Shed: Plastic or wood?

Author
Discussion

Acuity30

Original Poster:

691 posts

33 months

On the market for a shed. Doesn't need to be anything fancy at all. Double doors would be nice for convenience. Just to keep a small mower, a few garden and power tools, maybe a step ladder, hose reel when not in use. Anything of significant value is kept in the garage.
Budget as cheap as possible without being pathetically built. Up to around £800 I'd say. Will be sat on grass so i'll need to budget for some sort of base also (which I know nothing about)
Minimal maintenance preferred which is why I'm considering a Keter, something like this:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Keter-Factor-Outdoor-Plas...

What would I be looking at cost wise for a base for it?

Previous

1,552 posts

169 months

5 years ago I was un a similar position, albeit looking for a cheap 6x4 ft shed, for similar purposes.

I bought a keter plastic thing, and laid it on some of those plastic grids filled with small stones (just google plastic base for shed)

It's been great. And no risk of rot.

Acuity30

Original Poster:

691 posts

33 months

Previous said:
5 years ago I was un a similar position, albeit looking for a cheap 6x4 ft shed, for similar purposes.

I bought a keter plastic thing, and laid it on some of those plastic grids filled with small stones (just google plastic base for shed)

It's been great. And no risk of rot.
Yea I think that's what I'll go for. Do you have to fill the grid with stones?

Simpo Two

88,982 posts

280 months

This base appeared alongside the shed info: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Garden-Greenhouse-Plastic...

richhead

2,499 posts

26 months

no base really needed for a plastic shed, mine was just plonked on the lawn, been 4 years now no problems, if you take the cost of a base into account it works out cheaper too.

Belle427

10,553 posts

248 months

Yesterday (06:34)
quotequote all
The Keter ones are very good, whatever you do don`t buy one of these or one that resembles it, its utterly hideous.
https://www.diy.com/departments/palram-canopia-sky...

Jamescrs

5,301 posts

80 months

Yesterday (06:36)
quotequote all
I have a Keter plastic shed, 6x4 I believe and had it a few years with no issues.
I recall building it alone and it wasn’t bad at all.

Jamescrs

5,301 posts

80 months

Yesterday (08:27)
quotequote all
I have a Keter plastic shed, 6x4 I believe and had it a few years with no issues.
I recall building it alone and it wasn’t bad at all.

beambeam1

1,499 posts

58 months

Yesterday (10:42)
quotequote all
Mine is tucked away almost out of site and behind the garage so I was happy to pursue the Keter plastic option. It was light enough that when assembled on the lawn two of us were able to lift it with straps and manoeuvre it into place. It's possible to assemble on your own but an extra pair of hands at the ceiling stage is useful. If you do go for it, there are discount codes on their site all the time such as 10% for joining the mailing list, etc.



Edited by beambeam1 on Monday 7th July 10:54

DonkeyApple

62,509 posts

184 months

Yesterday (11:12)
quotequote all
If it can be masked from general view then a plastic keter shed is going to make a lot of sense.

Frimley111R

17,063 posts

249 months

Yesterday (11:14)
quotequote all
Jamescrs said:
I have a Keter plastic shed, 6x4 I believe and had it a few years with no issues.
I recall building it alone and it wasn t bad at all.
Did the same, it was like a big kids toy really, just click it all together.

Acuity30

Original Poster:

691 posts

33 months

Yesterday (15:59)
quotequote all
beambeam1 said:
Mine is tucked away almost out of site and behind the garage so I was happy to pursue the Keter plastic option. It was light enough that when assembled on the lawn two of us were able to lift it with straps and manoeuvre it into place. It's possible to assemble on your own but an extra pair of hands at the ceiling stage is useful. If you do go for it, there are discount codes on their site all the time such as 10% for joining the mailing list, etc.



Edited by beambeam1 on Monday 7th July 10:54
Looks smart and no more unsightly than a wooden shed after a couple of winters, they all tend to look crap after then. That will always look the same for years to come though, might just need a bit of a jetwash once in a while. That's also the model I was looking at. Double doors on a wooden shed are significantly more expensive for similar sizes.
Keter it is. I suppose I can have a go at DIYing a base. I supposed all I need is a spade to dig up 5cm worth of grass and soil, a rake to level it and a plank of wood with a spirit level to make sure it's flat.
Make it flat, throw a weed membrane on, assemble the plastic interlocking base, then fill the compartments with about 50kg of 10mm pebbles. I'd guess around £100-150 all in for the base

alangla

5,644 posts

196 months

Yesterday (16:14)
quotequote all
Acuity30 said:
Looks smart and no more unsightly than a wooden shed after a couple of winters, they all tend to look crap after then. That will always look the same for years to come though, might just need a bit of a jetwash once in a while. That's also the model I was looking at. Double doors on a wooden shed are significantly more expensive for similar sizes.
Keter it is. I suppose I can have a go at DIYing a base. I supposed all I need is a spade to dig up 5cm worth of grass and soil, a rake to level it and a plank of wood with a spirit level to make sure it's flat.
Make it flat, throw a weed membrane on, assemble the plastic interlocking base, then fill the compartments with about 50kg of 10mm pebbles. I'd guess around £100-150 all in for the base
I think you might be underestimating a bit. I’ve got an 8x6 shed sitting on shed grids filled with 10mm pebbles, up to the top and buried all round. I reckon I probably used about 40% of a bulk (800kg?) bag just filling the grids and building a bit of a shoulder around them. The 10mm pebbles do provide a fairly attractive (and cheap!) bit of landscaping to conceal the plastic base, so it’s definitely an approach I’d recommend.

Acuity30

Original Poster:

691 posts

33 months

Yesterday (18:34)
quotequote all
alangla said:
I think you might be underestimating a bit. I ve got an 8x6 shed sitting on shed grids filled with 10mm pebbles, up to the top and buried all round. I reckon I probably used about 40% of a bulk (800kg?) bag just filling the grids and building a bit of a shoulder around them. The 10mm pebbles do provide a fairly attractive (and cheap!) bit of landscaping to conceal the plastic base, so it s definitely an approach I d recommend.
That's a lot of pebbles. Is their purpose just for drainage? Be curious to see a photo if it's not too much bother. When done right it does look quite good

Condi

18,779 posts

186 months

Yesterday (22:38)
quotequote all
Acuity30 said:
Looks smart and no more unsightly than a wooden shed after a couple of winters, they all tend to look crap after then.
Would disagree, you can paint a wooden shed and with an occasional over-coat it will last many years looking similar to how it went up.

6x4 wooden shed £375. Add in a base (do that bit properly) and you're about £600 or so.

Plastic shed is fine behind the garage or whatever, but wood is better in almost every other way to my eyes.

Acuity30

Original Poster:

691 posts

33 months

Yesterday (23:23)
quotequote all
Condi said:
Would disagree, you can paint a wooden shed and with an occasional over-coat it will last many years looking similar to how it went up.

6x4 wooden shed £375. Add in a base (do that bit properly) and you're about £600 or so.

Plastic shed is fine behind the garage or whatever, but wood is better in almost every other way to my eyes.
Viewed a few today and the plastic ones just look like clean wood. Most shed suppliers require an annual overcoat and you can't exactly coat the underside where they all eventually rot. Quite dated looking too

Condi

18,779 posts

186 months

Yesterday (23:27)
quotequote all
But what does the plastic one look like in 8 years time? My wooden one gets a coat of paint every 3 years and still looks pretty much like new. If you have a good base then they should last 15/20 years before rotting.

Don't get me wrong, if I was putting a shed behind the garage like the picture above a plastic shed would be grand, but if people are going to see it then (IMO) a wooden shed looks nicer and can be kept in a better condition for longer than a plastic one which will eventually fade in the sun.

OutInTheShed

11,300 posts

41 months

Yesterday (23:50)
quotequote all
It's a shed.
It will look like shed new, it will look like an older shed as time goes on.
Whatever it's made of, rarely the best thing to dominate the view from the house.
Plant something in front of it?

Cheap wooden sheds can be bargains, or flimsy bits of rubbish.

Down here, it can be damp a lot and wood needs a lot of care if it's going to last.

Some people are talking about 4x6 sheds, some people 8x6, no surprise that prices vary.
A quality wooden 8x6 shed is probably similar price to the Keter.
Around the covid era, wood got pricey and plastic and metal sheds were better value, and actually available.

Some of the better metal sheds may be worth considering, some of the cheap ones rust.

A look on FB marketplace suggests Keter sheds fade but hang together for a long time, wooden sheds vary in their durability.
Pay your money, take your choice!

Personally, I'd probably choose wood, but there's a good case for plastic or metal if access for paint/treatment will be awkward, like if the shed is nicely hidden by plants.

Acuity30

Original Poster:

691 posts

33 months

Condi said:
But what does the plastic one look like in 8 years time? My wooden one gets a coat of paint every 3 years and still looks pretty much like new. If you have a good base then they should last 15/20 years before rotting.

Don't get me wrong, if I was putting a shed behind the garage like the picture above a plastic shed would be grand, but if people are going to see it then (IMO) a wooden shed looks nicer and can be kept in a better condition for longer than a plastic one which will eventually fade in the sun.
They can fade a bit over many years, but the plastic is easily paintable so can just paint it after 8 years if you want. I don't think an aged wooden shed looks nicer than something like this:

https://www.costco.co.uk/medias/sys_master/images/...

I'd hate to be so self conscious as to actively make effort to 'hide' it in fear of what the neighbours might think too. More pity them if that becomes talk of the town for the next month rolleyes

beambeam1

1,499 posts

58 months

Condi said:
But what does the plastic one look like in 8 years time? My wooden one gets a coat of paint every 3 years and still looks pretty much like new. If you have a good base then they should last 15/20 years before rotting.

Don't get me wrong, if I was putting a shed behind the garage like the picture above a plastic shed would be grand, but if people are going to see it then (IMO) a wooden shed looks nicer and can be kept in a better condition for longer than a plastic one which will eventually fade in the sun.


This one sat directly under a tree in the corner of my decking from 2015-2023 when I brought it with me to the new house. Brushed it off with a stiff brush and hit it on all sides with the Nilfisk and almost as good as new again.

The Keter shed products are a much better product than the small patio storage boxes they also do and that is probably the reference point for most people.

I’m with you though, Condi, a proper wooden shed will always look much nicer . My brother installed one at the start of spring and I’m a little jealous…



I’m not sure on the metal sheds as a former colleague described his crumpling like tinfoil during high winds but they don’t seem to be as readily available or advertised as typical wooden or Keter options so never thought much more about them.