the M235i simply don't have the damping to cope. An M4, meanwhile, would be well out of its comfort zone and unable to put its considerable power advantage to any use whatsoever, beyond a widening of the eyes and whitening of the knuckles. In the M2 there's not a moment's hesitation. Keep it pinned. Grin like an idiot. Repeat to fade.
How does it do this? Simply, because it appears to have been built by and for people who really, really enjoy driving, sod the numbers on the spec sheet. The money invested in hot-rodding the M235i wasn't lavished on the engine. It didn't go on the interior. It didn't go on slavishly benchmarking acceleration times against rivals and making sure the gearing showed the car in its best light in magazine figuring or lap times. It went on nicking the good stuff in the M parts store like the M4's wide track forged aluminium suspension bits. And then binning the electronic gimmickry that makes its big brother so difficult to read.
This rather feels like the kind of car we thought people didn't make any more.
The M2 succeeds where many others fail because it's been tuned to let you enjoy its performance. Not view it as some abstract beyond the realms of what traffic law, social responsibility or simply your own talent permit.
As we discovered on the US launch event the N55 engine is gruff and businesslike but has enough six-cylinder character to stand apart from the four-cylinder crowd. It also incorporates a few upgrades from the 'proper' M division S55 to set it apart from other applications. The single, twin-scroll turbo means a lazier initial throttle response than the more angry and immediate twin-turbo set-up in the M4. But the fact it drives through the same rear axle and Active M Differential reveals the advantage this brings in terms of traction. It's far easier to balance the initial power delivery than the M4, making DSC off progress on slippery surfaces much less anxious.
the recent rant on just this issue but it seems a little daft that you can't choose an auto blipping opt-out without also forgoing your safety nets. Well, it would be if the M2 wasn't such a hoot to slide around and manhandle without electronic interference. This is not just your typical motoring hack hubris either; the M2 isn't communicative in the way cars of 20 years ago might have been but by modern standards it's remarkably open about its intentions.
Wiggle it, just a little bit
The mellower throttle and nicely matched spring and damper rates are very much on your side in this. Keep your foot in over the bumps and you might get a murmur of movement as the wheels momentarily lose their connection to the road. But the passive dampers are much quicker to settle than BMW's usual adaptive equivalents and traction is restored quickly. What would have been a tank slapper in an M4 is little more than a pleasing wriggle through the wrists, with no need to back out of the throttle. This is a good thing!
The gearing and power delivery make sense for fast road pace too. Flicking up and down between third and fourth is plenty for most corners, the engine having sufficient grunt to haul from low revs and make the cross-gate shift down into second unnecessary, leaving you an easy back and forth shift for entertaining cross-country progress. Are you listening Porsche?
Of course the big question will be between the manual and the £2,645 M DCT auto. In comparing M235i to M2 this is a bigger difference, the dual-clutch down a ratio on the eight-speed auto but far snappier in its shift when in Sport Plus mode. On the M4 M DCT seems to complete the package, apparently reflected in a take-up beyond 90 per cent. As it stands BMW reckons it'll be 70 per cent for M2, though the UK product manager admits they are anticipating a slight swing back to manual given initial reviews and the proportionally larger premium.
The paddles certainly encourage a harder, faster, stand-it-on-its-nose driving style. But given the rest of the car is about feedback and fun over outright pace the manual seems the more appropriate to its spirit and gets our vote. And if that contradicts the view the M4 is better with M DCT it underlines the differences in their character.
At lower speeds the initial pedal bite of the M4-donated steel brakes can seem a little fierce, unsettling the balance if you're not careful. In the way of these things it makes more sense as the speeds rise, offering more to lean against than M cars of old. With real heat in them things get a little more vocal but the pedal remains resolute; whether this remains so on track is something we'll be exploring soon.
Engine: 3.0-litre turbocharged straight six
Transmission: 6-speed manual/7-speed DCT, rear-wheel drive
Power (hp): 370@6,500rpm
Torque (lb ft): 343@1,400-4,750rpm
0-62mph: 4.5sec (4.3sec)
Top speed: 155mph (limited)
Weight: 1,570 kg (EU unladen)
MPG: 33.2 (35.8)
CO2: 199g/km (185g/km)
Price: £44,070 (£46,715)
Figures in brackets for DCT gearbox