Would you rather...? Vantage buying

[YorksLS18]

Here's a twist on the done-to-death manual vs sportshift Vantage debate...

I'm starting my search for a V8 Vantage, with my ideal car being an early 4.7 manual. It's achievable with my budget.

The mixed reviews on sportshift 1 put me off this transmission. Separately, the weaker mid-range torque puts me off the 4.3 engine.

However, I'll have much more choice if I open up my options. Realistically this could mean a better car.

So here's the conundrum...

If push came to shove, would you rather have a good 4.7 sportshift, or a really tip-top 4.3 manual?

Which would give the better driving experience in your opinion? Comments especially welcome from anyone who's driven both.

Also, is there any noticable variation in clutch wear between the two transmission types?

Naturally I will be trying before buying. And any good experiences from independent specialist dealers would also be helpful to hear about.

Thanks in advance!

[YorksLS18]

Thanks to everyone who's taken the time to comment. Some really helpful insights, advice and experiences. And the range of opinions shows how personalised the experience of enjoyable driving can be.

From this, SS does seem to have its fans as well as detractors. So I'm going to keep an open mind and look at both transmission types in 4.7 form, and possibly try a 4.3 manual for comparison if I can find an accommodating dealer.

Either way, there seem to be some decent examples out there and it really is "the car I've always promised myself". They're beautiful in any configuration. Thanks again for all your genuinely helpful responses.