Apparently I've been jumping red lights forever

Apparently I've been jumping red lights forever

Author
Discussion

ndreaw

Original Poster:

20 posts

4 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
If I'm stopped at a red light, I go the second the amber illuminates. I don't wait for green, and I never noticed anyone else doing it differently to me. From reading a dash cam thread in another part of the forum people are bashing the driver for going on amber instead of green.
Have I really been doing it wrong this entire time?? I must have been doing it around police cars at some point, and have gone through MANY red light cameras without any issue.

fttm

1,768 posts

79 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
ndreaw said:
If I'm stopped at a red light, I go the second the amber illuminates. I don't wait for green, and I never noticed anyone else doing it differently to me. From reading a dash cam thread in another part of the forum people are bashing the driver for going on amber instead of green.
Have I really been doing it wrong this entire time?? I must have been doing it around police cars at some point, and have gone through MANY red light cameras without any issue.


How clever of you rolleyes

ndreaw

Original Poster:

20 posts

4 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
fttm said:
How clever of you rolleyes
Just looking for serious input on whether this is actually wrong. I learned to drive in London and you'd just get honked at if you waited for the green.

NGee

585 posts

108 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
Maybe you should buy yourself a copy of the Highway Code - you obviously need one!

M4cruiser

1,743 posts

94 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
ndreaw said:
fttm said:
How clever of you rolleyes
Just looking for serious input on whether this is actually wrong. I learned to drive in London and you'd just get honked at if you waited for the green.
Serious input: Of course it's wrong to go when the red is showing. It says that somewhere in the Highway Code.

Is this a serious thread!???? eekbiggrin

Whilst on the subject, what's everyone's view on why we still have a red-and-amber phase at all, when some countries don't?

giantdefy

444 posts

57 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
ndreaw said:
Just looking for serious input on whether this is actually wrong. I learned to drive in London and you'd just get honked at if you waited for the green.
I never go on amber and definitely would not do it in London. All you need is a 'it's amber so I can go' to meet a 'its only a bit red so go' (v common in London) to meet.

ndreaw

Original Poster:

20 posts

4 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
giantdefy said:
I never go on amber and definitely would not do it in London. All you need is a 'it's amber so I can go' to meet a 'its only a bit red so go' (v common in London) to meet.
It's a lot worse than "it's a bit red so go" in London - I walked up to a pedestrian crossing the other week when I was down there that had been showing a green man for a couple of seconds, crossed and when I was in the middle of the road almost got ran over by a woman in a leased AMG trim A class. I gave the car a good whack though.

garyhun

27,283 posts

172 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
You can proceed on flashing amber, not on fixed amber.

WonkeyDonkey

504 posts

47 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
I think the people slated the DCW because he floored it on amber to almost run into someone else still crossing a junction.

Jonnny

28,839 posts

133 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
Amber to Green is what, 1 second? Can't see it making much difference unless you're in a Tesla or Bugatti.

My 60hp Polo takes more than the Amber>Green time to even start moving.. I start lifting the clutch, off brake at Amber.

Cliftonite

7,032 posts

82 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
M4cruiser said:
Serious input: Of course it's wrong to go when the red is showing. It says that somewhere in the Highway Code.

Is this a serious thread!???? eekbiggrin

Whilst on the subject, what's everyone's view on why we still have a red-and-amber phase at all, when some countries don't?
Omission of the red-and-amber phase was trialled in Northampton (and perhaps elsewhere) some decades ago (circa 1970?) but clearly did not lead to changes.



meatballs

184 posts

4 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
ndreaw said:
If I'm stopped at a red light, I go the second the amber illuminates. I don't wait for green, and I never noticed anyone else doing it differently to me. From reading a dash cam thread in another part of the forum people are bashing the driver for going on amber instead of green.
Have I really been doing it wrong this entire time?? I must have been doing it around police cars at some point, and have gone through MANY red light cameras without any issue.
Oh my. How long have you been driving?

You know it doesn't go amber after red right?

mac96

1,494 posts

87 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
It's quite clear really- green means go; red and amber means it will soon be green so wake up,but stay stopped.
Nevertheless at many junctions with good visibility, starting to creep on red and amber may not actually matter- but why take the risk, it will save you, what, 2 seconds?
OP's example from the dashcam thread showed someone accelerating firmly away on red and amber to deliberately create a near miss for dash cam footage, or for the fun of scaring the other driver. Looked like dangerous driving, not just light running.

SS2.

11,256 posts

182 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
ndreaw said:
If I'm stopped at a red light, I go the second the amber illuminates.
3 points & £100 waiting to happen.

JungTheForeman

12 posts

31 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
For reference the clip in question is this: https://youtu.be/gHXsXP1OXqI?t=104


flashbang

64 posts

18 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
Red and Amber together after red means stop. If you want help with the delay to green, when its red, handbrake on and into neutral. When it's red and Amber, by the time you engage gear and take handbrake off, it should be green.

ndreaw

Original Poster:

20 posts

4 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
SS2. said:
3 points & £100 waiting to happen.
its been years and i'm still waiting for my points and fine

Pica-Pica

5,532 posts

28 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
Nobody can ever ‘go on amber’, because in that phase there is always a ‘red and amber’ showing. With the red still showing with the amber, it is not therefore a signal to go. I have driven far and wide, and always wait for the green before I pass the stop line. Never once in all my years driving have I been ‘honked’ for that.

(Try going on red and amber, and you may get T-boned by a ‘red runner’, from right or left)

ndreaw

Original Poster:

20 posts

4 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
I'm starting to second-guess myself, I think I might have just completely forgotten what I actually do, and don't actually go on amber. As people have pointed out, the red must be showing as well, and I wouldn't be going on red.
Weekends aren't good for my brain, too much lying around.

Wilmslowboy

2,566 posts

150 months

Saturday 20th July
quotequote all
It's fine until you meet your twin.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H4TDEPP1R9Q




  • Amber gambler" for those of us a bit older biggrin