Scottish Referendum / Independence - Vol 9

Scottish Referendum / Independence - Vol 9

TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED
Author
Discussion

Evercross

6,626 posts

79 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
Lim said:
I'll make this very simple for you. Black and white. I will only reply to your posts if they don't contain insults, misquotes or misrepresentations.
Judge, jury, executioner. It's cop-out mate, but as I and other have said to you before it is just an easy-out for you to talk drivel without having to explain yourself. Don't expect others to engage with you either if you aren't actually prepared to though.

One last chance - why would closing the border be an act of 'destabilising the SNP' because it jeopardised being on 'good terms with neighbours' if performed by others, but not by Sturgeon?

Why is it OK for her to ps off the neighbours, but not the other way around?

If you don't answer I will assume it is because you cannot because you don't want to admit to the error, or will not because you are fully aware of the double-standards you have applied and see nothing wrong with them.

Edited by Evercross on Friday 8th January 17:15

hutchst

3,726 posts

111 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
Evercross said:
Judge, jury, executioner. It's cop-out mate, but as I and other have said to you before it is just an easy-out for you to talk drivel without having to explain yourself. Don't expect others to engage with you either if you aren't actually prepared to though.

One last chance - why would closing the border be an act of 'destabilising the SNP' because it jeopardised being on 'good terms with neighbours' if performed by others, but not by Sturgeon?

Why is it OK for her to ps off the neighbours, but not the other way around?

If you don't answer I will assume it is because you cannot because you don't want to admit to the error, or will not because you are fully aware of the double-standards you have applied and see nothing wrong with them.

Edited by Evercross on Friday 8th January 17:15
You're just encouraging his delusion that anybody gives a flying fk what he thinks.

Alpacaman

1,034 posts

256 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
I don't think George Laird is much of a fan of Nicola-

https://glasgowunihumanrights.blogspot.com/2021/01...

He says- "To my surprise, SNP Leader Nicola Sturgeon is considering closing down 'takeaways'. This is a prime resource for many homeless people who don't have access to cooking facilities. If a person cannot maintain a reasonable body temperature, they are at serious risk of cold related illness and death. Is Nicola Sturgeon so backward and incompetent that she never thinks through the garbage she utters that passes for possible proposed policy? Sturgeon is what I term a 'cut and paste' politician, she is bereft of original thought, because everything she does has no depth to it."

and- "My contention is that SNP leader Nicola Sturgeon is a bad leader, stupid and dangerous, her gesture politics are a dead weight on the governance of Scotland. In the midst of the pandemic, Sturgeon has failed the people of Scotland. This is increasingly looking like abuse of power and abuse of ministerial office. The reality of Sturgeon's handling of the pandemic is that she has failed in the most key areas, such as public health messaging, which she deliberately has made political. Scottish people are ignoring her appeals because her incompetence has cost so many people their lives. It's like realisation that you aren't willing to get in the car with the drunk driver despite their protestations they can get you were you want to go."

It still amazes me that there is anyone left prepared to support this bunch of incompetents and ignore the damage they are doing to this country.

DocJock

8,674 posts

255 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
Evercross said:
Lim said:
Evercross said:
More bks.

Sturgeon took the decision to close the border legally - how does that fit with your narrative of 'destabilising the SNP'?

You really are away in a world of your own imaginations, verging on fantasy and paranoia.

A lost cause indeed when your own ruminations are just a bag of self-contradiction.
Reported.
For what? For pointing out that once again you want to have your cake and eat it? If you cannot see the obvious and blatant contradiciton in your own post then you are indeed a lost cause and there is nothing wrong in anyone observing that.

But I'll give you a chance to explain yourself - how is it that when someone suggested the border should have been closed to prevent Covid spread you consider that would have been a tactic exercised by others to 'destabilise the SNP' because of poor neighbourly relations yet you see no problem with your Sainted Nicola of the Fake Opinion polls doing the same thing?

Call me what you want - but putting that question to you breaks no rules in this forum!
It's at times like this that I really miss the 'cringe' thread...

A.J.M

8,193 posts

201 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
Lim

why would closing the border be an act of 'destabilising the SNP' because it jeopardised being on 'good terms with neighbours' if performed by others, but not by Sturgeon?

Lim

2,274 posts

57 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
A.J.M said:
Lim

why would closing the border be an act of 'destabilising the SNP' because it jeopardised being on 'good terms with neighbours' if performed by others, but not by Sturgeon?
Just a quick clarification, I said borders. If any country in the union had unilaterally banned international flights, against wishes of other 3 nations, that would be antagonistic, and rogue decisions unlikely to do much good for international trust and standing.

I looped back to SNP, but didn't conflate the points entirely. Those who argue UDI in my view, can't be sincerely interested in independence. For reasons others have given. Not least it would likely be in the end of SNP when they are laughed off the international stage.

Edinburger

10,404 posts

183 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
ant1973 said:
Edinburger said:
Roderick Spode said:
ant1973 said:
Like the ramblings of the demented across the political spectrum, they can be safely ignored.

What can't be ignored is the Dear Leader's comments this morning that she is going to look at taking further measures that prevent people leaving their house to go to work. I fear we may well see construction and manufacturing canned this week. She might adopt the sleekit "guidance" approach of last time but the entire industry will not fall for that trick twice. I am hopeful it will not be anything other than a repeat of the guidance because she can't afford to sub those two large sectors of the economy. Especially given that an election is imminent (maybe!).
I hope she gives it a square go, because she would be picking a fight with so many industry bodies and the UK Government. I work in the electricity sector, and the regulator Ofgem & National Grid lobbied the UK Government hard prior to the first lockdown, stating that continued upgrades to the electricity network should be considered vital for national security, to which the UK Govt agreed on the basis of suitable provision of Covid-safe methods of working be implemented, which has been done throughout the industry. I look forward to seeing Foghorn Dreghorn, a tinpot dictator of a regional assembly, getting slapped down when she tries to mix it with the big boys.
Apologies if this has been covered before but I haven't visited this thread for a few weeks.

When you say "I fear we may well see construction and manufacturing canned this week" I assumer you mean told they must not leave home for work? If that happens, good (asuming furlough, etc.). It makes no sense to have schools closed when vanloads of workmen are travelling together all over the place. Likewise, there's lots of businesses open and even shops open who should not be open if schools are not open.
Good!?

I take it you are able to work from home!!?

What should construction companies do? You know that furlough only deals with staff wages - not pension contributions and NI? How do they finance their fixed costs? Take out potentially ruinous loans? Owners to risk their homes with CBILs PGs?

But hey, you are ok, so I guess it's fine.

Both industries contribute enormously to the economy and our well being. Construction is a low margin, high risk business. Reserves are low and this will be the death knell for lots of companies. There is no support for fixed costs in terms of grants.

I hope the Chief Mammy understands that it is a one way ticket to unemployment for a key component of her demographic.

No doubt we will be issued with "guidance" so she can have clean hands in the future.

Not if I have anything to do with it.

With respect - your comfy middle class attitude makes me sick.
My "comfy middle class attitude"? Hardly. If only you knew me.

Look at this way. Schools are closed. Children's education is one of the most important things any government must look after. But kids are at home while schools try to provide some sort of education remotely. This is a catastrophe.

Yet we have van loads of builders driving to jobs every day and they do not all observe social distancing or other required procedures. Today I've seen bike shops, estate agents, cake shops, hardware shops, tailors, dry cleaners and pet shops all open. Are they all essential? Is ordering a cake or having a suit dry cleaned more important than children's education?

That's my point.

hiccy18

3,322 posts

82 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
Edinburger said:
My "comfy middle class attitude"? Hardly. If only you knew me.

Look at this way. Schools are closed. Children's education is one of the most important things any government must look after. But kids are at home while schools try to provide some sort of education remotely. This is a catastrophe.

Yet we have van loads of builders driving to jobs every day and they do not all observe social distancing or other required procedures. Today I've seen bike shops, estate agents, cake shops, hardware shops, tailors, dry cleaners and pet shops all open. Are they all essential? Is ordering a cake or having a suit dry cleaned more important than children's education?

That's my point.
In other countries the schools switch to remote learning when necessary and all the businesses stay open and function as normal. Is earning a living essential? I'd say so. Can learning be done remotely? I know it can; it's perhaps not as good but when high schools are running at 54% attendance at times thanks to self isolation wouldn't it be better to have properly organised remote learning in place?

A.J.M

8,193 posts

201 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all



Oh dear.
Shagger salmond just doesn’t seem to take the hint.
Or is this because Mr Murrell has contradicted Mrs Murrells claims.

Or is there still nothing to see?

Borghetto

3,285 posts

198 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
Lim said:
Reported.
You need to grow up.

Pastor Of Muppets

3,664 posts

77 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
Jasey_ said:
Borghetto said:
You need to grow up.
Hes been here 3 months and changed his name at least 3 times.
Maybe it's because he is out on a lim(b), his new name for February might just be a single L. That'd be apt.

Evercross

6,626 posts

79 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
A.J.M said:



Oh dear.
Shagger salmond just doesn’t seem to take the hint.
Or is this because Mr Murrell has contradicted Mrs Murrells claims.

Or is there still nothing to see?
Gotta love how the FM tried to deflect rather than defend the accusation, yet her deflection is to (continue to) imply that Salmond is a bad man despite him now winning TWO legal cases that state otherwise.

Sturgeon really does have a superiority complex verging on sociopathy. She believes she can do no wrong, but moreover when she falsely accuses others of doing wrong and gets called out for it she asserts that it is still their fault rather than hers.

Lim

2,274 posts

57 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
For sake of clarity, I changed it from lothianjim, to limjim to lim. Hope this clears it up.

Interesting definition of maturity doing the rounds this evening.

Scrump

Original Poster:

23,420 posts

173 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED