Taskmaster

Author
Discussion

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Wednesday 26th April 2017
quotequote all
New series started last night.

Hugh Dennis, Joe Lycett, Lolly Adefope, Mel Giedroyc, Noel Fielding.

Thought it a bit flat, has yet to achieve the heady heights of ridiculousness as previous series.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Sunday 7th May 2017
quotequote all
Clearly Noel Fielding is something of an artist, and not just a piss artist. Didn't realise he was an artist in his own right.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Wednesday 10th May 2017
quotequote all
Didn't like Noel Fielding much in the things he has done previously, mainly arsing about on quiz shows like 9 out of 10 cats and Big Fat Quiz etc, but having seen him on Travel Man, where he behaved impeccably and now on here, quite warming to him. He might be quite good on C4 Bake off.

Anyway agree with above, it would have been nice to see a good solution to that fish bowl challenge as nobody really figured it out, and the whole editing slant was failure by muppets who don't read the exam paper.

Secondly, does Al Murray live very close to that house where they film the tasks? How did he get there in 10 minutes for Joe's camouflage test?

Thirdly, remember the first show where Mel had to get juice out of a lemon, she was doing that with one odd black shoe. She's been wearing one odd shoe on every episode, is this some long running gag, or do they film them all at one time? Can't wait to see where she's going with keeping the Taskmaster seals.




FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Wednesday 14th June 2017
quotequote all
Best show of the series, overall things worked out better than expected, but, like others, we were crying with laughter at the second part of Mel's exotic sandwich farce.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
droopsnoot said:
Speed 3 said:
Russell and Tim should be good, can't say I've heard of the first two.
Alice Levine is a Radio 1 DJ, but seems to be trying to branch out into other stuff recently. I've never heard of the next one.
I think most series have held surprises, someone you've never heard of or particularly noticed turns out to be quite amusing, e.g. Romesh Ranganathan, someone you know of but don't like turns out to be much more likeable, e.g. Noel Fielding, and someone you do know of and has hitherto seemed fairly ordinary turns out to be a complete bleeding nutter, e.g. Sally Phillips. Bob Mortimer was always going to be a total nightmare.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
ajprice said:
FiF said:
Bob Mortimer was always going to be a total nightmare.
No! Rosalind was a nightmare hehe
https://youtu.be/H-XofhvgRcI
Lol bow

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
Enjoying this. Good crew so far.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
Apart from that I LoL'd at James Acaster asking Greg "I know it's early days but are we the stupidest so far."

yes

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Friday 26th October 2018
quotequote all
Wait for next week! Rhod's trolling of Greg gets ever better.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Saturday 27th October 2018
quotequote all
Kinky said:
FiF said:
Wait for next week! Rhod's trolling of Greg gets ever better.
Truly made me rofl
Greg's face was a picture, genuine reaction I thought.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Friday 2nd November 2018
quotequote all
youngsyr said:
droopsnoot said:
AlexRS2782 said:
From memory the BBC did commission a family friendly version of Taskmaster. I think it was called The Box and wen't out in the Friday evening slot and was narrated / produced by Alex Horne and at least 1 or 2 other Taskmaster producers / writers.
I caught the end of that a few times but it didn't really do anything for me - it just seems funnier when it's "celebs" doing the tasks. I wonder if a similar thing is going on with the forthcoming "Let me get that" or whatever it's called - seems to be quite a similar format to "Alan Davies as yet untitled".
What makes Taskmaster funny isn't that there are celebrities doing the tasks, but there are comedians doing the tasks (and commenting on them). They all have a very high sense of comedic timing, turn of phrase, expression and improvisation that elevates the show way beyond what a group of random members of the public could achieve.

The difference becomes starkly obvious on shows like Would I lie to you, which mixes comedians with sports stars and other celebrities. More often than not, the non-comedians are pretty dull "filler" and it's the comedians who really bring the entertainment. The chemistry between Lee Mack, David Mitchell and Rob Brydon carries that show. You could put anyone else on their teams and it would still be funny, but when you add yet another comedian, such as Bob Mortimer, it's hilarious.
Exactly, members of the public are motivated by wanting to win, ie the prize money incentive. The best of the comedians don't give a toss about winning, largely, but are motivated by getting the laughs and therefore think of something completely out of the box for the sake of geing funny. Rhod and the fez was a case in point, he didn't fulfil the task by the photo being of Greg's Mum wearing the fez in the bath, the motivation being getting the laughs for trolling Greg. You don't get contestants on quiz shows giving comedy answers, though I once did when didn't know the answer in a club quiz as it was better than being wet and saying I don't know to something that the entire fecking audience did but I didn't.

Q. Who was George Michael's partner in Wham?

A. Walt Disney. paperbag

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Wednesday 7th November 2018
quotequote all
Genuinely LoL'd during the tying up sequence, when you know what happened.

They're just such evil sods.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Thursday 8th November 2018
quotequote all
As was seeing Aisling Bea's Mum being seconded to be the only one taking photographs of that gold pineapple thing.

Rhod's Space Invaders was brilliant, as was Jessica's Mario Kart. Acaster's Grand Theft Auto was a bit lost on me due to never having played it, though family expressed disappointment with the disgraceful lack of prostitutes.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Thursday 8th November 2018
quotequote all
We're obviously all different, I gave up on Repertoire.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Thursday 8th November 2018
quotequote all
skinny said:
I think best series so far? Bob Mortimer and Sally Phillips also brilliant but can't remember who else was on with them. Although I still think the tasks in the first few series were better and more open.
Along with Bob and Sally were Aisling Beacloud9 , Mark Watson and Nish Kumar. Who can forget the challenge where they were blindfolded, given a slice of bread, had to walk for some time and then had to find their way back to the start line by following a line of dropped breadcrumbs. Except a Golden Retriever had scoffed all the bread Mark Watson had dropped. We cried with laughter.

This series has been the equal of that one.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Thursday 9th May 2019
quotequote all
Rocked the chair back and snoozed through it.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Thursday 30th May 2019
quotequote all
Paul Sinha surprisingly bad at lateral thinking.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Saturday 1st June 2019
quotequote all
youngsyr said:
slipstream 1985 said:
Podie said:
It's the way Greg acts as a teacher, berating them for their stupidity that makes me laugh the most.
He's the best part. Last episode and the punishment just because it would cause carnage was funny.

The appology task my immediate thought was to burn the caravan down.....
Greg is the funniest one on there this season because he's the only truly successful stand up comedian.

In previous shows he's had other comedians to bounce back and forth between and it's some of the funniest TV out there (Rhod Gilbert, James Acaster, Rob Becket, that Wang guy, etc. etc.).
The funniest times in the whole series is when Greg reacts to something completely unexpected, prime example when Rhod produced a photo of Greg's Mum in the bath wearing the task fez.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Monday 3rd June 2019
quotequote all
Just noticed Ian Stirling is the narrator on Love Island. He deserves a beasting from Greg simply for that.

FiF

Original Poster:

44,119 posts

252 months

Thursday 11th July 2019
quotequote all
David Baddiel - Like
Ed Gamble - Definitely like
Rose Matafeo - Like
Katy Fix- dunno (even got her name wrong just now)
Just to confirm point made in above post, Jo Brand - just FRO, still we will see how many "men are st and isn't cake brilliant" gags she can work in,