What’s the point in the Park function of a automatic?

What’s the point in the Park function of a automatic?

Author
Discussion

Nickbrapp

Original Poster:

5,277 posts

129 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
I was thinking today, manual cars have neutral, which most people use when they park, and the parking brake,

So why does an auto have park, neutral and parking brake?

You always see on tv especially in American programs they only use the transmission park, so why do we have both?

TonyRPH

12,963 posts

167 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
A manual left in gear will offer some roll resistance because the clutch is engaged and the engine compression will resist rolling to some degree.

An automatic left in gear has no clutch to engage, so can't offer any rolling resistance from the engine.

Hence the 'Park' facility, which engages a pawl in the gearbox to prevent the output shaft turning.


sooty61

686 posts

170 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
I would say most people use P when they park. I never use the handbrake

ScoobyChris

1,667 posts

201 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
sooty61 said:
I would say most people use P when they park. I never use the handbrake
In my car it engages P when the engine gets switched off anyway but I use the handbrake also. In manual cars, I’ll always leave it in gear with handbrake on.

Chris

Edited by ScoobyChris on Saturday 18th March 21:51

MDMA .

8,849 posts

100 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
If you didn’t have park, you couldn’t take your keys out the ignitionsmile

Nickbrapp

Original Poster:

5,277 posts

129 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
MDMA . said:
If you didn’t have park, you couldn’t take your keys out the ignitionsmile
But why do we have park

Why not leave an auto in neutral and use the parking brake the same as manual cars?

Silvanus

5,147 posts

22 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
MDMA . said:
If you didn’t have park, you couldn’t take your keys out the ignitionsmile
Not many modern cars have an ignition key. My work auto doesn't.

TonyRPH

12,963 posts

167 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
Nickbrapp said:
But why do we have park
See my post above - it's to provide additional assurance in addition to the handbrake - just like leaving a manual car in gear.


joropug

2,547 posts

188 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
Nickbrapp said:
But why do we have park

Why not leave an auto in neutral and use the parking brake the same as manual cars?
I guess the better question is why don’t manuals have park function.

In a manual I always leave in gear, on a flat I never used the handbrake (BMWs mostly that had awful handbrakes anyway)

In my torque converter auto I use the handbrake only if it’s going to roll back or forward, to take the pressure off.

Our DCT automatic however does park and handbrake simultaneously when you turn the engine off.

samoht

5,633 posts

145 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all

One of my cars has a dual clutch with no Park function at all, so you just put it into Neutral and then rely on the handbrake to secure the car. So that's a bit like what OP is saying.

I imagine that when torque converter autos first came out, handbrakes were less reliable than they are now and so leaving the car 'in gear' was more common, and so the autos needed some equivalent function to back up the handbrake.


Personally I prefer the way Nissan EVs work, if you brake it to a stop on the footbrake then the car will stay put until you explicitly request it to move, regardless of slope. Like, how often do you want a car to start rolling away?? So make it do the sensible thing by default.

Wacky Racer

38,099 posts

246 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
You should never leave a manual car parked up in neutral.

Always in first, plus apply the handbrake....No chance of the car rolling away.

Dogwatch

6,223 posts

221 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
Wacky Racer said:
You should never leave a manual car parked up in neutral.

Always in first, plus apply the handbrake....No chance of the car rolling away.
getmecoat

Higgs boson

1,091 posts

152 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
Wacky Racer said:
You should never leave a manual car parked up in neutral.

Always in first, plus apply the handbrake....No chance of the car rolling away.
If I'm facing downhill, I stick it in reverse. You likely do, too. smile

stevemcs

8,593 posts

92 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
We see quite a few automatic cars fail there mot because the owner never uses the handbrake, personally I always use the handbrake

Cliftonite

8,406 posts

137 months

Saturday 18th March 2023
quotequote all
Wacky Racer said:
You should never leave a manual car parked up in neutral.

Always in first, plus apply the handbrake....No chance of the car rolling away.
Seems this is too complex for the majority of drivers to fathom?

Why take the risk of a failed (or forgotten) handbrake when leaving a car in first (or reverse) gear is such a simple and effective way of nullifying it?

In a similar vein, using the handbrake in an automatic relives pressure on the gearbox pawl and reduces the risk of damage, e.g. when parked on a slope or if a collision occurs.


Second Best

6,402 posts

180 months

Sunday 19th March 2023
quotequote all
Cliftonite said:
Seems this is too complex for the majority of drivers to fathom?

Why take the risk of a failed (or forgotten) handbrake when leaving a car in first (or reverse) gear is such a simple and effective way of nullifying it?

In a similar vein, using the handbrake in an automatic relives pressure on the gearbox pawl and reduces the risk of damage, e.g. when parked on a slope or if a collision occurs.
When I learned to drive (in the late 2000s) I was taught handbrake and neutral, unless you're parked on a steep incline. Most of my non-petrolhead friends also leave their car in neutral when parked, sometimes it's caught them out when we've driven each other's cars and they've started it without checking if it's in gear. I find it funnier than they do.

Does anybody else here have an EV with a manual handbrake? I didn't think EVs were able to have a "Park" setting, so to speak, indeed mine just has R/N/D. Disengage the handbrake and you can push it around.

cootuk

918 posts

122 months

Sunday 19th March 2023
quotequote all
At least you don't have air brakes to worry about. We don't leave wagons stood long term in gear as, if they lose air pressure, you will find yourself trying to start it in gear until you can jolt it back to neutral.

Ninja59

3,691 posts

111 months

Sunday 19th March 2023
quotequote all
Modern automatic you pretty much cannot leave one or the other off. They both go on when the engine turns off.

But like a manual you can leave it in gear like am extra form of protection against rolling away.

ATG

20,485 posts

271 months

Sunday 19th March 2023
quotequote all
I don't trust the gearbox or the handbrake, so I chock the wheels and use an anchor or chain my car to a convenient piece of street furniture like a lollipop person or someone praying outside the VD clinic.

Twolane

67 posts

19 months

Sunday 19th March 2023
quotequote all
Wacky Racer said:
You should never leave a manual car parked up in neutral.

Always in first, plus apply the handbrake....No chance of the car rolling away.
My eldest daughters first car, an old Corsa almost rolled away.
Our drive is a slope downwards and opposite a tee junction, the road continues downhill for about 100 metres.
Handbrake cable snapped overnight and she hadn't left it in gear, luckily though it had a slight left lock on the steering and just gently came to rest against a fence.