Advice needed on pruning an apple tree.
Advice needed on pruning an apple tree.
Author
Discussion

Ultra Sound Guy

Original Poster:

29,627 posts

225 months

Wednesday 12th March 2025
quotequote all
Hi!
I have inherited an established Bramley apple tree at my new place.


In an effort to improve the quality & quantity of fruit (great in 2023, terrible last year) I've made a start by removing two very low, downward-growing branches (in red) and also cut back some of the thinner/longer branches.
My question is, should I remove one (or both) of the smaller 'trunks' (highlighted yellow) to improve both appearance and health of the tree?
If so, should I do it now, or wait till the end of this season?
TIA

TooLateForAName

4,935 posts

215 months

Wednesday 12th March 2025
quotequote all
Is it actually all bramley?

We have a similar looking tree which was a 'family' apple tree - basically three different types of apple grafted onto a single stock. Idea I think is that it self fertilises the three types.

We have a similar strange shape because the bramley bit has grown really well but the other two main branches, not so much. Leading to the tree leaning badly like yours.

Chrisgr31

14,300 posts

286 months

Wednesday 12th March 2025
quotequote all
In my experience if trees have a great year they tend to have a rest the following year. The fruiting is also subject to the weather, did the blossom set or was it destroyed by wind, rain etc.

Doesn’t help answer your question but my inclination would be to leave as is or thin out any conflicting branches but I am not an expert.

biggiles

2,194 posts

256 months

Wednesday 12th March 2025
quotequote all
Also not an expert (but I have had a go at many trees).

In my experience-
  • you can prune a tree an enormous amount so long as you accept you may not get much fruit until the following year.
  • you should be able to throw a tennis ball easily through the tree (so you have a lot to cut!)
  • if a tree isn't pruned enough, it will crop too heavily and then have a fallow year. But this isn't written in stone.
  • I've rarely thought "I pruned that too much" later in the season
I think pruning is an art, not a science... but don't be afraid to have a go at it. You need to get cracking now, before spring really gets going. I'm doing some this weekend.

Chrisgr31

14,300 posts

286 months

Wednesday 12th March 2025
quotequote all
In my experience if trees have a great year they tend to have a rest the following year. The fruiting is also subject to the weather, did the blossom set or was it destroyed by wind, rain etc.

Doesn’t help answer your question but my inclination would be to leave as is or thin out any conflicting branches but I am not an expert.

dhutch

17,963 posts

228 months

Wednesday 12th March 2025
quotequote all
"aim for an open, goblet shape, crown"

Which given where you are is easier said than done, but removing some of the in-ward pointing branches to open up the middle should help get the air through it.

RSstuff

1,321 posts

46 months

Wednesday 12th March 2025
quotequote all
Chrisgr31 said:
In my experience if trees have a great year they tend to have a rest the following year. The fruiting is also subject to the weather, did the blossom set or was it destroyed by wind, rain etc.
There is an old apple tree in our garden that one year has so much fruit we can't give it all away to our neighbours, followed by a year when there is barely enough for a few apple crumbles.

netherfield

3,213 posts

215 months

Wednesday 12th March 2025
quotequote all
Prune away anything pointing inward, anything crossing or rubbing, anything not strong enough to support the weight of an apple, all should be done in Winter.

Winter doesn't end until 21st March, so still time.

FlossyThePig

4,143 posts

274 months

Kev_Mk3

3,699 posts

126 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
FlossyThePig said:
handy thanks

Ultra Sound Guy

Original Poster:

29,627 posts

225 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies, some interesting insights there.
Having already removed 2 medium-sized low branches, which produced apples at ground-level, I’m just going to concentrate on a ‘trim’ this year, removing anything not facing upwards, close growing branches, crossed branches and anything which stops air and light getting to the centre, plus a bit of external shaping.
Next winter I’ll take a look at the two thinner ‘trunks’ with a view to removing one each year.

I’ll keep this thread open to post pictures if/when in bloom and later if fruit appears!

Randy Winkman

22,833 posts

220 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
Yes - let us know. I'm genuinely interested in fruit tree pruning.

Tyndall

1,010 posts

166 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
I'm in the same position and have just done ours. I followed this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3pny3_5eE4


Edited by Tyndall on Thursday 13th March 14:48

paulrockliffe

16,677 posts

258 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
One thing to be mindful of is that pruning will encourage it to put out more shoots. So you can get in a bit of a vicious cycle where all the growth goes into shoots you need to prune next year, which causes more shoots..... I reckon I'd be aiming to get that under control over 3 seasons.

dhutch

17,963 posts

228 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
Kev_Mk3 said:
FlossyThePig said:
handy thanks
The RHS site is my first go to for so many things. Not always a lot of detail, but a good start, and a reliable source.