Bikes and Euro Tunnel Vs Ferries

Bikes and Euro Tunnel Vs Ferries

Author
Discussion

Snapper7

Original Poster:

990 posts

273 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
I am new to biking and will have my first bike next month. The bike will be a Victory Vegas (Cruiser) which will only have a side stand (No Centre Stand).

I was wondering which is the best method for crossing the channel to France with this sort of bike. (Will be two up with Luggage).

Euro Tunnel looks the cheapest method although when I have traveled in the past in sports cars I have have always used the ferry.

I was wondering if people here could offer some advice as to what provisions both the ferries and Euro Tunnel have for bikers and for securing bikes so they don't get damaged.

All advice will be gratefully received.

moto_traxport

4,247 posts

235 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
Eurotunnel every time if you're worried about your bike although I've never had a problem with the ferries their method of tying bikes down can worry the anally retentive.

With Eurotunnel you sit with the bikes. Only problem I've ever had is when the train jiggles over some points on the loop and a top heavy bike on a dodgy sidestand (early Aprilia Mille RSV-R or Firestorm with silly length Ohlins in it) can use a steadying hand over this bit. A cruiser will have no worries whatsoever. Harley's with their lock type sidestands will never run forward off the stand - assume Victories have same idea? If not just stick it in gear.

Half hour chat with other bikers, study map on Eurotunnel or an hour and forty minute trip wandering around in leathers looking at stuff I don't want to buy, kids running around screaming, overly-expensive brekkie scratchchin

The only thing the tunnel lacks is sense of occasion - cliffs of Dover sort of thing. I've long got over that.

Stone Cold

1,546 posts

187 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
moto_traxport said:
Eurotunnel every time if you're worried about your bike although I've never had a problem with the ferries their method of tying bikes down can worry the anally retentive.

With Eurotunnel you sit with the bikes. Only problem I've ever had is when the train jiggles over some points on the loop and a top heavy bike on a dodgy sidestand (early Aprilia Mille RSV-R or Firestorm with silly length Ohlins in it) can use a steadying hand over this bit. A cruiser will have no worries whatsoever. Harley's with their lock type sidestands will never run forward off the stand - assume Victories have same idea? If not just stick it in gear.

Half hour chat with other bikers, study map on Eurotunnel or an hour and forty minute trip wandering around in leathers looking at stuff I don't want to buy, kids running around screaming, overly-expensive brekkie scratchchin

The only thing the tunnel lacks is sense of occasion - cliffs of Dover sort of thing. I've long got over that.
Nothing to add the above is spot on, I have done it several times with cars and bikes and it is a doddle, I would not willingly use the ferry again

podman

8,972 posts

254 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
moto_traxport said:
Eurotunnel every time if you're worried about your bike although I've never had a problem with the ferries their method of tying bikes down can worry the anally retentive.

With Eurotunnel you sit with the bikes. Only problem I've ever had is when the train jiggles over some points on the loop and a top heavy bike on a dodgy sidestand (early Aprilia Mille RSV-R or Firestorm with silly length Ohlins in it) can use a steadying hand over this bit. A cruiser will have no worries whatsoever. Harley's with their lock type sidestands will never run forward off the stand - assume Victories have same idea? If not just stick it in gear.

Half hour chat with other bikers, study map on Eurotunnel or an hour and forty minute trip wandering around in leathers looking at stuff I don't want to buy, kids running around screaming, overly-expensive brekkie scratchchin

The only thing the tunnel lacks is sense of occasion - cliffs of Dover sort of thing. I've long got over that.
Well put..I prefer the ferry for that sense of occasion, it is a more "exciting" way to start your holiday I think, its also quite a lot cheaper than the tunnel but no doubt being in France in 30odd mins is nice..but if your not in a rush, i still prefer the ferry but again the tunnel takes the gamble out of bad weather delaying an outward/return trip.

Personally ive only ever had that happen once but I too am now a tunnel convert

EvoBarry

1,903 posts

279 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
Tunnel everytime, quick, simple and you stay with the bikes so you can keep an eye on things. Less chance of the operatives damaging things throwing tie straps everywhere too (as there aren't any!).


Hooli

32,278 posts

214 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
I've not used the tunnel but boats are fine. Bike on the sidestand & in gear rolled forward till it hits compression. Then there is a tie-down strap over the seat, never had a problem with mine moving yet & I've done boats to Spain too.

Snapper7

Original Poster:

990 posts

273 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
Hmm thats a lot of weight and hardwear flying about if the train throws the brakes on......

Edited by Snapper7 on Sunday 6th February 17:13

Hooli

32,278 posts

214 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
Snapper7 said:
Hmm thats a lot of weight and hardwear flying about if the train through the brakes on......
Only bikers to squash though & since when have we been important? hehe

sjtscott

4,215 posts

245 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
I've used both, the tunnel is far less hassle so wins for me each and every time. The only two reasons not to use the tunnel, you're a tight git and you don't have any hurry. LOL
Personally the less f**king about possible the better, too much of that with ferries for my liking smile

They ferry does win for trips to Northern Spain though wink

black-k1

12,439 posts

243 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
podman said:
Well put..I prefer the ferry for that sense of occasion, it is a more "exciting" way to start your holiday I think, its also quite a lot cheaper than the tunnel but no doubt being in France in 30odd mins is nice..but if your not in a rush, i still prefer the ferry but again the tunnel takes the gamble out of bad weather delaying an outward/return trip.

Personally ive only ever had that happen once but I too am now a tunnel convert
Ferry for me too. Bikes on the train aren't tied down so if the train has to brake sharply they'll all fall over. The over the seat rachet strap on the ferry means the ferry could turn upside down and the bike would still stay put.

Add to that the fact that you can have a meal on the ferry, there's somewhere comfortable to sit, you have the ability to have a walk and get some fresh air and thus be totally set up for a days riding when you get off. Oh, and that the ferry is almost always much cheaper so you have a much better way to travel to France.

EvoBarry

1,903 posts

279 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
Its like the last chap said, if you're in a hurry and what relatively hassle free transport to France, the train wins imo. If you want to make more of an event of the crossing/want food/rest then ferry is a nice alternative. I preferred being able to stand with the bike as they're largely unprotected in the ship and I don't want the hassle of removing valuables from the bike for the sake of half n hour. IF the train has to perform an emergency stop I suspect there'd be bigger things on my mind than picking the bikes up?

TimmyWimmyWoo

4,345 posts

195 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
I've only done the crossing once (return) and we used P&O – they have dedicated bike areas with three 'troughs' side by side. You just ride in, stay on your bike while one of their guys comes and ties your bike down, off you hop with the bike upright and hey presto!

We caught a 5am ferry, so we'd been up riding since 1am – the 1.5 hour break/wakeup on the ferry was appreciated. I think it was £35 return too.

ask the sheep

18 posts

173 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
I'd take the train every time. You can get a good deal swapping tesco vouchers 3:1 I think it is now. You can always break up your journey by getting breakfast at the terminal.

Andy XRV

3,884 posts

194 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
Ferry for me too. I'm a little bit claustrophobic and although I've used the train in the past I'm really not a big fan. And as for price, I've just booked 6 bikes on a seven day return and the ferry was roughly 25/bike cheaper than the train.

psychoR1

1,093 posts

201 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
Tunnel every time for me.

IMHO the tunnel is less susceptible to delays than the ferry's and waiting on a windswept dock is no fun.

Ferry is good if you want a longer break and the opportunity to eat something.

I've never seen a bike topple on the train....yet

sjtscott

4,215 posts

245 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
Ferry for me too. Bikes on the train aren't tied down so if the train has to brake sharply they'll all fall over. The over the seat rachet strap on the ferry means the ferry could turn upside down and the bike would still stay put.

Add to that the fact that you can have a meal on the ferry, there's somewhere comfortable to sit, you have the ability to have a walk and get some fresh air and thus be totally set up for a days riding when you get off. Oh, and that the ferry is almost always much cheaper so you have a much better way to travel to France.
So how many times have you used the train and how many times have you had or seen a bike fall over?
I'm really interested since I've used it lots over the past 10 years and the only bike to ever have to keep an eye on was my Aprila Falco due to the ste stand (just like the RSV mentioned before).

black-k1

12,439 posts

243 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
sjtscott said:
black-k1 said:
Ferry for me too. Bikes on the train aren't tied down so if the train has to brake sharply they'll all fall over. The over the seat rachet strap on the ferry means the ferry could turn upside down and the bike would still stay put.

Add to that the fact that you can have a meal on the ferry, there's somewhere comfortable to sit, you have the ability to have a walk and get some fresh air and thus be totally set up for a days riding when you get off. Oh, and that the ferry is almost always much cheaper so you have a much better way to travel to France.
So how many times have you used the train and how many times have you had or seen a bike fall over?
I'm really interested since I've used it lots over the past 10 years and the only bike to ever have to keep an eye on was my Aprila Falco due to the ste stand (just like the RSV mentioned before).
I've used the train a couple of times and not seen a bike fall over, however, I was not comfortable with my bike ‘wobbling around’ on its side stand while the train went through the tunnel. I did not feel safe and I ended up feeling I had to sit on the bike or stand and hold it for most of the journey.

As I live 2 hours from Dover and almost always travel for at least 2 hours on the Calais side, I want the channel crossing to be a chance for me to take a break, relax and prepare my self for the next leg of my trip. I can’t do this on the train but I can on the ferry.

dern

14,055 posts

293 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
Used the train twice and wouldn't hesitate to use it again... fast and hassle free.

I'd rather find a cafe to eat/drink when I get there than the overpriced crap they serve on the ferries.

G Man

4,053 posts

274 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
Train .... much less hassle and quicker

308mate

13,758 posts

236 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
Tunnel is brilliant for a quick hassle free crossing, but consider your route. If youre starting in Exeter and heading to the Pyrenees, it makes no sense at all. If youre starting to Exeter and heading to the 'ring, it makes more sense but consider whether you want to spend more time riding East in England or in France.

If your schedule requires a ferry crossing, the ferry guys will tie it down for you when you board. You will wake up in your cabin with a headache after the piss-up in the bar the night before and have exactly 2 mins to get up, get into your leathers, get to the front of the queue at the doors to the garage, re-fit your luggage, untie your bike (you do that bit yourself), put your gloves on, take your gloves off, put your helmet on, put your gloves on, bimble down the wet, painted steel ramp in to the port. Whilst all that is going on, car drivers with no special clothes to put on, no luggage to refit and no vehicle to untie, will be squeezing past you and your p&j with mm to spare and some filthy looks.

It has its plus and minuses.