Driven: Mercedes CLS

During its development, the original Mercedes CLS was known to its development team as the 'Jag fighter', a car that was to take-on the sleek lines and cosy feel that Jaguar had left behind with its (then) increasingly boxy XJ series. In the process, Mercedes effectively created a whole new niche - the four-door coupe.

The original CLS had the segment pretty much to itself, with Merc managing to flog 170,000 of them in six years. But things will not be so easy for the new CLS, which steps into a class now occupied by such varied competition as the Audi A5 Sportback, a sleekified Jaguar range (both XF and XJ), the soon-to-be-launched Audi A7, the BMW concept granturismo thingy and, at the top end, the Porsche Panamera.

Visually, Mercedes hasn't played about too much with the CLS formula - it's still got a distinctive snout, a curved, low roofline and a tapering boot. What has changed are the details.

The nose now apes the thrusting grille of the SLS supercar, the side profile has sprouted some new crease lines and a muscular haunch over the rear wheel, and the rear lights have gone all sparkly and LED. The front lights are also now full LED jobs, a world first for Merc that uses a total of 71 LEDs to create a distinctive and effective set of lamps.

Inside, the wraparound cosiness that so distinguished the previous car has been diminished a little in favour of a more conventionally Mercedes interior. It's still much warmer than, say, the cabin of an E-class or C-class, but some of the unique character of the original has disappeared.

There's no faulting the build quality, however. Mercedes has been working hard of late to regain its reputation for cars that are hewn rather than built, and the CLS is another move in the right direction.

Underneath the bonnet there will eventually be a choice of four engines, two diesel and two petrol. The 262bhp, 455lb ft 350 CDI will be available from launch, as will the 302bhp petrol-powered 350 CGI. The 201bhp 250CDI (the first four-cylinder engine to feature in a CLS) will join the ranks a few months after the rest go on sale in March 2011, but the key engine (at least from a PH perspective) is the all-new motor in the range-topping CLS 500.

It might account for a tiny proportion of of CLS sales (you can expect the 350 CDI to account for around 90 per cent of CLS engines, if history is anything to go by), and it will eventually be superseded at the head of the range by the all-but-inevitable AMG version, but the 500 is nevertheless an important car.

This is because it drops the fine but venerable 5461cc naturally aspirated V8 in favour of an all-new 4.6-litre V8 with twin turbos. In the process, it jumps from 382bhp to 402bhp, and from 391lb ft of torque to a seriously healthy 442lb ft, all of which is available from just 1800rpm. It's all very impressive, and Mercedes even claims a provisional 31.3mpg from its combined-cycle run. (We didn't get anywhere near that, but this may have had more to do with the twisty Tuscan hill route of our test drive than any over-egging of fuel consumption puddings on the part of Mercedes.)

The new engine's on-road performance is also as fine as its on-paper stats. It pulls cleanly and vigorously from low-down in the rev range, is eager to rev should you ask it to, and still sounds like a proper Mercedes V8, albeit now accompanied by the Darth Vader whoosh of the two turbos.

The only thing that let the drivetrain down on our test car was Mercedes' 7G-tronic S gearbox, which seemed often to hunt unnecessarily for ratios - and then provide you with the wrong one. It was also often reluctant to swap ratios when commanded to by a flick of the wheel-mounted paddle shift.

But this is a gripe that should be wiped away by UK models - which all get the Sporting pack as standard. This means a different gearbox set-up with three modes rather than two and, crucially, a much more effective manual mode. We tried this gearbox in both the 350 diesel and 350 petrol models, and it was far less confused during excited twisty-road driving - and there's no reason why the same shouldn't be the case in the CLS 500.

The chassis is based broadly on the E-class, but has wider tracks front and rear, and an entirely new front suspension system designed specifically to cope with the car's 19in alloys. Another difference is an all-new electric power steering set-up, which sounds ominous - these systems have traditionally delivered less impressive feel than hydraulic ones - but actually works quite well.

Don't go in expecting Elise-standard feedback, but the system is well weighted, consistent and accurate - and there's an immediacy to its responses around the straight-ahead position that is quite impressive for a car that must have been designed to track straight and true at 155mph on the autobahn.

Mercedes' brave decision to set the launch up on the windy and tight mountain roads around the Futa pass - part of the Mille Miglia course - could be seen as a foolish one for a large executive saloon (sorry, coupe), but the CLS performs quite well.

True, it feels rather large for such roads, but the brakes remain unfazed even after a strenuous downhill workout, and the fact that it remains the same weight as its predecessor despite a growth in dimensions (aluminium doors that save 24kg are a big part of that) afford the CLS an agility consistent with the term 'coupe'.

Mercedes might not have the four-door coupe game to itself anymore, but the CLS is an enjoyable, accomplished car and deserves to be able to carve itself out a sizeable market among its various and varied rivals. Now all we need is the AMG version...


P.H. O'meter

Join the PH rating wars with your marks out of 10 for the article (Your ratings will be shown in your profile if you have one!)

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
Rate this article

Comments (41) Join the discussion on the forum

  • Wolfsbait 14 Oct 2010

    "The front lights are also now full LED jobs, a world first for Merc that uses a total of 71 LEDs to create a distinctive and effective set of lamps."

    I thought the V10 R8 was first to have full LED headlights??

    Edited by Wolfsbait on Thursday 14th October 11:54

  • Garlick 14 Oct 2010

    For Mercedes, not the world smile

  • porcupineprince 14 Oct 2010

    Wolfsbait said:
    The front lights are also now full LED jobs, a world first for Merc that uses a total of 71 LEDs to create a distinctive and effective set of lamps.

    I thought the V10 R8 was first to have full LED headlights??
    World first for Merc...

    Anyway, its got bloody ugly! The previous shape was very distinctive, this one has a 7 series front!

  • fredd1e 14 Oct 2010

    1st version looked classy, this one looks trashy.

  • Jonboy_t 14 Oct 2010

    I actually quite like it boxedin

    I'ts got something of the S-Class about it, and I've been a fan of them for ages too boxedin

View all comments in the forums Make a comment