Drive your pension... investment car

Drive your pension... investment car

Author
Discussion

Shnozz

Original Poster:

28,412 posts

282 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
I have a good pal who bought a certain red Italian classic that he has now had a decade or so and watched it steadily rise in value. His plan was that it would form part of his pension that he could get the enjoyment from for a few decades and then, as older years thwarted the ability to drive the thing, he could sell and see a nice addition to his funds.

It made me start thinking its not a bad little strategy - not as a guarantee or major part of your pension planning, but a fun addition on the side. Obviously running costs and maintenance will eat into any profit along the way, but these are incurred whether this is a part of a future investment consideration or just a consequence of your hobby. Inflation is of course another issue, but this applies across many tangible asset classes.

So this leads me to the question of what would you buy as something you would genuinely take pleasure in owning whilst also thinking you might see a tidy profit keeping it for a decade or greater? I have my own thoughts and it might influence my next move so wondering what the PH audience would propose. Over to you folks.

Krikkit

27,228 posts

192 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
Shnozz said:
So this leads me to the question of what would you buy as something you would genuinely take pleasure in owning whilst also thinking you might see a tidy profit keeping it for a decade or greater? I have my own thoughts and it might influence my next move so wondering what the PH audience would propose. Over to you folks.
Manual Gallardo.

Fairly sensible running costs (relatively!), sonorous NA engine with 3 pedals, there's nothing like it coming in future.

Len Clifton

50 posts

1 month

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
I think there are better ways to gamble your future than putting money into an object that’ll almost certainly depreciate or at best return bugger after 20-30 years.

With electric cars the norm, anything vaguely interesting will already carry a premium, to be locked up somewhere as an investment.

Good example here: https://collectingcars.com/for-sale/2005-vauxhall-...

It’s 20 years old and worth roughly the same as it was back in 2005. Which with inflation, means it’s actually worth less. Still nice though.

Shnozz

Original Poster:

28,412 posts

282 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
Manual Gallardo.

Fairly sensible running costs (relatively!), sonorous NA engine with 3 pedals, there's nothing like it coming in future.
Very interesting first post given my thinking!

Puzzles

2,702 posts

122 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
I’d worry about the future value.

If I bought a car that was popular in my demographic, when I go to sell at retirement would the market still be there?

I’d quite like another E36 M3

jeremyc

25,220 posts

295 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
Shnozz said:
Krikkit said:
Manual Gallardo.

Fairly sensible running costs (relatively!), sonorous NA engine with 3 pedals, there's nothing like it coming in future.
Very interesting first post given my thinking!
thumbup You know it makes sense. wink

Shnozz

Original Poster:

28,412 posts

282 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
Len Clifton said:
I think there are better ways to gamble your future than putting money into an object that’ll almost certainly depreciate or at best return bugger after 20-30 years.
Which is why I sad a small element of pension planning rather than going all in.

Shnozz

Original Poster:

28,412 posts

282 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
jeremyc said:
Shnozz said:
Krikkit said:
Manual Gallardo.

Fairly sensible running costs (relatively!), sonorous NA engine with 3 pedals, there's nothing like it coming in future.
Very interesting first post given my thinking!
thumbup You know it makes sense. wink
ha ha ha. I have fond memories of that blast out in yours mate. I might keep my powder dry here for now and see what gets thrown in the ring to update later down the line..

Robertb

2,401 posts

249 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
R8 V8 manual coupe.
360 manual
550M
997 GTS manual

FTSE World Index tracker.

GR_TVR

737 posts

95 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
Restricting the budget to semi-sensible levels, I'd go for these 3, in order of likely to result in better returns:

Ferrari 458
Porsche 997 GT3 (missed the bottom of these)
Aston Martin V12 Vantage Manual

Pica-Pica

14,873 posts

95 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
Best to invest in a pension and get the tax relief.
Avoid US stocks at the moment - I got out of them in early February, I could foresee the slide.

Puzzles

2,702 posts

122 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
Pica-Pica said:
Best to invest in a pension and get the tax relief.
You most likely won’t have to pay CGT on a car.

Shnozz

Original Poster:

28,412 posts

282 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
And again, this does not constitute anything more than a minor proportion of a wider and more standard portfolio.

Or to look at it another way, this is simply a next toy car plan that, if I keep it a decade, would potentially coincide with me turning 57 - ergo retirement age. It got me thinking that something like a 570S would be a great car, but, as an example from below, a manual G would also be a great car, with the added bonus that potentially at draw down stage it would probs top up the pension pot more than a 570 in 10 years might..

Puzzles

2,702 posts

122 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
I don't think it is a bad idea, it could even be tax efficient, also you can sell the car whenever you like but the pension is locked in.

8IKERDAVE

2,493 posts

224 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
The concept would scare me a little. What if values plummet or you write it off? I understand there's a risk with any sort of investment but it wouldn't sit right with me purely as an investment.

Shnozz

Original Poster:

28,412 posts

282 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
Puzzles said:
I don't think it is a bad idea, it could even be tax efficient, also you can sell the car whenever you like but the pension is locked in.
Indeed. Or keep it into retirement if I didn't need the top up, or certainly not initially but perhaps later as drawdown depleted, and assuming my 57 year old limbs were supple enough to drive the thing.

ChrisH72

2,447 posts

63 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
Is retirement age 57 these days?

Buying a car as an investment really is a gamble now. With the demise of ICE, they could either become valuable collectors items or be completely worthless in years to come.

Probably a RWD sports car with a manual box and NA engine. But not an mx5 though, I have one of them and it will definitely not appreciate in value.

-Cappo-

20,071 posts

214 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
One person I know has a 355 which he held for it's future value, watched it climb into 6 figures and then descend again.

Someone else I know has just bought a Lamborghini Aventador LP 750-4 SV which is tucked away under a cover and apparently will only appreciate?

Quattr04.

395 posts

2 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
You can guarantee any limited edition 911 will go up in value, GT3 touring, S/T ducktail etc

Pica-Pica

14,873 posts

95 months

Wednesday 12th March
quotequote all
Puzzles said:
Pica-Pica said:
Best to invest in a pension and get the tax relief.
You most likely won’t have to pay CGT on a car.
Who said anything about CGT? I am talking about the 25% HMRC add as gross-up to your personal pension contributions, its too daft to ignore.