P1 and P5/6) whereas the stuff in the garden centre is much watered down though still lethal!! Recommend wearing rubber gloves (not marigolds!), gum boots, eye protection and be fully clothed (seen idiots do it in shorts before!). To be quite honest unless the surface is a hard one like a drive or paving then it is easier and better to weed them out. My personal favorite is to strim the bacensoredards into submission on hard surfaces and hoe my beds and borders.

AndyAudi

3,058 posts

223 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
eldar said:
Simpo Two said:
AndyAudi said:
Agricultural stores are the place to get stuff like this
Technically no, unless you have the appropriate qualifications. If you're Joe Punter, you're supposed to go to a garden centre. Pesticides for agrochemical use are much more concentrated and can be much more toxic (different active ingredients) - ie not idiot-proof!
True, but the agricultural stuff is about 20% of the shed prices, and can be mixed a little stronger (I mean a little, 10%) and works far better. You do need to be cautions and sensible.
If your sensible about things of course. As an aside there are now very little products available which are classed as toxic (old skull & bones warning logo) as they keep phasing them out.

RizzoTheRat

25,233 posts

193 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
For good results with glysophate you need to spray then leave it a week or 2 to work it's way down to the roots. If you want a more persistant result try sodium chlorate, that should stop things growing back for several months.

Escort2dr

3,619 posts

202 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
racing green said:
I think what Simpo means is that if you buy Roundup from a trade supplier it will be for professional use and be much stronger- hence requiring certificates (spray license P1 and P5/6) whereas the stuff in the garden centre is much watered down though still lethal!! Recommend wearing rubber gloves (not marigolds!), gum boots, eye protection and be fully clothed (seen idiots do it in shorts before!). To be quite honest unless the surface is a hard one like a drive or paving then it is easier and better to weed them out. My personal favorite is to strim the bacensoredards into submission on hard surfaces and hoe my beds and borders.
Nearly... it's PA1 and PA6 (for knapsack application). We would not supply ag product to a home and garden user though.

The other poster mentioned Trik [sic] which he rightly said is a quite persistent residual, though Chikara seems to be very popular now. Neither of which are suitable for this situation IIRC as H&G isn't a label use AFAIK.

Escort2dr

3,619 posts

202 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
eldar said:
True, but the agricultural stuff is about 20% of the shed prices, and can be mixed a little stronger (I mean a little, 10%) and works far better. You do need to be cautions and sensible.
I did a comparison once - genuine Roundup for the garden was £15/litre @ 72g/l strength IIRC. Generic glyphosate for ag use at the time was £40 for 20 litres - but it was 360g/l...

Four Cofffee

11,800 posts

236 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
I have used a strong mix of sodium chlorate under tarmac and gravel as it kills it, and stops any new seed germinating. I think it sits in the soil, so nothing wilm drow. I still use it in a sprayer for the cobbles on my drive, and at the foot of walls to stop anything growing in the gap.

Simpo Two

85,735 posts

266 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
I believe sodium chlorate was banned about a year ago.

The Student

17,306 posts

172 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
Escort2dr said:
Nearly... it's PA1 and PA6 (for knapsack application). We would not supply ag product to a home and garden user though.

The other poster mentioned Trik [sic] which he rightly said is a quite persistent residual, though Chikara seems to be very popular now. Neither of which are suitable for this situation IIRC as H&G isn't a label use AFAIK.
Cant it still be used as an off label application though?

Escort2dr

3,619 posts

202 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
Just checked and Trik is revoked anyway.

Chikara is approved for hard surfaces and non-cropped areas. I can supply this to anyone who has a farm holding number.

If, by off-label, you mean there is a SOLA... no, there aren't any for Chikara.

There are some sodium chlorate products still approved, but they are due to be revoked very shortly (weeks).

Edited by Escort2dr on Saturday 17th April 13:28

bitwrx

1,352 posts

205 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
Glyphosate only really works on
stuff that is actively growing. Good at this time of year. Not so handy mid winter.

mrsxllifts

2,501 posts

200 months

Sunday 18th April 2010
quotequote all
I by the off the shelf 'mix at home' type glyphosate but I appear to miss-read the label each time and make it double strength. Its the only way to keep the thorny things out of the garden.