Most hauntingly beautiful song ever?

[Joyrider1]

Pieman68 said:

With an honourable mention for the live version of The Sound of Silence when Draiman duets with Myles Kennedy

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H3By4DZyTNM&li...

I’ve always loved the Disturbed version but that one takes it to a whole new level - Myles Kennedy is an incredible singer (that live version is also on Spotify)

[ScotHill]

Torch Song by Todd Rundgren is up there for me: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iJqDA7MZ_zU

[Trophy Husband]

The pills won't help you now, The Chemical Brothers with the beautiful voice of Tim Smith ex of Midlake.
My funeral song.
https://youtu.be/0hgELxiURLk

Needs to be heard start to finish as there are some wonderful uplifting crescendo moments.

[Fast and Spurious]

https://youtu.be/C2u4wOe_Jvs

[andyb28]

Pieman68 said:

T
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8SCCqC-u-9o - Hold on to memories by Disturbed (came out just before one of my best mates passed away at 46)

I have heard a number of other Disturbed songs, but not this one. Wow thats really something special.

[Trophy Husband]

andyb28 said:

Pieman68 said:

T
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8SCCqC-u-9o - Hold on to memories by Disturbed (came out just before one of my best mates passed away at 46)

I have heard a number of other Disturbed songs, but not this one. Wow thats really something special.

Sorry but it sounds like a Boyzone cover to my ears! Twee and schmaltzy. Neither haunting or beautiful. Each to their own of course.

[wibble cb]

Edge of darkness ,Eric Clapton live version from the 24 nights album, make my neck hairs tingle

[cherryowen]

Joyrider1 said:

Pieman68 said:

With an honourable mention for the live version of The Sound of Silence when Draiman duets with Myles Kennedy

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H3By4DZyTNM&li...

I’ve always loved the Disturbed version but that one takes it to a whole new level - Myles Kennedy is an incredible singer (that live version is also on Spotify)

Gersberms

[CubanPete]

Youth Groups cover of (Alphaville's) forever young

https://youtu.be/rQi8wEHMm5Y


Depeche Mode - somebody

https://youtu.be/jbaKcxTW7A8

[Hub]

Martin Grech - always haunting, frequently beautiful!

[tuscaneer]

Louis Balfour said:

tardelli said:

Hurt - Johnny Cash

Coincidentally my son was playing this on his guitar about half an hour ago. I am not sure it's beautiful, but haunting arguably. The video makes it more so.

the original by nine inch nails is WAY better

[Louis Balfour]

tuscaneer said:

Louis Balfour said:

tardelli said:

Hurt - Johnny Cash

Coincidentally my son was playing this on his guitar about half an hour ago. I am not sure it's beautiful, but haunting arguably. The video makes it more so.

the original by nine inch nails is WAY better

I could run with "different". I like the NIN version but it is more...gritty for want of a better description. Apparently they cleaned up the lyrics for JC, who I think did the song proud and the video was quite moving.

[tuscaneer]

Louis Balfour said:

I could run with "different". I like the NIN version but it is more...gritty for want of a better description. Apparently they cleaned up the lyrics for JC, who I think did the song proud and the video was quite moving.

undoubtedly a great version that could have turned out terrible.. i suppose it's a matter of timing.. when nine inch nails first appeared at the back end of the 80s with pretty hate machine i was hooked...a few years later when the downward spiral appeared trent reznor was etched into my soul.. i was so used to hearing hurt done his way anything else was never going to live up to it ..

[Patch1875]

tuscaneer said:

Louis Balfour said:

I could run with "different". I like the NIN version but it is more...gritty for want of a better description. Apparently they cleaned up the lyrics for JC, who I think did the song proud and the video was quite moving.

undoubtedly a great version that could have turned out terrible.. i suppose it's a matter of timing.. when nine inch nails first appeared at the back end of the 80s with pretty hate machine i was hooked...a few years later when the downward spiral appeared trent reznor was etched into my soul.. i was so used to hearing hurt done his way anything else was never going to live up to it ..

The quiet version on Further Down The Spiral tops them all for me.

[tuscaneer]

Patch1875 said:

The quiet version on Further Down The Spiral tops them all for me.

can't argue with that mate... the sparseness of "something i can never have" makes it my favourite NIN track although i must admit as a body of work "the fragile" is my favourite album.".la mer" and "the great below" are just stunning pieces of music

[WindyCommon]

Sorry if a repeat...

[WindyCommon]

And whilst we’re here...

[h0b0]

WindyCommon said:

Sorry if a repeat...

My first ring tone in the days you had to type in the notes to your Nokia 3210.

[Evoluzione]

WindyCommon said:

And whilst we’re here...

I get where you're coming from with that, but she's hauntingly beautiful and his vocal range is twice as good as hers.
Is it better than the original?

It is undoubtedly beautiful, but lacks the drama of the original.

Edited by Evoluzione on Thursday 4th March 00:24

[WindyCommon]

Evoluzione said:

I get where you're coming from with that, but she's hauntingly beautiful and his vocal range is twice as good as hers.
Is it better than the original?

Something about the way they harmonise, and the tonalities of their voices...