RE: PH Origins: Anti-lock brakes

RE: PH Origins: Anti-lock brakes

Monday 22nd January 2018

PH Origins: Anti-lock brakes

The aviation industry is often cited as the birthplace of anti-lock braking systems. The reality, however, is a little different...



Ask automotive enthusiasts about the history of anti-lock braking systems and you'll likely notice a theme to their answers. Most will say how the technology originated from the aviation industry in the 1950s, then arrived in the automotive market in 1966 with the launch of the Jensen FF - some 12 years before Mercedes-Benz rolled ABS out in earnest.

These answers would not surprise those with an interest in automotive technology. But, while not entirely incorrect, the concept of ABS predates all of the above by decades - and, in fact, didn't originally involve the aviation industry at all.

In 1908, Surrey-based engineer James Edward Francis submitted a patent detailing a system that focused on how to stop the driving wheels of a train slipping while accelerating. Braking, however, was also a problem in that era. The primitive systems available often caused the wheels to lock or decelerate quicker than the train, resulting in an uncontrolled slide. This would damage both the rails and the wheels, or cause more significant damage to whatever the train subsequently ploughed into.


Francis was aware of this issue, too. Consequently, having devised a system that could monitor wheel speeds and reduce the vehicle's power output to maintain traction, he detailed how it could also be employed to avoid skidding. If the brakes locked when 'an emergency braking pressure is employed', it would automatically release then re-engage them, preventing skidding and cutting stopping distances.

His patent, published in 1909, marks the established introduction of the concept of anti-lock braking. Whether Francis's idea ever saw action is unknown but it laid the groundwork for all future anti-lock and traction control systems.


Similar patents followed but, predominantly, many sources alternatively cite engineer and aviation pioneer Gabriel Voisin as the inventor of ABS. It is often stated that he conceived a system, at some point between 1920 and 1929, for use in aircraft. Voisin had abandoned aircraft manufacture by that point, however; the use of his aeroplanes in World War One horrified him to the extent that he shuttered any related activities in 1918.

He did promptly redeploy his engineering talents in another fast-moving field, though - that of the automobile - and built a reputation for developing innovative, fast cars. This shift attracted new talent, including a French Lieutenant called Pierre Cayla. He was well versed in speed and risk, having been a pilot since 1911 - one that was responsible for flying the Voisin 'Canard' seaplane during French naval trials in 1912.

Cayla was also an experienced and talented engineer and, if you trawl the archives, it is his name that is attributed to a patent - filed on 1 February 1923 and approved on 4 August 1925 - describing a braking system with an anti-lock feature.


The system, designed primarily for 'vehicle wheels, and particularly for steering wheels of motor vehicles', was a hub-driven, hydraulically operated, drum brake set-up. When driving along, a wheel-driven pump would draw fluid from an internal reservoir and pump it through a bypass valve - straight back into a reservoir. When the driver triggered the brakes, a linkage would close the bypass valve. This would direct the pressurised fluid into the brake cylinders, which would push the shoes into contact with the wheel-mounted drum and slow the car.

Because the pressure to operate the brake was produced by the wheel-driven pump, it was impossible for it to lock. 'The braking ceases at the same time as the rotation of the wheel,' stated Cayla, 'and therefore cannot occasion the blocking of the latter'. This is later described, quite rightly, as 'a considerable advantage in road operation' - particularly with regards to maintaining steering control, a key feature of modern ABS.

This system would presumably work in conjunction with a conventional set-up fitted on the driveshaft, or one axle, for parking and hill holds. It appears that it was at least tested, with references being made to it in myriad titles - including LJK Setright's 'The Designers: Great automobiles and the men who made them'.


ABS development escalated in the '40s, as jet power and aerodynamic developments increased landing speeds - upping crew workloads, stopping distances and the risk of tyre damage. Boeing promptly equipped its swept-wing B-47 Stratojet with Hydro-Aire Hytrol ABS. Dunlop followed with its Maxaret system in 1952, which could reduce stopping distances by 30 per cent. It featured in a wide range of aircraft, including the Avro Vulcan. In some cases, developers of these systems referenced Francis's original patent from 1909.

It was around this time that the technology began trickling back into cars, as the benefits became clear and technology advanced. Ford tested a system on the rear axle of the Mark II Continental, in 1954, but it was too heavy and expensive. Several other efforts were made but it was the Jensen FF that grabbed the headlines, in 1966, by being the first production car to offer Dunlop Maxaret ABS. The single-channel, single-sensor system would reduce unwanted sliding by releasing the brakes if all four wheels stopped turning.


It took until late 1970 for a multi-channel ABS to be offered to the car-buying public. Chrysler was first past the post with its effective Bendix 'Sure-Brake' set-up for the Imperial, which could monitor individual wheel speeds and modulate braking at each front wheel and across the rear axle.

Then, in 1978, Mercedes rolled out its optional Bosch-developed ABS in the W116 - and the acronym of 'Anti-Blockier System', later known as 'Anti-lock Braking System', was born. Ten years later, around a million Mercedes alone were equipped with ABS. As advancements reduced the cost and complexity of the hardware, its implementation spread at a vast rate of knots - but, ultimately, the principle remained the same as that established by Francis in 1909.

Author
Discussion

V8 FOU

Original Poster:

2,974 posts

147 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
Dunlop Maxaret system was being fitted to trucks in the 70's and 80's.
A lot of them were retro fitted.
I would think ABS on a large truck would be more beneficial than cars .......

Toltec

7,159 posts

223 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
Cannot find it, but I'm sure I saw a post saying traction control was originally developed for trains too.

J4CKO

41,560 posts

200 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
Maxaret sounds like something you get form Boots if you have the squits !

LotusOmega375D

7,622 posts

153 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
ABS is for girls.

Dr Interceptor

7,786 posts

196 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
Have a strong sense of Déjà vu - I'm sure I've read that very article, or one just like it somewhere else in the past week.

Michael77

55 posts

154 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
Toltec said:
Cannot find it, but I'm sure I saw a post saying traction control was originally developed for trains too.
Did you see it in paragraphs 3-5 of this very article? smile

tim milne

344 posts

233 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all

paulyv

1,020 posts

123 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
tim milne said:
One article on traction control, and one on anti-lock braking...2 different topics, or am I missing something?

Dr Interceptor

7,786 posts

196 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
tim milne said:
That's what I remember reading - glad I'm not losing it.

UltimaCH

3,155 posts

189 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
Photo of the Jensen shows it registered with Swiss canton Glaris (GL) plates. Interesting...

olderbutnotwiser

36 posts

129 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
The Jensen FF is definitely a nicer looking car than the Prototype Ferguson R5 which also had 4wd & anti lock.

https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/anything-goes/t...

Toltec

7,159 posts

223 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
Dr Interceptor said:
tim milne said:
That's what I remember reading - glad I'm not losing it.
Aha, weird it didn't show when I searched for it, then again maybe not.

jet_noise

5,650 posts

182 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
olderbutnotwiser said:
The Jensen FF is definitely a nicer looking car than the Prototype Ferguson R5 which also had 4wd & anti lock.

https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/anything-goes/t...
Aargh, my eyes!
A Frankencar if ever there was one.

So that's from where Ssanyong got their design cues smile

malucnojes

50 posts

108 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
Always remember seeing Cavaliers when I was growing up with ABS badges on the back and thinking it was cool for some reason!

vikingaero

10,334 posts

169 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
Did you know that ABS also works if you are braking and out of control travelling backwards?

timelord

316 posts

283 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
Worked in the rail industry and anti-wheel slip and slide controls have certainly been around for some time on trains, both on engines and carriages

Jex

838 posts

128 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
LotusOmega375D said:
ABS is for girls.
But have you had to apply emergency braking in a real emergency?

I know that if the wheels lock you should release them and re-apply them, but when it happened to me, the logical part of my brain which had noticed that the wheels had locked was saying release the brakes, but some more fundamental sub-conscious response was apparently saying: No you can't do that, you need to stop and to stop you press this pedal! The sub-conscious won and I slid into the back of another car (greasy road, just rained, downhill, probably wind behind etc) fortunately at a low speed (no-one hurt, just my pride) with my right foot still firmly on the brake pedal. I now know that ABS is a good thing! (For me anyway - or I'm just a whimp - you decide)

rtz62

3,369 posts

155 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
If she Germans considered it to be such a smart thing to have in production cars, pray tell why did my Audi UR Quattro have ABS that could be switched off (and yes, I know their explanation).
Shame that euro ‘n bureaucrats obviously thought that the human interface wasn’t to be trusted with such tomfoolery and hence ABS cannot now be switched off (as far as I’m aware anyway?).
I’m over 50 and had many a lark in my teens, together with my friends, all driving mk1 and mk2 Escorts, no PAS, ABS, TC, BO, VD etc (definitely not the last two...) and could plead the case of simpler days when a dab of oppo was fun and all that was needed to get us out of any situation.
Now, in my salad years, I realise that good driver as I may be, those systems are a benefit, as evinced recently at my local M1 roundabout when a tt of an HGV driver never even looked and steamed straight out in front of me and the car to my left at unabated speed.
Can’t wait for the AUC to be developed for SMP situations (automatic underwear changer for st my pants situations...)

RacerMike

4,205 posts

211 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
rtz62 said:
If she Germans considered it to be such a smart thing to have in production cars, pray tell why did my Audi UR Quattro have ABS that could be switched off (and yes, I know their explanation).
Shame that euro ‘n bureaucrats obviously thought that the human interface wasn’t to be trusted with such tomfoolery and hence ABS cannot now be switched off (as far as I’m aware anyway?).
I’m over 50 and had many a lark in my teens, together with my friends, all driving mk1 and mk2 Escorts, no PAS, ABS, TC, BO, VD etc (definitely not the last two...) and could plead the case of simpler days when a dab of oppo was fun and all that was needed to get us out of any situation.
Now, in my salad years, I realise that good driver as I may be, those systems are a benefit, as evinced recently at my local M1 roundabout when a tt of an HGV driver never even looked and steamed straight out in front of me and the car to my left at unabated speed.
Can’t wait for the AUC to be developed for SMP situations (automatic underwear changer for st my pants situations...)
Well. You may not have noticed, but technology has moved on somewhat since the late 80s and not all things that happen in the world are a conspiracy!

The reason for an ABS switch back then was due to the fairly limited capability of the hardware and software (if there even was any). A modern ABS system is integral to the stability control/TCS controller and has upwards of 7000 parameters and 20,000 signals. There simply isn’t a need for a switch as it’s possible for the software automatically change its behaviour depending on the conditions. The times where’s its better not to have ABS are so absolutely miniscule it’s pointless to make it possible to disable. In absolutely every emergency situation, you’re better off with it....

anonymous-user

54 months

Monday 22nd January 2018
quotequote all
RacerMike said:
Well. You may not have noticed, but technology has moved on somewhat since the late 80s and not all things that happen in the world are a conspiracy!

The reason for an ABS switch back then was due to the fairly limited capability of the hardware and software (if there even was any). A modern ABS system is integral to the stability control/TCS controller and has upwards of 7000 parameters and 20,000 signals. There simply isn’t a need for a switch as it’s possible for the software automatically change its behaviour depending on the conditions. The times where’s its better not to have ABS are so absolutely miniscule it’s pointless to make it possible to disable. In absolutely every emergency situation, you’re better off with it....
^^^ Absolutely this.

The key to effective ABS isn't when the first patent was granted but when people got computers smart enough to run it properly. And you need a pretty fancy computer to run modern 4-channel combined ABS, Traction Control and Chassis Stability control. The early systems were mechanical and then later systems were developed around analog computers, if you can imagine such a thing.

When the driving gods turn up and say they don't need the "nanny aids" all you have to do is ask them how they're going to independently operate four brake pedals at the same time while dealing with a panic situation.