More rail strikes

Author
Discussion

asfault

Original Poster:

13,189 posts

194 months

Wednesday 11th December 2024
quotequote all
Surprise surprise planned for around xmas travel time.
Serious question what's the longest period the railways have gone without some sort of strike action or threat?

alangla

5,676 posts

196 months

Wednesday 11th December 2024
quotequote all
No idea. Some companies seem(ed) to manage fine (Virgin never seemed to have much trouble) but others like their successors Avanti seem to have constant problems. One thing that will show if this government is serious about fixing the railways is if they finally sort this rest day working nonsense and get Sunday as a normal working day, at least for new starts initially. It’ll mean employing more people but it’ll stop nonsense like this strike and the total non-service being experienced on a Sunday at Northern and others.

272BHP

6,303 posts

251 months

Wednesday 11th December 2024
quotequote all
Anyone else feel that travelling into London these days is a bit of a gamble? Chances are that in able to get back home you are going to have to pay hundreds of pounds in taxi fares or just sit on a freezing platform for hours.

Used to travel in for drinks, gigs, football on a whim but those days are over for awhile - just too risky.

I know people who have spent over a 1000 pound in taxi fares in the last month alone.

Cats_pyjamas

1,727 posts

163 months

Wednesday 11th December 2024
quotequote all
Automate the lines, problem solved. We rarely use trains, but have been caught out a few times. We now take a coach.

alangla

5,676 posts

196 months

Wednesday 11th December 2024
quotequote all
272BHP said:
Anyone else feel that travelling into London these days is a bit of a gamble? Chances are that in able to get back home you are going to have to pay hundreds of pounds in taxi fares or just sit on a freezing platform for hours.

Used to travel in for drinks, gigs, football on a whim but those days are over for awhile - just too risky.

I know people who have spent over a 1000 pound in taxi fares in the last month alone.
Probably even more of a gamble trying to get into Manchester or Edinburgh, particularly at the weekend. It’s a nationwide problem (except Wales, where this particular nettle seems to have been grasped) so it’ll be interesting to see what the UK and Scottish governments attempt to do about it.

valiant

12,333 posts

175 months

Wednesday 11th December 2024
quotequote all
Cats_pyjamas said:
Automate the lines, problem solved. We rarely use trains, but have been caught out a few times. We now take a coach.
How?

272BHP

6,303 posts

251 months

Wednesday 11th December 2024
quotequote all
alangla said:
Probably even more of a gamble trying to get into Manchester or Edinburgh, particularly at the weekend. It’s a nationwide problem (except Wales, where this particular nettle seems to have been grasped) so it’ll be interesting to see what the UK and Scottish governments attempt to do about it.
Again tonight. South Western line from Waterloo to Woking - nothing moving for hours.

Same last week. Same the week before that.

RobB_

1,080 posts

203 months

Wednesday 11th December 2024
quotequote all
valiant said:
How?
With the advancements in self driving cars... it can be done, but there's no money in it for big AI/VC/PE to invest. Uk plc is too inept to see the advantages.

When was the DLR, 80s?

272BHP

6,303 posts

251 months

Wednesday 11th December 2024
quotequote all
valiant said:
How?
Trains are surely an order of magnitude easier to automate than cars.

Spend the savings on having cameras covering every inch of track, this should cut down the amount of time investigating trespassing incidents.

Tankrizzo

7,738 posts

208 months

Wednesday 11th December 2024
quotequote all
272BHP said:
Anyone else feel that travelling into London these days is a bit of a gamble? Chances are that in able to get back home you are going to have to pay hundreds of pounds in taxi fares or just sit on a freezing platform for hours.

Used to travel in for drinks, gigs, football on a whim but those days are over for awhile - just too risky.

I know people who have spent over a 1000 pound in taxi fares in the last month alone.
Yup. Mrs came back from Waterloo on Sunday night, supposed to be getting off at Fareham. At Guildford, they announced that due to the overcrowding on the train, they now wouldn't be stopping at any stops at all after that until Southampton. No advice on what to do for anyone who was supposed to get off before that - tough st, basically.

survivalist

6,019 posts

205 months

Wednesday 11th December 2024
quotequote all
272BHP said:
Anyone else feel that travelling into London these days is a bit of a gamble? Chances are that in able to get back home you are going to have to pay hundreds of pounds in taxi fares or just sit on a freezing platform for hours.

Used to travel in for drinks, gigs, football on a whim but those days are over for awhile - just too risky.

I know people who have spent over a 1000 pound in taxi fares in the last month alone.
Went in last Saturday for a family day out. Didn’t even consider using the train, £15 congestion charge plus whatever the fuel is is way cheaper than the train fare anyway.

Sure enough, loads of cancellations and people on our towns Facebook group talking about hours of delays and expensive taxis.

Shame, as the children like the train as it’s a novelty for them.

I still go in for work, but Mrs S and I won’t go to London on the same day.

Hoofy

78,602 posts

297 months

Wednesday 11th December 2024
quotequote all
Cats_pyjamas said:
Automate the lines, problem solved. We rarely use trains, but have been caught out a few times. We now take a coach.
I've thought this was the solution for ages but before everything could be properly set up, the strikes would get to a point where the trains would be unusable.

I do think what needs to happen is people just stop using public transport, transport companies lose money so bin their employees, then the employees start accepting lower salaries and stop moaning/striking every time there's a rota change because they're scared of losing their jobs as the customer has decided to vote with their feet.

Then they introduce automation.

MrBogSmith

3,369 posts

49 months

Thursday 12th December 2024
quotequote all
I have to go to London late in the month. With the strikes and general state of the railway it’s easier and cheaper to fly London and back from Manchester.

borcy

7,718 posts

71 months

Thursday 12th December 2024
quotequote all
https://www.timeout.com/uk/news/avanti-west-coast-...


Appears to be a dispute over pay for working on a rest day.

Vasco

18,009 posts

120 months

Thursday 12th December 2024
quotequote all
1. Automation isn't realistic - too costly, disruptive and never ending.
2. Train Unions remain in a very strong position and can still do largely as they like.
3. Train passengers make up under 10% of overall transport journeys but are centred on main lines into London and other cities.

Is there any solution other than changing travel to cars, buses or bikes - or working from home - or changing work locations ?

272BHP

6,303 posts

251 months

Thursday 12th December 2024
quotequote all
Vasco said:
1. Automation isn't realistic - too costly, disruptive and never ending.
2. Train Unions remain in a very strong position and can still do largely as they like.
3. Train passengers make up under 10% of overall transport journeys but are centred on main lines into London and other cities.

Is there any solution other than changing travel to cars, buses or bikes - or working from home - or changing work locations ?
Break the unions. No unions should have control over infrastructure or essential workers.

alangla

5,676 posts

196 months

Thursday 12th December 2024
quotequote all
The irony of this particular dispute is that the unions are in favour of the one (practical!) thing that would prevent them from being able to cause a dispute like this: employing enough staff that the timetable can be operated without overtime.

Bathroom_Security

3,594 posts

132 months

Thursday 12th December 2024
quotequote all
They are greedy s. No wonder people think of them as insects.

What do they get paid now 70odd k a year and its not enough for them. More than many skilled qualified professionals earn in the south.

Don't start with the hours they have to work, they know what they are getting into when they sign up.

Absolute idiots, literal idiots.

borcy

7,718 posts

71 months

Thursday 12th December 2024
quotequote all
As long as there's few training places for many roles in the railway then a strong union will get them as much as possible.

Expecting the rail unions not to try and get the maximum is a bit like hoping Apple will cut the price of their products for the benefit of their customers.

Unions are given fairly strong levers to pull by successive govs and rail companies, hardly surprising that they then use them.

andy43

11,610 posts

269 months

Thursday 12th December 2024
quotequote all
272BHP said:
alangla said:
Probably even more of a gamble trying to get into Manchester or Edinburgh, particularly at the weekend. It’s a nationwide problem (except Wales, where this particular nettle seems to have been grasped) so it’ll be interesting to see what the UK and Scottish governments attempt to do about it.
Again tonight. South Western line from Waterloo to Woking - nothing moving for hours.

Same last week. Same the week before that.
We arranged to go into Manchester a couple of Sundays ago for 1pm.
All trains cancelled between 1115 and 215. Fare for two was £12.
Drove in instead and parked all day for £4.
Resulted in cuts in : walking, people, cold, money, hassle.
Completely pointless having a railway if it doesn’t work.