Invoice-tax point date?

Invoice-tax point date?

Author
Discussion

Dave_ST220

Original Poster:

10,294 posts

205 months

Wednesday 12th October 2011
quotequote all
I should fire this to our accountant but this place is full of knowledge so I should get the answer! Do invoices need to have a tax point date if the invoice date differs from the actual order date? eg, order placed on the 1st but not invoiced until say the 5th? I'm thinking more for instances when the VAT rate changes, not a regular thing I know but still good to cover. Cheers

Eric Mc

122,029 posts

265 months

Wednesday 12th October 2011
quotequote all
I presume you are talking about VAT here as it is VAT that tends to refer to "Tax Point Date" in their regulations.

Invoices always need to have a tax point date but how that is decided can vary.

The date of the order tends NOT to be a tax point date. The date the actual invoice is issued is the usual date chosen but there can be occasions when some other date might become the tax point instead, such as the date of payment (which can sometimes be ahead of the issuing of the invoice).

Dave_ST220

Original Poster:

10,294 posts

205 months

Wednesday 12th October 2011
quotequote all
Thanks Eric. Yes these are VAT invoices, so even though someone may have ordered & paid in the old VAT rate period we are OK that the invoice date is when the new VAT rate would be in effect? Or does the fact they have paid require a seperate date "tax point"?

Eric Mc

122,029 posts

265 months

Wednesday 12th October 2011
quotequote all
Tax Point often becomes an issue when the VAT rates change. Here is HMRC's instructions for this situation -

VAT rate changes
At the time of a VAT rate change, suppliers can choose to use the rate in force on the date the supply physically takes place under the normal time of supply rules (see above), even though a different rate might apply at the time of supply (tax point), for example because the time of supply has been changed to a different date by a payment in advance or the issuing of a VAT invoice. They can also do this when the liability of a particular product or service changes - for example, because a product or service that was standard-rated becomes reduced-rated.

These special provisions do not change the time of supply. Both supplier and customer must still account for VAT at the time of supply using the rules in the rest of this guide.

In the event of a VAT rate increase suppliers might want to use the special provisions so they can charge the lower rate of VAT on a supply that takes place before the rate increase, but the time of supply occurs afterwards when the VAT invoice is issued.

In the event of a VAT rate decrease suppliers might want to use the special provisions so they can charge the lower rate of VAT on a supply that takes place after the rate decrease, but where the time of supply occurred beforehand when a payment was received or a VAT invoice was issued.

Is your customer VAT registered?


Dave_ST220

Original Poster:

10,294 posts

205 months

Wednesday 12th October 2011
quotequote all
The customer may or may not be VAT registered, we sell online to anyone.

Eric Mc

122,029 posts

265 months

Wednesday 12th October 2011
quotequote all
Dave_ST220 said:
The customer may or may not be VAT registered, we sell online to anyone.
Find out if they are.

If they are, the tax point is irrelevant as they can reclaim the VAT at whatever rate you use.

Dave_ST220

Original Poster:

10,294 posts

205 months

Wednesday 12th October 2011
quotequote all
We have no way of finding out I'm afraid. Do we need to do anything?

Eric Mc

122,029 posts

265 months

Wednesday 12th October 2011
quotequote all
Why is this an issue with your customers?

Do you quote your prices VAT exclusive or VAT inclusive?

Did you raise your sale prices after the VAT change?

If you quote VAT inclusive and someone contracted to buy something from you at the VAT inclusive price you quoted before the VAT rate hike and they ordered BEFORE the VAT rate change - AND you didn't make any comment in your advertsing that prices would be rising after the VAT rate change, then I think you are obliged to supply the goods at the original pre VAT increase price. Obviously, you will still will have to pay the VAT to HMRC at the new higher rate, which of course means that you will be left with a lower amount to take as the actual VAT exclusive sale value for yourself.

Are you an on-line reatil outlet?

Do you normally issue specific VAT invoices to customers?

How do you handle exports?

Dave_ST220

Original Poster:

10,294 posts

205 months

Wednesday 12th October 2011
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Why is this an issue with your customers? It isn't, I'm covering myself

Do you quote your prices VAT exclusive or VAT inclusive? both

Did you raise your sale prices after the VAT change? no

If you quote VAT inclusive and someone contracted to buy something from you at the VAT inclusive price you quoted before the VAT rate hike and they ordered BEFORE the VAT rate change - AND you didn't make any comment in your advertsing that prices would be rising after the VAT rate change, then I think you are obliged to supply the goods at the original pre VAT increase price. Obviously, you will still will have to pay the VAT to HMRC at the new higher rate, which of course means that you will be left with a lower amount to take as the actual VAT exclusive sale value for yourself.

Are you an on-line reatil outlet? yes

Do you normally issue specific VAT invoices to customers? yes, all customers get a VAT invoice

How do you handle exports?we only sell in the UK
I'm think I'm confusing things here! This is the scenario :-

Our site shows an item at £10 + VAT so currently £12 inclusive, customer orders & pays that amount. We don't invoice them as we are closed until Monday. In the time between them ordering & paying the VAT rate changes to 25%. We will send them an invoice that shows the VAT rate at 20% BUT the date of this invoive will fall on the day where the VAT rate is in fact 25%.

Eric Mc

122,029 posts

265 months

Wednesday 12th October 2011
quotequote all
As I said, there are special transition provisions for when VAT rates change. If the sale was finalised before the rate changes, then you account for the VAT at the old rate.

If the sale was initiated before the rate change but finalised after the rate change, retailers can still account for the sale at the old rate.

Obviously, sales initiated and finalised after a rate change will be at the new rate.

There are anti-avoidance provisions to prevent businesses manipulating sales so that they fall within a particular VAT rate.

These rules pertain whetrher rates go up or down.

Dave_ST220

Original Poster:

10,294 posts

205 months

Wednesday 12th October 2011
quotequote all
OK, so my worry over the invoice date is without substance by the sounds of it?

Eric Mc

122,029 posts

265 months

Wednesday 12th October 2011
quotequote all
I don't really know - it depends on what types of things make you worried.

I would go back to your pwn accountant for his/her view.

Digga

40,318 posts

283 months

Wednesday 12th October 2011
quotequote all
Dave_ST220 said:
We will send them an invoice that shows the VAT rate at 20% BUT the date of this invoive will fall on the day where the VAT rate is in fact 25%.
I don't think you're allwoed to decide your own VAT rate.

Acutally an interesting problem.

ABZCARS

28 posts

152 months

Sunday 23rd October 2011
quotequote all
Does cash accounting not come into this, where for VAT purposes you charge the VAT rate when your actually paid

davepoth

29,395 posts

199 months

Sunday 23rd October 2011
quotequote all
When doing invoices, the VAT rate that applies is the VAT rate at the date of supply. So on the day when the goods were shipped, if the VAT rate was 20% then the invoice should show 20% VAT.

As regards tax point, the invoice date should be the date on which the invoice was raised; I've been in some compromising positions where my finance department didn't do that and I've been asked to chase a backdated invoice that the customer had only received a day previously. Naughty.