RE: F1 history in the making | PH Footnote
RE: F1 history in the making | PH Footnote
Saturday 11th December 2021

F1 history in the making | PH Footnote

The climax of the 2021 season has everyone talking. It's about time



This is it, folks. By the end of tomorrow. we'll know. Will it be Hamilton or Verstappen? And whatever your views on either driver - and my God, everyone has one - personally I think that we've all been winners this year, whoever happens to take the title. Think back over the last seven years. The Mercedes' stranglehold at the top of F1. The charge that the sport is boring, again, just like it was at the height of Schumacher's and Ferrari's domination between 2000 and 2004. How it needs a challenger on Lewis Hamilton's level, in a car that's good enough to win, to make it interesting again. Well, we've had that, haven't we?

Other than the epic fight between Hamilton and Rosberg in 2016, which also went down to the wire, the seven-time world champion hasn't really been challenged in any meaningful sense. And even during that fight with Rosberg, there was always the sense that this wasn't quite a battle of equals. Rosberg was a far better rival to Hamilton than most people expected, including me. I thought that, when Hamilton had bedded himself into the Mercedes team, he would break Rosberg, in much the same manner that he has broken Valtteri Bottas. That never happened, though. Rosberg took a reasonable share of the spoils, in terms of wins, podiums and poles, even beating Hamilton 11-7 in the qualifying head-to-head in 2014. But still Hamilton ended up taking the title in 2014 and 2015, as per the formbook.

In 2016, Rosberg raised his game again. So the story goes, he threw everything at it: employed a sports psychologist to strengthen his mind and even sidelined his family life in pursuit of the perfection required to beat his long-term nemesis. That's what is required to beat Lewis Hamilton. He can be beaten over one race, as even Bottas has showed. But when it comes to performing at his level over the course of a whole season, beating him consistently with equal machinery, few can do it. Even in Rosberg's all-out 2016 attempt, he still needed a Hamilton handicap - in the form more retirements - to get him across the line. And it by the end, it had taken so much out of him that, just five days later, he retired from the sport.



Coincidentally, as the acrimony between Hamilton and Rosberg was reaching fever pitch at 2016 Spanish Grand Prix - when the pair took each other out - that shone a light on what was coming. Max Verstappen's talent hadn't gone unnoticed, but many youngsters with promise have proved to be false dawns over the years. For that race Verstappen had been promoted from Torro Rosso to Red Bull, and when the two Mercedes' drivers put themselves in the gravel trap it laid a path for Verstappen to prove his resolve.

He had qualified fourth, behind his teammate, Daniel Ricciardo, and with the Mercedes' drivers out, the Red Bull pair were first and second. But Verstappen's two-stop strategy proved quicker than Ricciardo's three-stopper, so it was Verstappen who was leading in the final stages and being chased down by Kimi Räikkönen's Ferrari on fresher tyres. It would've been easy for a young driver, in his first race for a top-flight team, to crack and drop it. He didn't. He went on to become the youngest winner of a Formula One Grand Prix at the age of 18 years and 228 days. As he has proved over the course of this year, nothing seems to phase his still-young mind.

I remember thinking then that he was the real deal, but he confirmed it at the Brazilian Grand Prix later in the year. Again, Verstappen had qualified fourth, but in a heavily rain-affected race he made everyone else look silly, even though he didn't win. His various tyre changes dropped him down the order, plus he only just survived a spin that could so easily have ended his day; but his was a masterclass of wet-weather driving, to rival even Hamilton's 2008 British Grand Prix. He just drove around his competitors with seeming ease, getting creative with his lines and finding grip where the others couldn't. With just 15 laps remaining he was down in 16th but by the chequered flag he had risen to 3rd. Christian Horner called it "one of the best drives I've seen in Formula One." I happen to agree with him.



Of course, Hamilton has displayed equal genius over the years. That amazing 2008 British Grand Prix stands out, when, in the wet, he finished the race 68-seconds ahead of the rest of the field. Then there's the fact that he only just missed out on the title in his rookie year, driving alongside that other great, Fernando Alonso. And last year's Turkish Grand Prix, when he kept his intermediate tyres on for 50 laps, until they were basically slicks, and won by the race by 31 seconds. That prompted Sebastian Vettel to comment "It wasn't his race to win and he still won it; again he managed to pull something special out of that bag."

Over the ensuing years, the talk has been about seeing Hamilton and Verstappen going head-to-head, but the Red Bull was never quite quick enough. Until this year that is. Finally, we have been treated to the show we've craved, and it hasn't disappointed. There have been controversies, like Silverstone, when Hamilton took Verstappen out and was judged to be at fault. Or In Brazil, last month, when Verstappen 'got away' with forcing Hamilton off the track to keep his position. A tactic he used again at the last race, which was, perhaps, among the most controversial sporting event of the last decade.

That Saudi race had everything, with both drivers riding the very edge of their talents while also being accused of unsportsmanlike behaviour. Over the weekend, it kept the stewards kept busy to the point of distraction. It also proved to be awesome entertainment, but my abiding memory isn't the controversies, which are mere filler. It's the number of times this year that we've seen these two rise to the top like the cream always does, duelling it out at the front while leaving everyone else in their wake.



It's fair to say both drivers are polarising, and for different reasons. Max with his inventive attitude to the rules and Hamilton for his off-track lifestyle - mainly the fashion and the politics. Personally, I thought he looked ridiculous walking around the paddock in shorts and luminous-green boots this year, but I also thought his criticism of the human rights records of both Qatar and Saudi Arabia was considered and admirable.

Whichever side you take, there are strengths and weaknesses to discuss, but, together, no doubt these two have put on the greatest show on earth. It's a trope, but we are watching history in the making. This season will be talked about as one of the greatest, alongside Senna v Prost and the like. And I can't remember a season like it. That's why I am happy whoever wins. They are both exceptional. They are both deserving. Hamilton will become the greatest of all time, in terms of championships, or Verstappen will come of age and shrug the monkey of that first title off his back. And here's a thought: maybe that'll help him raise his game further? Imagine that. An improved Verstappen, dualling it out with the already-perfectly-honed Hamilton who's still hungry for his eighth. Maybe I am favouring a Verstappen win, after all.







Author
Discussion

JD2329

Original Poster:

513 posts

199 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
A proper title decider - between two drivers in different teams - has been long overdue.
It’s a rather damning indictment of the hybrid era that it’s taken eight seasons to get here - the 2022 regulations need to result in a simpler sport with better racing.

Liberty are clearly making the most of their investment but it’s been a long season to maintain interest.
Nonetheless, whoever wins on Sunday will be a worthy champion - let’s hope for a good, clean fight.

Stuart70

4,176 posts

214 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
Lewis, Lewis, LEWIS

I am not a fan of Verstappen as a person or as a racer.
It would be great to see LH get his eighth WDC tomorrow.

Oddly I think it would also bridge Merc into the GR era and the sport into the new regulations.

There would be a pleasing symmetry.

All very nice, but most likely destroyed by MV taking out LH in a lap one “incident”.

Driver Rider

608 posts

228 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
I wouldn’t say Hamilton got involved in “politics” more human rights issues.

The same way Rashford wasn’t political but simply got on involved in a humanitarian issue.

Bobtherallyfan

1,524 posts

109 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
Given the move to electrification F1 has become a dinosaur. Huge carbon footprint, no social conscience, full of contradictions.


Baddie

809 posts

248 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
Bobtherallyfan said:
Given the move to electrification F1 has become a dinosaur. Huge carbon footprint, no social conscience, full of contradictions.
Much of the carbon footprint comes from the transport around the world rather than running the cars.

As an illustration and, for a moment, disregarding testing/practice/qualifying, and assuming the 110 kg of fuel equates to, say, 130 litres…

20 cars in 22 races will burn 57,200 litres of fuel. Shock, horror, zut alors, what a waste?!

One Airbus A380 can hold 320,000 litres, more than 5 times what 20 F1 cars will burn over a season’s worth of race distances…. Then remember that Mercedes have improved the thermal efficiency of their power plant from 44% in 2014 to over 50% now, which is something that can filter to road cars in time, much like engine management did after the 80’s turbo era.

If we’re being objective, as opposed to political, the environmental gains from purely electric cars are not as clear cut as is often believed.

russy01

4,823 posts

212 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
Cheering on Hamilton here. A few reasons:

- he’s British and I’m proud to be British most the time.

- Max, whilst great, Doesn’t deserve it yet. I love the fact he pushes boundaries, but imo he often goes one step too far and shows a lack of maturity, experience and regard for safety.

I personally think he’ll do better in the long run if he loses this one to experience and comes back wiser.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
Bobtherallyfan said:
Given the move to electrification F1 has become a dinosaur. Huge carbon footprint, no social conscience, full of contradictions.
Yet you still support other carbon intense racing? scratchchinconfused

https://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&...


ETA I do agree with you on the point though. F1 should be replaced with a sexed up, money backed Formula E package.

Whilst the noise is lost and race format compromised, I'm sure a major investment and some imagination can make it more exciting whilst the battery tech catches up.

Edited by anonymous-user on Saturday 11th December 08:12

jason61c

5,978 posts

205 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
Go Max!

Torquey

1,961 posts

259 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
My prediction on this is that it will be won by some factor other than pure driver skill and Max's and Lewis' efforts wil be irrelevant.

A crash, slow pit stop or strategy.

spikyone

1,924 posts

131 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
russy01 said:
Cheering on Hamilton here. A few reasons:

- he’s British and I’m proud to be British most the time.

- Max, whilst great, Doesn’t deserve it yet. I love the fact he pushes boundaries, but imo he often goes one step too far and shows a lack of maturity, experience and regard for safety.

I personally think he’ll do better in the long run if he loses this one to experience and comes back wiser.
Pretty much nails my thoughts. Max has a lot of growing up to do. I'm not blaming him completely for the Silverstone crash but it's notable that he's been on the outside of Hamilton twice this season and they've crashed both times even though Hamilton has kept it on track. Whereas they've yet to crash with Hamilton on the outside despite Max going, in some cases, a long way off track. Max lost a big bag of points at Silverstone when he could've at least been more pragmatic, and might have beaten Lewis at Monza too.

Max is a very fast driver but needs better people around him. Toto has in the past kept Lewis in check, whereas in the eyes of Jos, Helmut, and Christian, Max can do no wrong. And right now in a tight title fight between Max and pretty much anyone else on the grid, you'd back Max to come off second best because he lacks that intelligence as a driver.

I'd like to see him mature to the point he can back up his speed with brains and a bit more class in the way he drives, so that we can see more of these close title battles in years to come. My money is already on Red Bull having the best car concept next year, as they so often do when the aero rules change, and he needs to be in a position to take advantage.

Edited by spikyone on Saturday 11th December 08:18

spaximus

4,365 posts

284 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
I would like to see Max win as it would set up next year better.

Hamilton is special we all know that and this year we have seen him see he is no longer the only one. This has forced some errors as Max wants to win and win at all costs.

Outside the PR Lewis and Max allegedly get on fine they both need each other and i hope this is decided on the day by the best driver on the day, not some legal challenge or some unfortunate accident.

It will be a hell of a race

Stuart70

4,176 posts

214 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
jason61c said:
Go Max!
Yeah, but not quite in the way you mean it smile.

Bobtherallyfan

1,524 posts

109 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
lord trumpton said:
Bobtherallyfan said:
Given the move to electrification F1 has become a dinosaur. Huge carbon footprint, no social conscience, full of contradictions.
Yet you still support other carbon intense racing? scratchchinconfused

https://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&...


ETA I do agree with you on the point though. F1 should be replaced with a sexed up, money backed Formula E package.

Whilst the noise is lost and race format compromised, I'm sure a major investment and some imagination can make it more exciting whilst the battery tech catches up.

Edited by lord trumpton on Saturday 11th December 08:12
A difference is Le Mans doesn’t pretend to have a social conscience…I can’t stand people like LH pontificating about saving this, or changing that, while in fact flying all over the world to attend a fashion show, hanging out with DJ stupidname or racing in countries with appalling human rights records.

PH User

22,154 posts

139 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
Bobtherallyfan said:
lord trumpton said:
Bobtherallyfan said:
Given the move to electrification F1 has become a dinosaur. Huge carbon footprint, no social conscience, full of contradictions.
Yet you still support other carbon intense racing? scratchchinconfused

https://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&...


ETA I do agree with you on the point though. F1 should be replaced with a sexed up, money backed Formula E package.

Whilst the noise is lost and race format compromised, I'm sure a major investment and some imagination can make it more exciting whilst the battery tech catches up.

Edited by lord trumpton on Saturday 11th December 08:12
A difference is Le Mans doesn’t pretend to have a social conscience…I can’t stand people like LH pontificating about saving this, or changing that, while in fact flying all over the world to attend a fashion show, hanging out with DJ stupidname or racing in countries with appalling human rights records.
Why come on an F1 thread if you hate it so much? I presume you don't watch F1, so none of the above actually matters.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
F1 may be the most boring form of motorsport. Its dogged by nothing but endless rules and frankly most races have one or two "incidents" then its a precession to the end.

Luckily in the UK we have a extremely good driver, if we didnt this would of been off our TV screens a long time ago.

As for formula E, its a replacement for this rubbish and is just as bad.

When i do watch i watch in the desperate hope it will improve but find myself bored and switching over which is a shame.

Best of luck to Mr Hamilton but i won't be watching, i will read about the rules infringement and who one the day after....

And for those who worry about the carbon footprint you need to go to north america where a large majority drive around in 6 litre diesels and dont give a crap, please go preach to them as they are the ones that need preaching to. !


PH User

22,154 posts

139 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
I'm not sure which is faster, an F1 car, or people's desire to tell us on an F1 thread how much they hate F1!

waynecyclist

14,884 posts

145 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
I am hoping Lewis can do it.

Max has had the faster car and should have this wrapped a few races ago but driving like an idiot has not helped him.

Scrump

23,949 posts

189 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
Bobtherallyfan said:
A difference is Le Mans doesn’t pretend to have a social conscience…I can’t stand people like LH pontificating about saving this, or changing that, while in fact flying all over the world to attend a fashion show, hanging out with DJ stupidname or racing in countries with appalling human rights records.
https://www.24h-lemans.com/en/csr

ddom

6,657 posts

79 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
Cheering for Max this weekend, but F1 is the winner. Despite a lot of whinging about driving standards the sport was dead, a boring procession fronted by drivers with zero personality. Max is a breath of fresh air and the rivalry has ignited a lot of interest with new and old fans alike.


gravitygravy

99 posts

67 months

Saturday 11th December 2021
quotequote all
Hoping that Lewis can win it, but fully expecting some kind of dodgy driving from Verstappen that bags him the title.

I've never understood why people dislike Lewis so much. Hugely talented and a genuinely decent bloke.