Navara vs L200 - Argh, which one!!?!

Navara vs L200 - Argh, which one!!?!

Author
Discussion

Phil Hopkins

Original Poster:

17,110 posts

217 months

Monday 12th March 2007
quotequote all
Forgive me for the rather dull, diesel, pickup thread but i'm really struggling with this quandry!

I'm looking to contract hire either a Nissan Navara Outlaw or a Mitsubishi L200 Animal/Warrior. My reasoning behind choosing these two are to turn it into a mobile advertising platform (as well as the obligatory beaujolais runs to France). Now, they're both pretty much on a par in terms of spec and pricing. I'm not particularly concerned about the 'look' that each one has (although the L200 is a tad odd). So I suppose ultimately it boils down to performance, comfort & ownership experiances. Clearly if i'm using it for business, it has to be pretty reliable - but in a modern car you'd expect that anyway! Cost of servicing is important, i've never dealt with either Mitsubishi or Nissan before in my murky motortrade past so I don't know if they're stupidly expensive?

I suppose what i'm really after is people to share with me any tales of woe or tales of orgasmic enjoyment etc.

Navara


L200


What do you fine folk think?




Edited by Phil Hopkins on Monday 12th March 14:57

Phil Hopkins

Original Poster:

17,110 posts

217 months

Monday 12th March 2007
quotequote all
dern said:
baSkey said:
(the 'self employed' tax rules have a lot to answer for..!)
I thought they were changing so that these things were will be as unattractive from a financial perspective as they are from every other perspective (unless you're a builder)?



Edited by dern on Monday 12th March 15:21


'They've' been saying it for years but as yet haven't actually done anything about it.

Thanks for the insights folks, certainly some mixed views to consider. Keep them coming. thumbup

Phil Hopkins

Original Poster:

17,110 posts

217 months

Monday 12th March 2007
quotequote all
staceyb said:
And please don't buy it in silver, I'm sick of looking at silver pickups, cheers thumbup


It's got to be black so the signwriting fits in with corporate identity.

Phil Hopkins

Original Poster:

17,110 posts

217 months

Monday 12th March 2007
quotequote all
dern said:
What's the attraction? Is it the tonka looks or do they not drive like they look?


For me; it's the ability to signwrite them without it looking completely out of place, e.g. on a car (I HATE signwritten cars with a passion). I also like the fact I can throw in everything and anything, it'll be great when we go to France, it'll be great when we go camping & hopefully, it'll be great at creating awareness for my business and ultimately a few leads. I also happen to quite like the rugged looks. They're also relatively cheap and tax efficient.

Phil Hopkins

Original Poster:

17,110 posts

217 months

Monday 12th March 2007
quotequote all
MonkeyMatt said:
I’m suppressed you haven’t been tolled to just get an M3 or a Porche yet or suggestions of an F-150 or Ram!


A Ram has been suggested actually. Still loosely considering it BUT, if I got the Ram i'd have to forego buying a weekend car later this year I think.

Phil Hopkins

Original Poster:

17,110 posts

217 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
308mate said:
shout Attention Phil!



I know nothing about the new shape L200 but I can list a few of things the old L200 didnt have:

Performance
Comfort
Fuel economy
A good turning circle

It did:
Look good
fit things in the back
Go through a gearbox inside 12,000miles (replaced under warranty)

And thats about it.

Its a safe bet the Nissan will be better on all counts, though more expensive to maintain.

Its an even safer bet a Hilux will be better than both on all counts, especially performance and comfort, wont need maintaining anyway and looks better. And just is better. So there we go. You should get one. Theyre good.

Plus the SR5 will have a few creature comforts too.

ETA - Forget the Ram or the F150 unless you want to use the side of a fuel tanker trailer for your mobile advertising. Having said that, EVERYONE will look at it. Birds hate it though and would you believe it, being the callous and shallow little man that I am, I actually get self concious when driving an ugly girl around in it cause you cant keep it secret!

ETA again - not that I would ever have an ugly bird in it...DOH!


Edited by 308mate on Monday 12th March 18:15



Edited by 308mate on Monday 12th March 18:16


Thanks for the info there chap. I'll go and have a shufty at the Hi-lux!

Phil Hopkins

Original Poster:

17,110 posts

217 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
Well that's just tossed a rather gigantic spanner in the works.

I've been offered a deal I simply can't refuse so i've gone for the L200 Animal!

It gets delivered next week! bounce

Phil Hopkins

Original Poster:

17,110 posts

217 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
sixpackpert said:
Good choice that man!! bounceparty

Join the L200 Owners Club, £15 for life membership and you'll get all the techno knowledge you'll ever need, discounts on parts, servicing and accessories plus much more.

www.l200.org.uk/

See you on there!!?!

Cheers

Sixpack


Just this second registered, waiting for admin approval as we speak/type etc. thumbup

Phil Hopkins

Original Poster:

17,110 posts

217 months

Monday 14th May 2007
quotequote all
Yay, it was delivered on Friday! I've fallen in love with it already. Got it a wee bit muddy on Saturday (well, you've got to haven't you?) Then promptly had it valetted on Sunday!

The spec level is tremendous given that it's a 'commercial' vehicle. Equally, with it being the Animal version, it's had a little bit of tweaking to the engine to give it a power boost. It's not the quickest thing by a long shot but it's not overly sluggish either.

I didn't realise but RalliArt are the people who have developed the software for the auto box too!