RE: 2024 Dacia Duster Journey | PH Fleet

RE: 2024 Dacia Duster Journey | PH Fleet

Monday 21st April

2024 Dacia Duster Journey | PH Fleet

Ben has swapped his RS3 for a Duster - has he lost the plot?


Nope, April Fool’s has passed. I really have sold my 340hp Audi RS3 and replaced it with a 150hp Dacia Duster. But I can explain. As much as I loved the RS3 for its epic 2.5-litre five-pot and the glorious sound it made, it was 13 years old, had clocked over 70k miles and I was haemorrhaging money on it.

Ironically nothing had actually gone wrong, yet I was spending a fortune on preventative and general maintenance. In the 18 months or so I had it, I serviced it twice at nearly a grand a pop (at specialist garages, too) and I was starting to lose sleep over what could go wrong and leave me with a huge bill. If it were a weekend car I wouldn’t mind so much, but for a daily I wanted something reliable that wouldn’t cost the earth to run. Trying to fund two project cars at the same time just wasn’t working.

Enter the Duster. It wasn’t long ago that I ran one as a long-termer and thoroughly enjoyed it, but at the time felt like I couldn’t give up on performance even for a daily. Now it's finally time to put my money where my mouth is. For not much more than what I sold the aging RS3 for, I’ve bought a one-year-old Duster, with 10k miles on the clock. And thanks to Dacia Zen, the remainder of a seven-year warranty remains intact, as long as I continue to service it at Dacia - which costs peanuts anyway.

Had I bought any other wafty mid-sized family SUV I wouldn’t have felt compelled to write about it, but given how popular Dacia is proving on PH, here you go - you’re welcome. In fact, the popularity has grown so much that you asked us for a dedicated Dacia forum, and our Duster Extreme SE review was one of the most read for the whole of 2022. And now with a couple of years under the collective belt, the facelifted Dusters are even more of a bargain than they were new.

Some say the Duster was named after the Dacia chairman’s niece; all I know is that it’s a very welcome addition to the fleet. The majority of my daily driving is on collapsing, pothole-riddled B roads, so the Duster is absolutely perfect for it and far more appropriate than the Audi it replaced. I love its Tonka toy looks, and I have such an obsession with green cars at the moment that there was only one colour I’d settle on. Now to see if I can get the seats re-trimmed in tan cloth…

While this Duster has only just recently gone off sale, it has come a very long way since the original Renault parts-bin special, and the newest model has moved the game on even further, while maintaining a very affordable price. While I’m yet to drive the Duster that has replaced this one, the starting price has only gone up around 10 per cent, at £19,380. With the cheapest Nissan Qashqai from £30,615, it’s plain to see how much of a bargain it still is in 2025.

BP73 YWJ is exactly the same spec as my previous long-termer - a top spec Journey (ignoring the special edition Extreme), albeit in a different colour. Naturally I wanted the most power on offer, so opted for the petrol-powered TCe 150 Auto 4x2. But it’s still no overweight SUV, tipping the scales at 1,263kg, and it feels light on its feet as a result.

The boosted 1,332cc four-cylinder engine sends all 150hp to the front wheels (4WD was only available on the diesel, sadly) to launch you to 62mph in under 10 seconds. The six-speed automatic gearbox isn’t the sharpest, though nor would you expect it to be at this price point; it’s perfectly adequate for the job at hand and still my preference over the manual for a daily.

It has all the luxuries I need at this price point and none that I don’t. An 8.0-inch screen with Apple CarPlay, parking sensors with four Multiview cameras, heated seats, keyless entry, cruise control and proper knurled knobs that you turn for the climate control rather than being buried in a screen. Lovely.

I’ve already racked up 3,000 miles since picking it up in December, and it’s proving to be the perfect Sunday Service wagon and stablemate to my Renaultsport Megane 275 Trophy. And to be honest, as much as I enjoyed driving the RS3 at the time, I don’t miss it one bit.


FACT SHEET

Car: 2024 Dacia Duster Journey TCe 150 Auto 4x2 EDC
Run by: Ben Lowden
On fleet since: December 2024
Mileage: 13,546
Last month at a glance: RS3 out, Duster in - and Ben couldn't be happier

Author
Discussion

fantheman80

Original Poster:

1,942 posts

63 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
Good luck to you and I know you’ve got the Megane for the weekends, but a newer, larger one car do it all hot hatch is where i would and did put my money, even boring drives in the week can have flashes of excitement

Edited by fantheman80 on Monday 21st April 07:06

ChocolateFrog

31,496 posts

187 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
Nice write up. I can't prize mine out of my OH's hands despite it costing her atleast 6x as much to run as when she's using the 400hp EV.

Actually thinking about it I pay the electric bill and she still prefers the mighty Duster hehe

ChocolateFrog

31,496 posts

187 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
Maybe you'll get special treatment with your reach but I wouldn't pay £10 for the warranty.

GreatScott2016

1,838 posts

102 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
"And to be honest, as much as I enjoyed driving the RS3 at the time, I don’t miss it one bit". I find that hard to believe but each to his own. What surprised me more though was the servicing costs yikes Anyway, enjoy the new car, ticks lots of boxes that one smile

Edited by GreatScott2016 on Monday 21st April 08:09

Huzzah

28,001 posts

197 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
ChocolateFrog said:
Maybe you'll get special treatment with your reach but I wouldn't pay £10 for the warranty.
Yes, I was actually quite pleased once the warranty had expired
,

Jon_S_Rally

3,931 posts

102 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
I give it six months max laugh

They're decent cars, but it seems like you have a healthy appetite for performance stuff, so I'm just not sure I can see it lasting long.

Unwize

106 posts

111 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
Like the poster above I am surprised a service at an independent was almost £1000 for the RS3.

Tindersticks

2,698 posts

14 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
"I don’t miss it one bit."

You will.

Been there, done it. Thought the same for about a month then realised I was talking absolute bks.

Jte3397

33 posts

110 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
Unwize said:
Like the poster above I am surprised a service at an independent was almost £1000 for the RS3.
Sadly I'm not. Not a RS3 but a Cupra 280 however whenever it goes in for a service, it invariably needs something else and I rarely get a bill below £600-700 and that's at a indy specialist. These VAG cars cost as they get older.

spikyone

1,728 posts

114 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
Article said:
It has all the luxuries I need at this price point and none that I don’t. An 8.0-inch screen with Apple CarPlay, parking sensors with four Multiview cameras, heated seats, keyless entry, cruise control and proper knurled knobs that you turn for the climate control
A timely reminder after the Cayman GT4 buyer's guide over the weekend that Porsche charging extra for most of those on a car costing £80k is a monumental piss-take...

As with others I wonder how long the love affair with 150bhp will last, but the Duster is a funky little thing so hopefully it has enough character to overcome the lack of performance. Just a shame it doesn't have a manual 'box!

GRM944

14 posts

72 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
I will go against the grain here and say that this is a brilliant move and exactly what I would do (and did).

If you are lucky enough to have one or more "weekend toys" then there is a lot of pleasure to be had from a simple, unpretentious everyday car.
I had a succession of slightly interesting dailies - Fiesta Zetec S, Cooper SD, and a silly X350 XJ6 - but moved on to a plain Skoda Octavia Estate, not even a VRS, just a 1.5 TSI manual.

The key concept for me is that if you use a performance car as a daily, how often will you use it as a performance car? For me, it was about 5% of the time, yet I was paying for the running costs on 100% of the miles.

It's been cheap as chips to buy, totally reliable despite more than 130k on the clock and brilliantly useful for moving people and stuff.
Now I've had it, I wouldn't be without it, and I don't miss the performance and overtaking power in daily driving whatsoever. Instead, it's just lovely to have something that flies under the radar, is easy to own, comfortable, and after the Jag - just works.

In this case, I think the Duster fulfills a similar brief. Not quite for me being a 2wd SUV but I get why so many people like them and buy them.
The RS3 is fun, but saving the cash and spending it on an even more special weekend toy gets my vote every time.

Konan

2,068 posts

160 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
Article said:
As much as I loved the RS3 for its epic 2.5-litre five-pot and the glorious sound it made, it was 13 years old, had clocked over 70k miles and I was haemorrhaging money on it.
I've recently been mulling over the idea of chopping in the Legacy I use on the regular and my JZX tinker car and just running a 3.0TFSi S4 estate. It's a tad bland, but has just enough about it to box tick daily duties and leave me with some garage space / budget to knock something up for some track day trips.

But my word do I get a bad feeling about reliability and running costs - or even how damn awkward basic repairs and servicing look to be on the things.

I think the fact that one had 'Recent £12K work done!' as a plus point on the sale blurb is etched into my head now wink

S600BSB

6,529 posts

120 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
Makes a great budget two car garage with an MX-5.

Mackofthejungle

1,162 posts

209 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
I went into buy a 2 year old SE just a few months ago. Loved the way it looked, thought it drove like a pile of ste. Awful gearbox, couldn't get over how cheap it felt. Horrid throttle and clutch relationship, a-la Renault - no feel or sense of what you're doing. And it sounded hollow and boxy to sit in.

It's cheap, but it's not better value than anything else on the market. It's just cheap. Spend the two grand more to get something that's enjoyable.

ThingsBehindTheSun

1,972 posts

45 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
Mackofthejungle said:
It's cheap, but it's not better value than anything else on the market. It's just cheap. Spend the two grand more to get something that's enjoyable.
If I wanted something cheap, comfortable and reliable I would rather just get a Kia or Hyundai than a Dacia. The new prices are now crazy and I would much rather get a year or two year old car from a better brand.

The Pistonsdead

5,159 posts

221 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
GRM944 said:
I will go against the grain here and say that this is a brilliant move and exactly what I would do (and did).

If you are lucky enough to have one or more "weekend toys" then there is a lot of pleasure to be had from a simple, unpretentious everyday car.
I had a succession of slightly interesting dailies - Fiesta Zetec S, Cooper SD, and a silly X350 XJ6 - but moved on to a plain Skoda Octavia Estate, not even a VRS, just a 1.5 TSI manual.

The key concept for me is that if you use a performance car as a daily, how often will you use it as a performance car? For me, it was about 5% of the time, yet I was paying for the running costs on 100% of the miles.

It's been cheap as chips to buy, totally reliable despite more than 130k on the clock and brilliantly useful for moving people and stuff.
Now I've had it, I wouldn't be without it, and I don't miss the performance and overtaking power in daily driving whatsoever. Instead, it's just lovely to have something that flies under the radar, is easy to own, comfortable, and after the Jag - just works.

In this case, I think the Duster fulfills a similar brief. Not quite for me being a 2wd SUV but I get why so many people like them and buy them.
The RS3 is fun, but saving the cash and spending it on an even more special weekend toy gets my vote every time.
100% this thumbup

cerb4.5lee

36,776 posts

194 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
Tindersticks said:
"I don’t miss it one bit."

You will.

Been there, done it. Thought the same for about a month then realised I was talking absolute bks.
We're all different of course, but I was gutted quite quickly when I swapped the E53 X5 4.8iS for the E61 520d as well. I did it for money saving reasons, and there isn't anything wrong with that in principle for sure, but the reality felt quite different though, and I missed the V8 X5 loads in the end.

croyde

24,699 posts

244 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
Thought my Duster with the dinky little 1.0 3cyl 100bhp engine was zippy enough as long as you stirred the gears.

With an extra 50 horses, does it need upgraded brakes biggrin

Please say what it cost?

86wasagoodyear

709 posts

110 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
The Pistonsdead said:
GRM944 said:
I will go against the grain here and say that this is a brilliant move and exactly what I would do (and did).

If you are lucky enough to have one or more "weekend toys" then there is a lot of pleasure to be had from a simple, unpretentious everyday car.
I had a succession of slightly interesting dailies - Fiesta Zetec S, Cooper SD, and a silly X350 XJ6 - but moved on to a plain Skoda Octavia Estate, not even a VRS, just a 1.5 TSI manual.

The key concept for me is that if you use a performance car as a daily, how often will you use it as a performance car? For me, it was about 5% of the time, yet I was paying for the running costs on 100% of the miles.

It's been cheap as chips to buy, totally reliable despite more than 130k on the clock and brilliantly useful for moving people and stuff.
Now I've had it, I wouldn't be without it, and I don't miss the performance and overtaking power in daily driving whatsoever. Instead, it's just lovely to have something that flies under the radar, is easy to own, comfortable, and after the Jag - just works.

In this case, I think the Duster fulfills a similar brief. Not quite for me being a 2wd SUV but I get why so many people like them and buy them.
The RS3 is fun, but saving the cash and spending it on an even more special weekend toy gets my vote every time.
100% this thumbup
Me too. I daily a Mazda 3 2.2d that does a fair few miles, mostly on dual carriageways, and have a 205 1.3 Rallye that I use as much as reasonably possible in the drier half of the year. Works for me as a 2-car combo in a similar sensible/not-quite-so-sensible way.

ChocolateFrog

31,496 posts

187 months

Monday 21st April
quotequote all
GreatScott2016 said:
"And to be honest, as much as I enjoyed driving the RS3 at the time, I don’t miss it one bit". I find that hard to believe but each to his own. What surprised me more though was the servicing costs yikes Anyway, enjoy the new car, ticks lots of boxes that one smile

Edited by GreatScott2016 on Monday 21st April 08:09
Why? They seem like the automotive equivalent of a dishwasher in the fast car world. Literally the least imaginative fast ICE car you can buy. Suppose it does atleast still have a 5cyl.