Which car insurance do you use, NY state

[satans worm]

So as the question implies , I bought an Audi s5 5 years old last May and paid progressive the handsome amount of 1750 usd for 6 months.
It hurt a bit, given I’m a 46 year old who has had a driving license for 29 years, but I get it, and m an unknown risk etc.
People told me not to worry, it will halve when I renew( note friends, not progressive) however now at renewal, and it’s actually increased 100!
I tried geico, got it 200 less but still not the heavier discount I was hoping for.
Is this normal? Any other insurance companies you guys can recommend?
Thanks!