Black Circles "Quality Tyres"
Black Circles "Quality Tyres"
Author
Discussion

BuzzBravado

Original Poster:

2,947 posts

187 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
Those that have used Black Circles will see they offer an unnamed quality tyre, which is likely whatever they have an abundance of in the medium quality price point.

Does anyone know what sort of brands they tend to sell through this offering? For perspective an Avon ZV7 is £80, which i would be happy with, but the "quality tyre" is £55, and just wondered what that would likely be.

Haltamer

2,583 posts

96 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
I don't expect they'd be taking a loss on it, so probably the tyres they're offering for about ~£55

nikaiyo2

5,359 posts

211 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
They will be some make you have never heard of.

We got 2, about 6 months ago, for a focus pool car, I think they are branded Aceleration (with one c biggrin) For a 1L diesel Focus that spends most of its life in a car park they are fine... Not sure what they will be like long term or what they would be like on a car with any kind of power.

xjay1337

15,966 posts

134 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
BuzzBravado said:
Those that have used Black Circles will see they offer an unnamed quality tyre, which is likely whatever they have an abundance of in the medium quality price point.

Does anyone know what sort of brands they tend to sell through this offering? For perspective an Avon ZV7 is £80, which i would be happy with, but the "quality tyre" is £55, and just wondered what that would likely be.
They would he the worst of the worst.

Go with your Avon if you are happy with those.

If you have Costco card check out Michelin deals they had up to £100 off recently.

anonymous-user

70 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
i used asda tyres and bought the cheapest tyre going for my shed and actually they have been pretty good. Yes a bit skittish in wet but i just drive slower. In comparison to Cross climates there is minimal difference in normal british weather conditions, which i found were pretty st.

Rapid85

53 posts

71 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
Almost certainly ditch finders. They will just be budget tyres that they have lying around in stock. They don't commit to which brand it will be because they will use different budget tyres depending on stock levels.

swagmeister

382 posts

108 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
The term QUALITY differs from person to person and item to item.
if something is quality it conforms to requirements - some would say a Jaguar or a Mercedes is a quality car - some would say a Dacia Sandero is a quality car - it does everything they ask of it.
I have been driving 32 years and owner over 60 cars. If I need to buy new tyre I buy the cheapest possible. I buy all my cars 2nd hand so effectively (as stated on here in many threads) running on part worns.

Ive never ended up in a ditch, never killed anyone nor ever thought these tyres are rubbish, my braking distance is terrible or the sky may fall down.
If I drove a Ferrari or a race car I could see the point - for day to day commuting to work and going to the supermarket or visit family of a weekend driving through 30,40,50,60,70 mph zones - any tyre should be enough to cope.

Que the people coming up saying they always buy the top tyre as they value their lives and their kids lives and you will be glad of a better tyre in the even of an emergency stop blah blah blah. You pay your money to take your chance, and so far my cheap tyres work for me.

xjay1337

15,966 posts

134 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
swagmeister said:
The term QUALITY differs from person to person and item to item.
if something is quality it conforms to requirements - some would say a Jaguar or a Mercedes is a quality car - some would say a Dacia Sandero is a quality car - it does everything they ask of it.
I have been driving 32 years and owner over 60 cars. If I need to buy new tyre I buy the cheapest possible. I buy all my cars 2nd hand so effectively (as stated on here in many threads) running on part worns.

Ive never ended up in a ditch, never killed anyone nor ever thought these tyres are rubbish, my braking distance is terrible or the sky may fall down.
If I drove a Ferrari or a race car I could see the point - for day to day commuting to work and going to the supermarket or visit family of a weekend driving through 30,40,50,60,70 mph zones - any tyre should be enough to cope.

Que the people coming up saying they always buy the top tyre as they value their lives and their kids lives and you will be glad of a better tyre in the even of an emergency stop blah blah blah. You pay your money to take your chance, and so far my cheap tyres work for me.
Ah yes, the argument that you yourself have never had a problem so it's fine.

I don't understand why you'd buy the very cheapest tyres , as a motoring enthusiast (assumedly given you are on this site) surely you want some quality given it's the only thing connecting your car to the road.

Many of us buy the better tyres on the market because we appreciate that we need the grip also the extra feedback you get. Budget tyres always drive horribly, and you can tell almost immediately , especially in the wet, if the tyres are cheap. Given the statistics that often it can be 20-30% longer stopping distances in the wet, that is a quantifiable distance. If it was 5% then I'd say ah well, screw it buy the cheap ones.

You skinflint! smile

STe_rsv4

940 posts

114 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
swagmeister said:
The term QUALITY differs from person to person and item to item.
if something is quality it conforms to requirements - some would say a Jaguar or a Mercedes is a quality car - some would say a Dacia Sandero is a quality car - it does everything they ask of it.
I have been driving 32 years and owner over 60 cars. If I need to buy new tyre I buy the cheapest possible. I buy all my cars 2nd hand so effectively (as stated on here in many threads) running on part worns.

Ive never ended up in a ditch, never killed anyone nor ever thought these tyres are rubbish, my braking distance is terrible or the sky may fall down.
If I drove a Ferrari or a race car I could see the point - for day to day commuting to work and going to the supermarket or visit family of a weekend driving through 30,40,50,60,70 mph zones - any tyre should be enough to cope.

Que the people coming up saying they always buy the top tyre as they value their lives and their kids lives and you will be glad of a better tyre in the even of an emergency stop blah blah blah. You pay your money to take your chance, and so far my cheap tyres work for me.
This statement largely depends on driving style. If you drive like my dad does, then yes, cheap budget tyres are fine because he rarely drives and when he does, he drives slowly and never pushes on in his panda 100.
Me on the other hand, I often fit the best rubber I can as I'm not my dad and I like to push on often, and know that I'm giving myself the best chance of survival if things go wrong ( sudden braking / heavy rainfall etc.)

Pica-Pica

15,235 posts

100 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
When buying new tyres, I read several reviews, work out what suits my need (usually wet circle, and wet braking are tops) then order, often through Black Circles. I rarely buy a tyre brand I have not heard of.

sasquartch

109 posts

118 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
I've always found that the most expensive tyres work out the cheapest in the long run.

My old Galaxy had Michelin tyres that lasted 25k on the front, anecdotally other people got half that with cheap ditchfinders.

Often cheap tyres seem fine when new, but once they wear down a bit which they usually do quickly) then they become ditchfinders

The only time cheap tyres make sense is if you know you'll be getting rid of the car before they wear out



832ark

1,244 posts

172 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
swagmeister said:
The term QUALITY differs from person to person and item to item.
if something is quality it conforms to requirements - some would say a Jaguar or a Mercedes is a quality car - some would say a Dacia Sandero is a quality car - it does everything they ask of it.
I have been driving 32 years and owner over 60 cars. If I need to buy new tyre I buy the cheapest possible. I buy all my cars 2nd hand so effectively (as stated on here in many threads) running on part worns.

Ive never ended up in a ditch, never killed anyone nor ever thought these tyres are rubbish, my braking distance is terrible or the sky may fall down.
If I drove a Ferrari or a race car I could see the point - for day to day commuting to work and going to the supermarket or visit family of a weekend driving through 30,40,50,60,70 mph zones - any tyre should be enough to cope.

Que the people coming up saying they always buy the top tyre as they value their lives and their kids lives and you will be glad of a better tyre in the even of an emergency stop blah blah blah. You pay your money to take your chance, and so far my cheap tyres work for me.
I’d say that any decent driver should be able to tell the difference between a premium tyre and a ditchfinder in certain conditions such as wet braking. I have driven (non) performance cars back to back in such circumstances and the difference is night and day. Add in the fact that the performance differences are demonstrable and measurable under controlled conditions and I have to wonder why you’d choose a safety critical item that just about copes rather than something that does a good job. If you’re on the bones of your arse and it’s either that or nothing then fair enough but if it’s just to be tight then the mind boggles.

Coilspring

577 posts

79 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
Quite simply tyre choice comes down to , what car, who drives, how often, how is it driven, what budget?

The answer varies on every input to the above.

Personally I prefer to see budget tyres with tread on cars, rather than quality tyres run til they are bald.

I run 3 vehicles, and all 3 have different useages, and that affects the tyre choice.

Nobody can answer what the right tyre is for anybody else. Except that, if in doubt, go upwards in brand/name/price rather than down

Flumpo

4,024 posts

89 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
Nexen tyres from s korea normally.

Terzo123

4,570 posts

224 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
Flumpo said:
Nexen tyres from s korea normally.
Nexens are decent enough. Just fitted a couple of their 4 season range to my shed with the winter coming up.

Flumpo

4,024 posts

89 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
Terzo123 said:
Flumpo said:
Nexen tyres from s korea normally.
Nexens are decent enough. Just fitted a couple of their 4 season range to my shed with the winter coming up.
Black circles quality choice tends to be what they consider mid range but not quite Avon or Hancock. As someone else has said it’s what stock they are wanting to shift at that time.

bobtail4x4

4,031 posts

125 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
usually older tyres too

Flumpo

4,024 posts

89 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
832ark said:
swagmeister said:
The term QUALITY differs from person to person and item to item.
if something is quality it conforms to requirements - some would say a Jaguar or a Mercedes is a quality car - some would say a Dacia Sandero is a quality car - it does everything they ask of it.
I have been driving 32 years and owner over 60 cars. If I need to buy new tyre I buy the cheapest possible. I buy all my cars 2nd hand so effectively (as stated on here in many threads) running on part worns.

Ive never ended up in a ditch, never killed anyone nor ever thought these tyres are rubbish, my braking distance is terrible or the sky may fall down.
If I drove a Ferrari or a race car I could see the point - for day to day commuting to work and going to the supermarket or visit family of a weekend driving through 30,40,50,60,70 mph zones - any tyre should be enough to cope.

Que the people coming up saying they always buy the top tyre as they value their lives and their kids lives and you will be glad of a better tyre in the even of an emergency stop blah blah blah. You pay your money to take your chance, and so far my cheap tyres work for me.
I’d say that any decent driver should be able to tell the difference between a premium tyre and a ditchfinder in certain conditions such as wet braking. I have driven (non) performance cars back to back in such circumstances and the difference is night and day. Add in the fact that the performance differences are demonstrable and measurable under controlled conditions and I have to wonder why you’d choose a safety critical item that just about copes rather than something that does a good job. If you’re on the bones of your arse and it’s either that or nothing then fair enough but if it’s just to be tight then the mind boggles.
It depends how far you take that approach though. I’m willing to bet giving your kids non organic meat and veg is far more likely to have a real impact in their health than the chances of them dying in a car crash. Have you ever given your kids chips or a bacon sandwich or something g with sugar in?

In real terms that’s probably had a more realistic impact on your children’s health or cancer risk and death than driving in a car with nexen tyres.

Put the best tyres you can afford on your car, but let’s not be hysterical and claim a mid range tyre brand is somehow playing Russian roulette with your children.

BGarside

1,568 posts

153 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
Had a mixture of cheap tyres on a Seat Leon diesel I bought secondhand once, including 'Accelera Alpha' tyres on the front. Was like driving on banana skins, wheelspin in 3rd gear, sliding on tight bends in the wet at less than 20mph. Needless to say they quickly got tossed.

Now, driving a 24 year old RWD BMW with no traction aids and cr@p crash resistance compared to moderns I figure decent tyres give me a better chance of survival, in an emergency scenario when I need all the grip I can get, maybe just if someone runs out in front of the car. Life is unpredictable and idiots are everywhere....

As a cycle commuter grip is crucial and I'd never put cheapo tyres on my bikes. Decent tyres start at £20-30.

Can't understand people wanting to save a few quid putting cheap rubbish tyres on their car.

redguy

132 posts

95 months

Wednesday 11th September 2019
quotequote all
When I bought my Cooper SD it was fitted with Nexen tyres - albeit 2 variants - matching front and rear.

I'd never used them before - quick search had them as a mid-range - so, not to bad, I thought.....

I personally couldn't wait to get them off. Having driven other mid-rangers before (Avon, Kumho, etc.), I couldn't believe the difference. The slippery handling and wheel spin just seemed like a nightmare in the making.

ASAP, it was fitted with Michelin Pilot Sport 4's all round. Not cheap, but the car was transformed in an instant.

Not really much help, am I?!! smile