SLK Diesel ..... Yes or No

[taxboy]

I'm considering getting an SLK as second car. My early research suggests that the diesels are well reviewed but I'm not certain how a diesel sits with me in respect of a convertible, so I'm seeking input from SLK owners on what choice of engine they chose and why.

Im not anti diesel as my daily driver is a BMW 520d just to place that in context

All views appreciated

[taxboy]

Miglia 888 said:

We've had 3 petrol SLK's, and currently have a MINI Cooper SD Convertible powered by a diesel engine similar to that in your BMW.
I'd also happily have a diesel SLK, or indeed a petrol MINI Cooper S Convertible.
If you want a diesel SLK, get one and enjoy it.

Thanks for that if buying another slk would you choose the diesel or petrol ?

[taxboy]

Miglia 888 said:

As a second car not doing many miles, with purchase & running costs no object, I'd choose the SLK 55 with its 420hp & 540Nm.
The SLK 350 has a very sweet & tuneful revvy 300hp engine, however it's just a bit too light on low down torque for my taste.
If I was doing 10k+ miles a year in it, I'd take the SLK 250CDI - as quick as the 250 petrol, similar torque as the 55 but with half its fuel costs.
However, it's not about what I would choose, it's about what you like best - everyone's different.
Test drive some SLK's, both petrol & diesel, with the big & the smaller engines, and most importantly, with the top down, to see what is best for your needs - let us know how you get on. HTH

You are quite correct I do need to drive them both. It's sometimes certain models are known amongst owners as being much better / worse than others

Thanks for you input much appreciated