How would you like to die?

How would you like to die?

Author
Discussion

Papa Hotel

Original Poster:

12,760 posts

184 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
From my experience, there are two ways in which we die - a slow downhill mess or a one-day-you're-here-and-the-next-you're-not quickie death.

I've watched grandparents take years to die an undignified death and it almost come as a relief when they finally shuffle off. On the other side, last year my father was alive and healthy on Sunday morning and buried by Friday afternoon. While this quick death caused untold heartache that I'm still not dealing with very well, I have a friend whose father has had a stroke and is now in a pretty bad physical way but not really getting better or worse. The poor guy is in his 50s and will be a burden on his family for probably the next 20-30 years. Every day I'm thankful that my father never had to suffer any indignity in death although despite any hardships my friend is going through, his dad is still here and mine isn't.

So, I'm not asking whether you want to die in a great fireball or something heroic, I'm asking if you'd like to die unexpectedly and quickly or grip on to every little thread of life as long as you can. Think from the point of view of your family too.

Me, I don't know. There is a lot to be said for a dignified quick death and every day I'm thankful my father had one of those... but every day I resent it.

Papa Hotel

Original Poster:

12,760 posts

184 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Ganglandboss said:
Peacefully in my sleep like Granddad - not screaming and shouting like his passengers.

getmecoat
I almost posted this joke in the OP...

Papa Hotel

Original Poster:

12,760 posts

184 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Cock Womble said:
TheCarpetCleaner said:
Thing is, being brutal about it, once you are dead, you never even knew you existed - just gone. So it wouldn't matter much anyway.


It's not like you will be looking down going "Oooo that was a bit of a crap way to go - DOH"
Good point.

When we're dead, we won't care how we died.
Well even if you don't believe in life after death, the original post did ask you to consider the thoughts of your family. Or maybe you don't care about them either?

Papa Hotel

Original Poster:

12,760 posts

184 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
TheCarpetCleaner said:
Papa Hotel said:
Cock Womble said:
TheCarpetCleaner said:
Thing is, being brutal about it, once you are dead, you never even knew you existed - just gone. So it wouldn't matter much anyway.


It's not like you will be looking down going "Oooo that was a bit of a crap way to go - DOH"
Good point.

When we're dead, we won't care how we died.
Well even if you don't believe in life after death, the original post did ask you to consider the thoughts of your family. Or maybe you don't care about them either?
No, it's just irrelavent. When you are dead, you won't exist anymore, and being that existance is utterly meaningless in its entirity, and the feelings of others are merely a byproduct of this meaningless existance, then the whole thread question - not only the part about family, is fundimentally pointless.

As was my reply.

Carry on...
So you genuinely don't care about the future heartache of your family?

Some people believe and hope there is something after you die but I wouldn't be so arrogant to tell people of either the yes or no camp that they're wrong. What makes you think you have all the answers? Tell me why there is no life afterwards, how are you so sure?

Papa Hotel

Original Poster:

12,760 posts

184 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
TheCarpetCleaner said:
It's all totally irrelavent at the end of the day.
It's not though. Well, I'm happy with my beliefs, you're happy with your impending nothing, we'll agree to disagree and leave it at that.

Papa Hotel

Original Poster:

12,760 posts

184 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
deviant said:
Papa Hotel said:
Tell me why there is no life afterwards, how are you so sure?
I'm sure becuase I went there. The light fades and you die and there is nothing on the other side. When I think back to that day I remember lying on the bottom of the pool amd my vision closing in and then there is nothing until I woke up to my hysterical parents and several exhausted people that had spent the last few minutes bringing me back.
There is no memory of blackness or time passing or anything...the best way to describe it that I can think of is to ask if you have ever had an operation that required you to be fully unconcious? Its like when you are given the anaesthetic, you remember going to sleep and you remember waking up but there is no memory of anything in between...not sure if this make sense?
Well, it was a question about life after death... the thing is, you aren't dead. They might have said "you died" but you didn't. Your heart might have stopped, brain activity might have slowed but human bodies do not just come back to life from being truly dead.