City Dwellers: What runabout for petrolheads?

City Dwellers: What runabout for petrolheads?

Author
Discussion

jimmybell

Original Poster:

599 posts

123 months

Sunday 7th February 2016
quotequote all
Calling anyone that lives in a large city, commutes largely on public transport and when you do get in the car you end up spending time sat in city traffic doing daily tasks, yet you still aspire to own a special vehicle...

What's your idea of a daily runabout that's practical, comfortable, small enough for city life parked on a street - but still ticks the petrolhead box?

Things you or i might do in a runabout:

Drive to Sainsburys and do the weekly shop when hurricane imogen makes walking uncomfortable,
Buy some stuff in ikea,
Visit some friends or family out of town,
Drive to the golf course,
Bug out of the city for a quick b-road blast,
Go away for the weekend,
Chuck some mountain bikes in the back and find some trails,
Commute on a Friday when you can't face the tube...

Whilst we'd all love to do this in a V12 fezza, or the most favoured 911 GT3, this isn't the most practical and eventually you might want to carry something other than yourself - What's the best car for this job?






caelite

4,282 posts

118 months

Sunday 7th February 2016
quotequote all
Fiesta ST, Twingo/Clio RS, Colt Ralliart, Abarth Punto/500.

A fair few baby hot hatches about that are more than quick enough for B roads whilst also being small and easy to maneaver around cities. Also being baby hatches they have the added advantage of cheap body panels for when when someone drives into it in the Sainsburys car park.

EDIT: Oh I just read a couple more of your criteria. Get a roof rack for the bikes and you will most likely need to fold down a back seat for a set of golf clubs. Ikea... rent a Fiat Doblo for £40.

sebhaque

6,495 posts

187 months

Sunday 7th February 2016
quotequote all
Really depends on your budget, you could spend £30k on a 911, £20k on an M6, £10k on an Impreza or £2k on a Clio 182 and they'd all fulfil what you wanted to do. The 911 may struggle on bikes but you get the point.

I've moved into London so I've steadily lost the nice cars and will end up with a ~£2k toy - at the moment it's a Clio 182 that's top of the list.

Of course there are always practical cars that are somewhat fun to drive - think Volvo T5 or Merc C320; lower end of the budget, but great for versatility and alright for performance.


anonymous-user

60 months

Sunday 7th February 2016
quotequote all
This is a large part of why I ended up with the Alpina B3 (old, cheap E46 version). In the real world it's a great car for the exact conditions the OP described. Could do a few mpg more but not really an issue on low mileage. Lovely to be in, a little bit special, sounds fab and is low key too. And auto. I'm done with manuals for London!

Blanchimont

4,078 posts

128 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
caelite said:
Fiesta ST, Twingo/Clio RS, Colt Ralliart, Abarth Punto/500.

A fair few baby hot hatches about that are more than quick enough for B roads whilst also being small and easy to maneaver around cities. Also being baby hatches they have the added advantage of cheap body panels for when when someone drives into it in the Sainsburys car park.

EDIT: Oh I just read a couple more of your criteria. Get a roof rack for the bikes and you will most likely need to fold down a back seat for a set of golf clubs. Ikea... rent a Fiat Doblo for £40.
I had the Abarth Punto's baby brother, The Fiat Grande Punto T-Jet.

It shares the same engine with the A500/AGP, but has a slightly smaller turbo. It was still mega fun though.

Did Ikea trips in it. Mrs had to sit behind me, which was funny.
Sainsburys trips were no problem.
I could park it up and not worry about it getting vandalized.

http://www.pistonheads.com/regulars/ph-carpool/fia...

That was a carpool of mine.

Krikkit

26,951 posts

187 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
Something automatic for the times when you're stuck in traffic imo. Golf GTI with DSG?

Gary C

13,109 posts

185 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
Mk1 MR2!

Don't laugh, it used to be my only car and did everything!

Only difficulty was large diy, but most deliver now.

Great commuter car, so as such I would now say get an Elise!


Hum, bikes. Toyota did a roof rack for the MR2, not sure about lotus.

Actus Reus

4,238 posts

161 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
Mk.1 MX5.

Might struggle with the bikes, but everything else is just a fold of the roof from fitting in the passenger seat. Your missus can get the bus (and anyway, who plays golf with the wife?).

jimmybell

Original Poster:

599 posts

123 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
Considering i currently drive a Z4 M Coupe, and that's considered not practical enough (although has done an admiral job over the years, ikea included) - i guess that counts out ideas on the MR2/MX5 scale, though appreciate the effort justifying a mk1 MX5.

I tend to find the main difficulty is the natural contrast between 'small city practicality' and 'visit family/friends long distances away in comfort', thus i'm settling on ideas like the latest RS3, M135i, Golf GTI/R etc - but they're all a much bigger commitment than some decent second hand bargains, so before i put my money down on an overpriced RS3, i'm wondering if there's any interesting alternatives.

PomBstard

7,079 posts

248 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
Forester XT - should tick just about all your boxes. The version up to 2008 was small enough to be nifty round city streets, but big enough for the IKEA trip and mtbs, esp with roof racks. Suspension deals with speed bumps effortlessly, and its a hoot on B roads.

parabolica

6,800 posts

190 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
I fit your criteria exactly OP (apart from the mountain biking, can't be doing with that); live in one of the most congested parts of our capital on an incredibly narrow street... and I have a 645ci which I can't bear to part with. Ticks every box I need.

Prof Prolapse

16,160 posts

196 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
Golf GTI. Jack of all trades, master of none.

You can even do blasts in the country and motorway jaunts in relative comfort.

DonkeyApple

58,456 posts

175 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
If I had to park a car on the street then I'd just buy a Dacia Duster for urban work to be honest.

Prof Prolapse

16,160 posts

196 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
My Mrs saw the advert for the Dacia last night and goes "why would they name a car after something you clean your house with?"

anonymous-user

60 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
Just buy what you want.

Hundreds of Thousands of people drive Buses, Trucks and Vans use the roads in tight and congested cities every day, usually without major incident or issue.

You're more likely huge Rolls Royces and Range Rovers or expensive Ferraris or Lamborghinis parked on and driven along some of the tightest Victorian streets in Central London than most places in the World.

I don't buy into this idea that you cannot have a nice/interesting/large car just because you happen to live in a City.

devnull

3,789 posts

163 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
Lupo GTi, but they seem to rocket in price by the dub scene

Baryonyx

18,063 posts

165 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
Maximise the satisfaction and fun you get from all aspects of motoring rather than trying to cover them all at once with one vehicle. Get a decent car for around town. Something that costs nothing to run, is comfortable, reliable, practical and nice to drive. A Prius or Insight would be ideal. They are fantastic in town, a pleasure to drive. There isn't much I'd prefer as a practical proposition.

With the money you've saved and the Zen of calm you've accumulated in a suitable car, go wild and get a decent motorbike. A Daytona 675R, a Suzuki GSXR1000, an Aprilia RSV, a Ducati 888 or whatever. You'll have loads of fun on the most focused performance machines you can buy, and may find contentment far above what one car trying to cover all based will offer.

Prof Prolapse

16,160 posts

196 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
279 said:
I don't buy into this idea that you cannot have a nice/interesting/large car just because you happen to live in a City.
Then you've either never lived in one, only lived in a particularly nice part of one, or had off street parking.







jamiebae

6,245 posts

217 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
I drive a Range Rover Evoque Si4, partly because I have a 2 year old and like to go skiing at weekends but it still ticks most of the boxes. For me the most important thing is the interior, and the car 'feeling special' which the RR does far better than an Audi Q3 or other similar small 4x4s.

Without the kid and skiing requirements though I'd have a Mini Cooper S (Clubman if the space is important) with an auto box of course. The Abarth 500 would have been an option but the auto is utterly undriveable so plan B would be a RenaultSport Clio, or maybe a budget busting M135i if I was feeling extra flush.

DonkeyApple

58,456 posts

175 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
279 said:
Just buy what you want.

Hundreds of Thousands of people drive Buses, Trucks and Vans use the roads in tight and congested cities every day, usually without major incident or issue.

You're more likely huge Rolls Royces and Range Rovers or expensive Ferraris or Lamborghinis parked on and driven along some of the tightest Victorian streets in Central London than most places in the World.

I don't buy into this idea that you cannot have a nice/interesting/large car just because you happen to live in a City.
And yet you don't see the owners parking them day in day out in residential streets or in shopping car parks.

If you really want car A but recognise that car B is appropriate for what you will actually be using it for then there doesn't seem any logic in blowing more money than needed when it's something you don't really aspire to owning. Just get something cheap and cheerful that you don't give a damn about the 70m cretinous low life's that you share this country with who will be smashing it up and turning it to crap within a few years.