On paper, this Polo GTI should mark the step change, and it will need to be good in what looks like becoming a fiercely competitive B-segment hot hatch market. The big news is that it's based on the VW MQB platform (specifically MQB-AO), which feels like it might provide the basis for a new leisure centre soon given the modular kit's prevalence in new cars. Still, it has underpinned stuff like the Leon Cupra and the Golf GTI, so there are certainly worse places from which to start when building a hot hatch.
It uses their engine too, the perennial EA888 2.0-litre turbo here installed with 200hp. Which by our reckoning now means it's been offered with 200, 220, 230, 245, 265, 280, 290, 300 and 310 horsepower via assorted VW subsidiaries. But who's counting? A six-speed manual is on the way to be standard fitment (the test cars are DSG), there are adjustable dampers on the options list and VW promises a Polo that's a "compact sports car"...
I'd also wager that the Polo ought to look a tad more exciting, as even on the optional 18-inch wheels it can appear a bit frumpy from some angles. Fortunately, from the moment you get in a Polo GTI things start to look a lot brighter. And not just because of the sunroof.
Yes, new VW product in 'pleasant interior' shock. It really is something special though, combining nice materials and minimalist style with genuine technical intrigue (this is the first use of the Active Info Display) and a great driving position. You can have the red slab in grey too, fear not. Not only does the Polo's cabin feel about as good as this class currently can be, it's remarkably good for something that's expected to cost £20K.
Where things change, however, is at the race track at the end of the motorway. Because, finally, this feels like being the Polo GTI you might take out for a drive - or indeed to a track day - because you really, really want to. The Mallorca circuit is hardly the world's most demanding (they race karts there, which should give you some idea of scale) and the car is not flawless, but there's an awful lot to like about the GTI on track.
It's balanced, that's the key. This is a front-wheel drive car that feels to be working its contact patches equally, not collapsing into terminal understeer or spiking into oversteer when pushed. There's an argument to say that sounds prescriptive; it's not, because you as the driver have an influence on what the car is doing. Attitude on entry can be adjusted subtly yet satisfyingly (and precisely) with a touch of the brakes or a lift of the throttle, and the car feels willing and amenable to your demand. In their firmer setting, the Sport Select dampers - not VW's DCC system, but rather conventional dampers that have two compression/rebound settings controlled by the driver and activated by valves in the unit - offer great control and composure over bumps. It's cohesive, neutral and fluid, not challenging to drive yet enjoyable to try and get the most from.
the Golf Clubsport S and then razzed it around the Nordschleife in 7:47; they know a thing or two about front-wheel drive road and race cars, basically. And while the Polo isn't a CS on the cheap, that same feeling of engineering nous and chassis expertise is present. From a standard car the GTI has had a lot of work put into each axle, including a completely overhauled rear torsion beam, and it really feels to have paid dividends.
Which make its drawbacks all the more frustrating. While traction is fine, and the brake nibbling systems do a good job, there's little doubt that the Polo would be improved by the fitment of VW's VAQ system, which mimics very effectively the work of a limited-slip diff. Nobody likes a one-tyre fire out of hairpins now, do they? And nobody likes a dual-clutch gearbox that won't change down when you want it to but will change up when you'd rather it didn't (though you can at least hold on and opt for the manual in that regard). Fingers crossed for a Performance Pack with that VAQ at some point soon.
a Fiesta ST and not as focused as a Peugeot Sport 208 yet willing, eager and agile enough to entertain. There's sufficient involvement and adjustability at realistic speeds to make it feel like a properly driver-focused hot hatch, rather than simply a faster Polo - a marginal semantic difference, yes, but one that has tangible influence on the road.
How to sum it up? Put simply, where it before seemed like the Polo was a distant relative of the Golf GTI, it now feels like a much closer descendent. There's the same quality and dynamic finesse we've become familiar with in the larger car since 2005, concentrated and honed in a smaller package - it's the predictably very good Polo GTI we've expected for a while but never really had. Those after the final few per cent dynamically will still be better served elsewhere; for those after the most accomplished hot hatch in the segment, it's hard to imagine even a year like 2018 producing something to surpass the Polo
SPECIFICATION - VOLKSWAGEN POLO GTI
Engine: 1,984cc, 4-cyl turbocharged
Transmission: 6-speed dual-clutch automatic, front-wheel drive
Power (hp): 200@4,400-6,000rpm
Torque (lb ft): 236@1,500-4,400rpm
Top speed: 147mph
Weight: 1,355kg (EU with 75kg driver)
Price: £19,995 (manual)